10 Best Hard Rooftop Cargo Carriers 2025 in the United States

The FIVKLEMNZ rooftop cargo carrier is a spacious soft-shell bag offering 21 cubic feet of storage, which can fit around 6 to 8 suitcases or other travel gear. Its dimensions (52 x 40 x 17 inches) make it suitable for most cars, trucks, and SUVs, providing a good boost to your vehicle’s storage capacity. Made from durable 700D Oxford cloth with heat-welded seams and a waterproof zipper, it keeps your belongings dry even in heavy rain.

The mounting system uses 10 reinforced adjustable straps combined with an anti-slip mat and 6 door hooks for installation, which does not require roof racks, making it versatile. Security is addressed with a luggage lock to deter theft, which is a helpful addition. However, as a soft carrier, it might not offer the same impact protection as hard carriers and requires care during installation—particularly avoiding attaching front or back straps to side bars to prevent damage over time.

Soft bags tend to create more wind resistance and noise than hard cases, so expect some extra sound and slightly reduced fuel efficiency. This carrier is well suited for travelers looking for a waterproof, secure, and flexible rooftop storage solution without investing in a hard-shell carrier.

The Thule 614 Pulse Rack is a robust and functional rooftop cargo carrier providing 14 cubic feet of extra packing space, which is quite substantial. Its rugged plastic design ensures durability and protection for your belongings. The dimensions are 67 inches in length, 35 inches in width, and 16 inches in height, making it suitable for various types of items, including up to 5 snowboards with a maximum length of 155 cm.

The load capacity is impressive at 110 lbs, suitable for heavy loads but keep in mind the carrier itself weighs 34 lbs, which adds to the weight on your car roof. The FastGrip quick-mount system makes installation straightforward, taking just a few minutes, and it fits universally on most car types. For security, the central locking system with the Thule Comfort Key ensures that all locking points are securely closed before the key can be removed, adding a reliable safety feature.

The passenger-side opening is convenient for easy access to your items. However, the product's aerodynamics might not be the best, given its bulkier dimensions, potentially affecting fuel efficiency. This cargo box is ideal for families or individuals needing extra space for their outdoor gear or travel items. If you prioritize space, durability, and security, the Thule 614 Pulse Rack is a strong contender.

The Thule Motion 3 LTitan is a robust hard-rooftop-cargo-carrier ideal for anyone needing extra storage space on their vehicle. With a generous capacity of 450 liters, this carrier offers ample room for your belongings. Its dimensions (80 x 38 x 18 inches) ensure it can hold quite a bit without being overly bulky. The 24.04 kg weight makes it manageable for mounting and dismounting.

Made of durable aluminum, it promises longevity and resistance to elements, ensuring your cargo stays dry and secure with its water-resistant design. The wing-shaped profile and dynamic, forward-leaning nose improve aerodynamics, reducing drag and improving fuel efficiency. The PowerClick quick-mount system makes installation straightforward, with a helpful torque indicator to ensure secure fitting. The SlideLock system provides additional security by automatically locking the lid and indicating when it's securely closed.

However, some users might find the carrier's large size challenging to store when not in use. The wide handle makes opening and closing the lid easy, even with one hand, but this might not compensate for its somewhat hefty size. Accessories such as an interior box light, protective box liner, and storage cover enhance functionality but come at an extra cost. The Thule Motion 3 LTitan suits those seeking a spacious, durable, and efficient rooftop cargo solution, though its size and extra costs for accessories might be worth considering.