10 Best Pie Irons 2025 in the United States

The IPROUDER Campfire Pie Iron is a solid choice for outdoor cooking enthusiasts who enjoy making hearty sandwiches, mountain pies, and other campfire treats. Made from heavy-duty cast iron, it offers excellent heat distribution for even cooking, which is essential for good campfire pies. The size is larger than many standard pie irons, providing more room for fillings, so you can create more substantial meals.

Its 22.6-inch long wooden handles are a nice feature, keeping your hands safely away from the heat while flipping the pie iron over flames or a grill. The handles also have an ergonomic, heatproof grip, enhancing safety and comfort during use. The included storage bag makes it convenient to carry and store the pie irons, which is handy for camping or picnics. The cast iron comes pre-seasoned with natural vegetable oil to help prevent sticking and makes cleaning easier.

Weighing just over 10 pounds, it is somewhat heavy, which could be a consideration if you’re looking for lightweight gear. This pie iron suits campers and outdoor cooks looking for a durable, reliable tool that can handle frequent use and larger portions.

The AILITOR Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker is a durable and practical option for campfire cooking, particularly for those who enjoy making toasted sandwiches, pies, and grilling meat outdoors. Made from pre-seasoned cast iron, it locks in food flavors and is ready for immediate use. The square cooking head measures 4x4 inches, offering a good size for various campfire treats.

The length of 28 inches, with extra-long wooden handles, ensures users can comfortably and safely cook away from the fire. The non-stick coating simplifies cleaning and provides rust resistance if maintained properly, though it requires hand washing as it is not dishwasher safe. Additionally, the easy open hinge design adds convenience during use.

However, the weight of 6 pounds might be a bit heavy for some campers, and the need for hand washing might be seen as less convenient compared to dishwasher-friendly options. The pack includes two pie irons, making it a great value and a thoughtful gift for outdoor cooking enthusiasts. Though it is not oven safe, it is compatible with gas for more controlled cooking environments. Those who prioritize ease of use and durability in their campfire cooking equipment will find this product particularly suitable.

The Toas-Tite Sandwich Grill is a versatile handheld pie iron that lets you create a variety of toasted sandwiches, snacks, and desserts. Made from sturdy cast aluminum with steel rods and hardwood handles, it is lightweight yet durable, making it perfect for camping, hiking, and other outdoor activities, as well as home use on various stovetops and grills. The retro-inspired design and packaging, including a reprint of the original 1949 instructions and recipe book, adds a nostalgic touch that many users might appreciate.

One key advantage of the Toas-Tite is its ability to seal the edges of your sandwiches, preventing fillings from spilling out, which can enhance your cooking experience, especially when making messy or gooey treats. The handle length and dimensions make it easy to maneuver and cook with, though some might find it a bit small for larger meals. While the grill does not come with a non-stick coating, applying a spray or oil can easily prevent sticking issues. The hinge type is simple and effective, allowing for easy flipping and handling.

With a high customer rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars from over 1,800 reviews, many users appreciate its functionality and nostalgic charm. However, those looking for a non-stick pie iron or a larger cooking surface might need to consider other options. The Toas-Tite is especially ideal for people who enjoy cooking with kids or want to relive fond memories of making pocket-style sandwiches.