10 Best Pie Irons 2025 in the United States

The AILITOR Campfire Sandwich Maker Pack of 4 offers a solid choice for those who enjoy cooking over an open fire while camping. Made from durable cast iron, these pie irons can withstand high heat and have a pre-seasoned surface that locks in flavors and makes them ready to use immediately. Their square 4" x 4" cooking heads provide a classic shape for sandwiches or small pies, and the length of 28" with long wooden handles helps keep your hands safely away from the flames. The handles are comfortable to grip and designed to make cooking easier.

One of the nice features is the non-stick coating, which simplifies cleanup and helps prevent rust if they are kept dry, although these pie irons require hand washing since they aren’t dishwasher safe. The easy-open hinge system is practical for turning or removing food without hassle. Coming as a set of four, this product is great for group camping trips or as a gift. At 11 pounds total weight, these pie irons are on the heavier side, which might be less convenient for backpackers looking to travel light.

They are not oven-safe and are intended mainly for open-fire cooking. If you need sturdy, reliable pie irons with long handles and non-stick surfaces for camping or backyard fire pits, this set covers those needs well, but it might be less suitable if you want a very lightweight or oven-compatible option.

The AILITOR Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker is a durable and practical option for campfire cooking, particularly for those who enjoy making toasted sandwiches, pies, and grilling meat outdoors. Made from pre-seasoned cast iron, it locks in food flavors and is ready for immediate use. The square cooking head measures 4x4 inches, offering a good size for various campfire treats.

The length of 28 inches, with extra-long wooden handles, ensures users can comfortably and safely cook away from the fire. The non-stick coating simplifies cleaning and provides rust resistance if maintained properly, though it requires hand washing as it is not dishwasher safe. Additionally, the easy open hinge design adds convenience during use.

However, the weight of 6 pounds might be a bit heavy for some campers, and the need for hand washing might be seen as less convenient compared to dishwasher-friendly options. The pack includes two pie irons, making it a great value and a thoughtful gift for outdoor cooking enthusiasts. Though it is not oven safe, it is compatible with gas for more controlled cooking environments. Those who prioritize ease of use and durability in their campfire cooking equipment will find this product particularly suitable.

The HAWOK Cast Iron Camp Pie Iron Jaffle iron set is a versatile option for campers and outdoor cooking enthusiasts. This set includes a variety of pie irons, including round and square shapes, as well as slotted and double slotted burger and meat grillers. The handles are long, ranging from 27.17 to 28.35 inches, making them suitable for use over an open fire or burning ash.

The cast iron material is pre-seasoned, providing durability and even heat distribution, though it requires hand washing and isn't dishwasher safe. The set's rust-resistant feature adds to its longevity, even with outdoor use. However, the lack of non-stick coating may make cleaning a bit more challenging.

The wooden box included for carrying and storage is a nice touch, adding convenience and making it an excellent gift option. Potential buyers should note that the entire set weighs 703 grams and care instructions specify hand washing only. It's not the best option for those looking for a lightweight or non-stick alternative, but it excels in providing a durable and versatile cooking experience for outdoor settings.