10 Best Cotton Mattress Covers 2025 in the United States

The SafeRest 100% Waterproof Queen Size Mattress Protector is a solid choice for those looking to safeguard their mattress from fluids, urine, perspiration, and potential stains. The material quality is commendable, being made of cotton, which offers comfort and breathability. Its fitted design with stretchable pockets ensures a snug fit for queen-sized mattresses, preventing movement or bunching during sleep.

The waterproof feature is a significant strength, providing peace of mind against spills and accidents, making it especially useful for homes with children or pets. Additionally, its hypoallergenic properties are beneficial for those with allergies, as it protects against unwanted creatures that could trigger allergic reactions. The ease of cleaning is another advantage, as the mattress cover is machine washable on cold and can be tumble dried, simplifying maintenance.

Given its design and functionality, this mattress cover effectively meets the needs of those seeking protection, comfort, and easy upkeep for their bedding. It is well-suited for first homes, new apartments, and Airbnb hosts who want to ensure their mattresses remain in pristine condition.

The EASELAND Queen Size Mattress Pad is designed to enhance the comfort of your mattress with its 300 thread count cotton surface and down alternative fillings. This makes it soft and skin-friendly, allowing it to absorb sweat and remain breathable. The deep pocket design stretches up to 21 inches, ensuring a snug fit that stays in place even with movement, which is quite convenient for restless sleepers.

This mattress pad is machine washable, which adds to the ease of maintenance, and drying it under the sun can help keep it fluffy and fresh. However, it does not offer waterproof protection, which might be a drawback if you're looking for a cover that can guard against spills or accidents.

Additionally, while it is hypoallergenic to some extent due to the materials used, it may not provide full protection for those with severe allergies. This mattress pad is a comfortable and fitting option, but you might want to consider your specific needs regarding waterproofing and hypoallergenic properties before purchasing.

The SOPAT Extra Thick Mattress Topper is made from high-quality 400 thread count cotton, which offers a comfortable and breathable sleep surface. The topper features a unique Double Border Pillow Top Construction, providing extra support and softness with 50% more filling than typical pads, making it particularly suitable for those who need additional comfort and support during sleep.

The soft and breathable fill mimics the feel of authentic goose down without the associated issues of feathers poking through, enhancing the quality of sleep. The topper's 21-inch deep pockets with an elastic skirt ensure a snug fit on mattresses up to 21 inches thick, preventing any slipping or movement during the night. It’s noteworthy for its ease of cleaning, being machine washable, though it comes vacuum-packed and may require tumbling on low heat to regain its full loft.

However, it lacks significant waterproofing, only protecting against minor spills, which might be a drawback for households with kids or pets. While it has hypoallergenic properties and prevents back ache, these features may not fully compensate for its limited water resistance. Given its features, this mattress topper is suitable for those seeking enhanced comfort and support from their bedding, especially in households without significant concerns about spills or allergies.