10 Best Cotton Mattress Covers 2025 in the United States

The SafeRest 100% Waterproof Queen Size Mattress Protector is a solid choice for those looking to safeguard their mattress from fluids, urine, perspiration, and potential stains. The material quality is commendable, being made of cotton, which offers comfort and breathability. Its fitted design with stretchable pockets ensures a snug fit for queen-sized mattresses, preventing movement or bunching during sleep.

The waterproof feature is a significant strength, providing peace of mind against spills and accidents, making it especially useful for homes with children or pets. Additionally, its hypoallergenic properties are beneficial for those with allergies, as it protects against unwanted creatures that could trigger allergic reactions. The ease of cleaning is another advantage, as the mattress cover is machine washable on cold and can be tumble dried, simplifying maintenance.

Given its design and functionality, this mattress cover effectively meets the needs of those seeking protection, comfort, and easy upkeep for their bedding. It is well-suited for first homes, new apartments, and Airbnb hosts who want to ensure their mattresses remain in pristine condition.

The Utopia Bedding Queen 2 Pack Quilted Mattress Pads are made from polyester microfiber, not cotton, which means they feel soft and breathable but won’t have the natural feel of cotton. With a thread count of 150, the fabric is moderately dense, offering reasonable durability without being heavy. These pads fit mattresses up to 16 inches deep, making them suitable for most queen-sized beds with thick mattresses. They are not waterproof, so they won't protect against spills or liquids—if you need waterproofing, you'll want to buy a separate cover. The pads are hypoallergenic to an extent due to the polyester material, which can resist some allergens better than cotton but might not be ideal for those with sensitive skin.

Cleaning is straightforward since these pads are machine washable and can be tumble dried on low heat, making maintenance easy. The quilted fiberfill adds a soft, cushioned layer for extra comfort, and the elastic edges keep the pad securely in place during the night. This product is a solid choice if you want a soft, affordable mattress pad with a good fit and comfort but do not require waterproofing or pure cotton material.

The Utopia Bedding Waterproof Mattress Protector for Super Queen mattresses provides a snug and secure fit with deep fitted pockets and an all-around elastic band, suitable for mattresses up to 17 inches thick. It features a soft, breathable terry surface made of polyester with a 200 thread count, delivering comfort while protecting your mattress.

This protector includes a waterproof TPU backing that effectively blocks liquids, keeping your mattress clean and safe from spills or accidents. It is machine washable on a gentle cycle and can be tumble dried on low, though ironing and bleach are not recommended.

Polyester offers durability and ease of maintenance. The mattress protector is an excellent choice for reliable waterproof protection combined with a comfortable, fitted design and simple care, especially for those with a Super Queen size mattress who want to safeguard it from spills and allergens.