We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

10 Best Foods For Selective Cats 2025 in the United States

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

headphones-stars

Our Top Picks

#1

Winner

IAMS Proactive Health Indoor Weight Control & Hairball Care Adult Dry Cat Food with Chicken & Turkey, 22 lb. Bag

Rating
10.0
Chosen by1,390
Nutritional Content
Flavor
Special Dietary Needs

Most important from
41879 reviews

Nutritional Content
This cat food has made my cats more energetic with shiny, soft coats, and significantly reduced their hairball issues.
Flavor
The salmon flavor is a hit with cats suffering from food sensitivities, providing a tasty and economical option that doesn't cause skin issues.
Special Dietary Needs
The salmon flavor is a hit with cats suffering from food sensitivities, providing a tasty and economical option that doesn't cause skin issues.
Brand Reputation
Switching to IAMS has been a game-changer, with noticeably healthier weight and comfort for our Maine Coon.

The IAMS PROACTIVE HEALTH Adult Indoor Weight Control & Hairball Care Dry Cat Food is designed to cater to the unique needs of adult indoor cats. One of its main strengths lies in its complete and balanced nutritional profile, providing essential nutrients with zero fillers, which helps support health. Additionally, the inclusion of antioxidants supports a strong immune system, making it a good choice for maintaining your cat's well-being.

The product is specifically formulated for hairball control, featuring a proprietary fiber blend with beet pulp to reduce hairballs, which can be a common issue for indoor cats. This is a significant benefit for those who often deal with hairball problems. Another notable feature is its weight management support. The inclusion of L-carnitine helps indoor cats burn fat and maintain a healthy metabolism, addressing a common concern for less active house cats. The food is also enriched with calcium and potassium to promote a healthy heart.

The chicken and turkey flavor is generally well-received by cats, making it easier for pet owners to transition their cats to this food without much fuss. However, as a dry pellet form, it may not appeal to cats that prefer wet food or softer textures. At 22 pounds per bag, it offers good value but might be cumbersome for storage or handling for some pet owners. IAMS is a reputable brand known for its commitment to pet health, and this product upholds that reputation by providing tailored nutrition for adult indoor cats focused on tackling weight and hairball issues effectively.

Rating
10.0
Chosen by1,390
Nutritional Content
Flavor
Special Dietary Needs

Most important from
41879 reviews

Nutritional Content
This cat food has made my cats more energetic with shiny, soft coats, and significantly reduced their hairball issues.
Flavor
The salmon flavor is a hit with cats suffering from food sensitivities, providing a tasty and economical option that doesn't cause skin issues.
Special Dietary Needs
The salmon flavor is a hit with cats suffering from food sensitivities, providing a tasty and economical option that doesn't cause skin issues.
Brand Reputation
Switching to IAMS has been a game-changer, with noticeably healthier weight and comfort for our Maine Coon.
#2

Iams Proactive Health Indoor Weight & Hairball Care Adult Dry Cat Food with Salmon, 16 lb. Bag

Rating
10.0
Nutritional Content
Flavor
Ingredients

Most important from
41879 reviews

Nutritional Content
This cat food has transformed my cats' energy levels and coat quality, making their fur shiny and soft.
Flavor
Iams Proactive Health-Salmon flavor is a lifesaver for cats with food sensitivities, providing relief from severe skin allergies while being economical.
Ingredients
Hairballs are now a rare occurrence thanks to the high-quality ingredients in this food.
Special Dietary Needs
Iams Proactive Health-Salmon flavor is a lifesaver for cats with food sensitivities, providing relief from severe skin allergies while being economical.

Iams Proactive Health Adult Indoor Weight & Hairball Care Dry Cat Food with Salmon is a strong contender for pet owners with selective cats. Its nutritional content is commendable, offering 100% nutrition with no fillers and essential nutrients that support whole-body health. The inclusion of antioxidants is beneficial for a strong immune system, which is a plus for your cat's wellness. For cats that struggle with hairballs, this dry food’s proprietary fiber blend with beet pulp helps in reducing hairballs, addressing a common issue indoor cats face.

Furthermore, the formulation includes L-carnitine, which aids in healthy weight management by assisting your cat in burning fat and maintaining a healthy metabolism. This is particularly helpful for indoor cats that tend to be less active. The flavor of salmon is likely to be a hit among cats, adding to its appeal for picky eaters. The texture of the food is in pellet form, which most cats find easy to consume. However, it's worth noting that the product is quite heavy, with the 16 lb. bag weighing around 13.8 pounds, making it less convenient to handle and store.

The brand Iams has a good reputation in the pet food industry, known for its commitment to quality and tailored nutrition for pets at every life stage. While the product seems to cater well to the needs of indoor cats with specific dietary requirements, it's important to monitor your cat’s response to the food and adjust portions as necessary to maintain optimal weight.

Rating
10.0
Nutritional Content
Flavor
Ingredients

Most important from
41879 reviews

Nutritional Content
This cat food has transformed my cats' energy levels and coat quality, making their fur shiny and soft.
Flavor
Iams Proactive Health-Salmon flavor is a lifesaver for cats with food sensitivities, providing relief from severe skin allergies while being economical.
Ingredients
Hairballs are now a rare occurrence thanks to the high-quality ingredients in this food.
Special Dietary Needs
Iams Proactive Health-Salmon flavor is a lifesaver for cats with food sensitivities, providing relief from severe skin allergies while being economical.
#3

IAMS Proactive Health Healthy Adult Dry Cat Food with Chicken, 22 lb. Bag

Rating
9.8
Nutritional Content
Flavor
Texture

Most important from
23417 reviews

Nutritional Content
The chicken-based formula provides a great source of protein, keeping cats active and energetic throughout the day.
Flavor
The smell of the food is pleasant and does not overpower, resembling a well-cooked salmon.
Texture
Cats love the taste of the hard, small, crunchy kibble, and it stays fresh if sealed properly.
Special Dietary Needs
Noticeable improvement in coat quality—shinier and softer than ever before.

IAMS Proactive Health Healthy Adult Dry Cat Food with Chicken offers a balanced diet for adult cats, containing essential nutrients and antioxidants that support health and a strong immune system. It's formulated with natural fiber and prebiotics to promote healthy digestion. The Omega 6:3 fatty acid ratio helps maintain a healthy skin and coat, while nutrients like calcium and potassium support heart health.

This product is designed to be complete and balanced, eliminating the need for additional vitamin or mineral supplements. The 22 lb bag provides a long-lasting supply, which is convenient for cat owners. However, some cats may be particular about the pellet texture or flavor. The chicken flavor is popular, but individual cat preferences can vary.

The IAMS brand is well-regarded, though it's always best to introduce new food gradually to ensure compatibility with your cat's diet. For cats with specific dietary needs, consulting with a vet is recommended.

Rating
9.8
Nutritional Content
Flavor
Texture

Most important from
23417 reviews

Nutritional Content
The chicken-based formula provides a great source of protein, keeping cats active and energetic throughout the day.
Flavor
The smell of the food is pleasant and does not overpower, resembling a well-cooked salmon.
Texture
Cats love the taste of the hard, small, crunchy kibble, and it stays fresh if sealed properly.
Special Dietary Needs
Noticeable improvement in coat quality—shinier and softer than ever before.

Buying Guide for the Best Foods For Selective Cats

Choosing the right food for your selective cat can be a bit challenging, but with the right approach, you can find something that meets their needs and preferences. It's important to consider various factors such as nutritional content, flavor, texture, and any specific dietary requirements your cat may have. By understanding these key specifications, you can make an informed decision that will keep your feline friend happy and healthy.
Nutritional ContentNutritional content refers to the vitamins, minerals, proteins, fats, and carbohydrates present in the cat food. This is crucial because it ensures your cat gets a balanced diet that supports their overall health. Look for foods that meet the AAFCO (Association of American Feed Control Officials) standards, which indicate that the food is nutritionally complete and balanced. If your cat is very active, they may need higher protein and fat content, while older or less active cats might benefit from lower calorie options.
FlavorFlavor is a key factor for selective cats, as they can be quite picky about what they eat. Cat foods come in various flavors such as chicken, fish, beef, and more. If your cat has shown a preference for a particular type of meat, try to choose foods that feature that flavor prominently. You may need to experiment with a few different flavors to find the one your cat likes best.
TextureTexture refers to whether the food is dry, wet, or semi-moist. Some cats prefer the crunchiness of dry kibble, while others may favor the softness of wet food. Wet food can be beneficial for cats who need more hydration, while dry food is often more convenient and can help with dental health. Semi-moist foods can be a good middle ground. Observe your cat's eating habits to determine which texture they prefer.
IngredientsThe ingredients list will tell you what the food is made of, and it's important to choose foods with high-quality ingredients. Look for foods that list a specific meat (like chicken or salmon) as the first ingredient, rather than by-products or fillers. Avoid foods with artificial preservatives, colors, or flavors. If your cat has allergies or sensitivities, you'll need to avoid certain ingredients that trigger those reactions.
Special Dietary NeedsSome cats have special dietary needs due to health conditions such as diabetes, kidney disease, or food allergies. There are specially formulated foods available for these conditions that can help manage your cat's health. If your cat has a specific health issue, consult with your veterinarian to determine the best dietary options.
Brand ReputationBrand reputation can give you an idea of the quality and safety of the cat food. Brands with a good reputation are more likely to use high-quality ingredients and adhere to safety standards. Research brands and read reviews from other cat owners to find reliable options. Your veterinarian can also recommend trusted brands.

FAQ

Most Popular Categories Right Now