We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

10 Best Fall Cookie Cutters 2025 in the United States

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

headphones-stars

Our Top Picks

#1

Winner

Scalloped Edge Flower Cookie Cutter 3.75" Made in USA by Ann Clark

Rating
9.9
Chosen by1,341
Material
Size

Most important from
918 reviews

Material
Great quality and very sturdy, perfect for using with piecrust in small muffin tins.
Size
Ideal size for making sugar cookies with a large surface area, allowing for creative royal icing designs.

The Scalloped Edge Flower Cookie Cutter by Ann Clark is a versatile tool perfect for fall-themed baking. Made in the USA from certified food-safe American steel, it ensures durability and safety in your kitchen. With a size of 3.75 x 3.5 x 1 inches, it's suitable for creating a variety of baked goods, including cookies, fondant decorations, biscuits, brownies, and craft clay shapes.

The flower shape with scalloped edges adds a decorative touch to your treats, making it ideal for holiday parties and events. It is appreciated for its ease of use, though it must be hand washed, which might be a downside for those who prefer dishwasher-safe tools. Weighing only 0.48 ounces, it’s lightweight and easy to handle.

The product's smooth finish aids in cutting through dough cleanly. Those looking for more varied shapes or larger sizes might need to explore other options. The cookie cutter’s design is specialized, appealing mainly to users interested in floral themes or intricate cookie designs.

Rating
9.9
Chosen by1,341
Material
Size

Most important from
918 reviews

Material
Great quality and very sturdy, perfect for using with piecrust in small muffin tins.
Size
Ideal size for making sugar cookies with a large surface area, allowing for creative royal icing designs.
#2

Multi-Occasion Silicone Molds Set | 3-Pack of Pine Tree, Star & Gingerbread Man - Durable Mini Molds for Baking, Candy, Crafts & Ice Cubes Treats

Rating
9.8
Material
Size
Ease of Use

Most important from
456 reviews

Material
The silicone quality is impressive, being thick and durable.
Size
The molds are perfect for making small cookies, which can be used as toppings for other desserts.
Ease of Use
The molds work exceptionally well for chocolates, allowing the candy to come out effortlessly.

The Festive Silicone Molds Set from RYCORE is a versatile 3-pack that includes pine tree, star, and gingerbread man designs, each with multiple cavities. These multi-purpose molds are perfect for a wide range of uses, such as making chocolates, candies, jellies, baked treats, ice cubes, and even crafts like soap or wax melts. One of the main strengths of this product is its high-quality, food-grade silicone material, which is safe, durable, and flexible. This ensures that the molds can withstand high temperatures in ovens and microwaves, as well as low temperatures in freezers and dishwashers, making them highly practical for various projects.

The non-stick and flexible nature of the silicone makes it easy to release your creations without breaking or sticking, and the molds are easy to clean either by hand or in the dishwasher. They are designed for repeated use, making them ideal for seasonal celebrations, family crafting days, or school events. The compact storage design is another practical feature, allowing you to stack and store the molds conveniently.

However, one potential drawback is the relatively small volume capacity (10 ml) per cavity, which might not be suitable for larger projects. Additionally, while the molds are fun for all ages, younger children may require supervision due to the flexibility of the silicone. This product is ideal for families who enjoy baking and crafting together, as well as for those who like to create personalized gifts.

Rating
9.8
Material
Size
Ease of Use

Most important from
456 reviews

Material
The silicone quality is impressive, being thick and durable.
Size
The molds are perfect for making small cookies, which can be used as toppings for other desserts.
Ease of Use
The molds work exceptionally well for chocolates, allowing the candy to come out effortlessly.

Buying Guide for the Best Fall Cookie Cutters

Choosing the right fall cookie cutters can make your baking experience more enjoyable and help you create beautiful, festive cookies. When selecting cookie cutters, consider the material, size, shape, and ease of use. These factors will ensure that you get the best results for your baking needs and preferences.
MaterialCookie cutters come in various materials such as metal, plastic, and silicone. Metal cutters, usually made of stainless steel or tin, are durable and provide clean, sharp edges for precise shapes. Plastic cutters are lightweight, often more affordable, and come in a variety of colors and designs, but they may not cut as cleanly as metal. Silicone cutters are flexible and easy to clean, but they might not hold their shape as well. Choose a material based on your preference for durability, ease of use, and the type of cookies you plan to make.
SizeCookie cutters come in different sizes, ranging from small to large. Small cutters are great for bite-sized cookies or detailed designs, while larger cutters are ideal for creating statement cookies or for easier handling, especially for kids. Consider the size of your baking sheet and the number of cookies you want to make at once. If you plan to decorate your cookies elaborately, larger cutters might be more suitable.
ShapeFall cookie cutters come in a variety of shapes, such as leaves, pumpkins, acorns, and turkeys. The shape you choose should reflect the theme or occasion you are baking for. If you are making cookies for a specific event, like Thanksgiving, you might want to choose more traditional shapes. For general fall-themed baking, a mix of different shapes can add variety and fun to your cookie platter.
Ease of UseConsider how easy the cookie cutters are to use and clean. Some cutters come with handles or grips that make them easier to press into the dough, which can be especially helpful for children or those with limited hand strength. Additionally, look for cutters that are dishwasher safe for easy cleaning. If you plan to use the cutters frequently, ease of use and maintenance will be important factors to consider.

FAQ

Most Popular Categories Right Now