10 Best Fall Cookie Cutters 2025 in the United States

The JOB JOL Fall Thanksgiving Cookie Cutters set includes six festive shapes like pumpkin, leaf, apple, turkey, and acorn, perfect for autumn baking. Made from stainless steel, these cutters are sturdy and durable, so they won’t easily bend or break during use. Their sizes range from about 3 to 3.6 inches, which is a good size for standard cookies—not too big or too small. The design with rolled edges makes cutting dough simple and comfortable, although cleaning requires hand washing since they’re not dishwasher safe.

This set is great if you want a variety of classic fall shapes for cookies, fondant, or even craft projects. If you prefer larger or more intricate cutters, this set might feel a bit basic. It represents a solid choice for anyone looking to add some seasonal fun to their baking with easy-to-use and well-made cutters.

The Number Cookie Cutters 9-Pc. Set by Ann Clark offers a durable and reliable option for anyone looking to create number-shaped cookies, whether for educational purposes, birthdays, or anniversaries. Made from certified food-safe American alloy steel, these cookie cutters are handcrafted in the USA, ensuring quality and safety. The set includes numbers 0 through 8 (with the number 6 doubling as 9), providing versatility for various occasions.

The powder-coated finish guarantees longevity and ease of cleaning, although it is recommended to hand wash only to maintain the integrity of the material. Measuring lightweight at just 0.48 ounces, these cutters are easy to handle and store, with dimensions of 7.24 x 7.05 x 3.19 inches making them compact enough to fit in most kitchen spaces. The included booklet of sugar cookie and icing recipes, along with access to decorating videos, provides added value, making it easier for beginners to get creative with their baking projects.

The hand wash-only requirement might be a minor inconvenience for some, especially those who prefer dishwasher-safe products. The set ranks well within the cookie cutter category, positioned at #619 on Amazon, indicating it's a favored choice among consumers. This set is ideal for families looking to bond over baking activities or individuals aiming to add a creative touch to their baked goods.

The Festive Silicone Molds Set from RYCORE is a versatile 3-pack that includes pine tree, star, and gingerbread man designs, each with multiple cavities. These multi-purpose molds are perfect for a wide range of uses, such as making chocolates, candies, jellies, baked treats, ice cubes, and even crafts like soap or wax melts. One of the main strengths of this product is its high-quality, food-grade silicone material, which is safe, durable, and flexible. This ensures that the molds can withstand high temperatures in ovens and microwaves, as well as low temperatures in freezers and dishwashers, making them highly practical for various projects.

The non-stick and flexible nature of the silicone makes it easy to release your creations without breaking or sticking, and the molds are easy to clean either by hand or in the dishwasher. They are designed for repeated use, making them ideal for seasonal celebrations, family crafting days, or school events. The compact storage design is another practical feature, allowing you to stack and store the molds conveniently.

However, one potential drawback is the relatively small volume capacity (10 ml) per cavity, which might not be suitable for larger projects. Additionally, while the molds are fun for all ages, younger children may require supervision due to the flexibility of the silicone. This product is ideal for families who enjoy baking and crafting together, as well as for those who like to create personalized gifts.