We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

10 Best Pie Irons 2025 in the United States

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

headphones-stars

Our Top Picks

#1

Winner

AILITOR Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker, Campfire Sandwich Maker (Pack of 2)

Rating
10.0
Chosen by1,450
Material
Size and Shape
Handle Length

Most important from
196 reviews

Material
The pie irons are sturdy and cook evenly, though some users wish they were a bit larger and deeper.
Size and Shape
The pie irons are sturdy and cook evenly, though some users wish they were a bit larger and deeper.
Handle Length
Handles need improvement, as they can be hard to see and may require taping to keep dirt out, but the overall performance is appreciated.

The AILITOR Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker is a durable and practical option for campfire cooking, particularly for those who enjoy making toasted sandwiches, pies, and grilling meat outdoors. Made from pre-seasoned cast iron, it locks in food flavors and is ready for immediate use. The square cooking head measures 4x4 inches, offering a good size for various campfire treats.

The length of 28 inches, with extra-long wooden handles, ensures users can comfortably and safely cook away from the fire. The non-stick coating simplifies cleaning and provides rust resistance if maintained properly, though it requires hand washing as it is not dishwasher safe. Additionally, the easy open hinge design adds convenience during use.

However, the weight of 6 pounds might be a bit heavy for some campers, and the need for hand washing might be seen as less convenient compared to dishwasher-friendly options. The pack includes two pie irons, making it a great value and a thoughtful gift for outdoor cooking enthusiasts. Though it is not oven safe, it is compatible with gas for more controlled cooking environments. Those who prioritize ease of use and durability in their campfire cooking equipment will find this product particularly suitable.

Rating
10.0
Chosen by1,450
Material
Size and Shape
Handle Length

Most important from
196 reviews

Material
The pie irons are sturdy and cook evenly, though some users wish they were a bit larger and deeper.
Size and Shape
The pie irons are sturdy and cook evenly, though some users wish they were a bit larger and deeper.
Handle Length
Handles need improvement, as they can be hard to see and may require taping to keep dirt out, but the overall performance is appreciated.
#2

HAWOK Cast Iron Camp Pie Iron Jaffle iron set of 10 with Wooden Box…

The HAWOK Cast Iron Camp Pie Iron Jaffle iron set is a versatile option for campers and outdoor cooking enthusiasts. This set includes a variety of pie irons, including round and square shapes, as well as slotted and double slotted burger and meat grillers. The handles are long, ranging from 27.17 to 28.35 inches, making them suitable for use over an open fire or burning ash.

The cast iron material is pre-seasoned, providing durability and even heat distribution, though it requires hand washing and isn't dishwasher safe. The set's rust-resistant feature adds to its longevity, even with outdoor use. However, the lack of non-stick coating may make cleaning a bit more challenging.

The wooden box included for carrying and storage is a nice touch, adding convenience and making it an excellent gift option. Potential buyers should note that the entire set weighs 703 grams and care instructions specify hand washing only. It's not the best option for those looking for a lightweight or non-stick alternative, but it excels in providing a durable and versatile cooking experience for outdoor settings.

#3

Uno Casa - XL Pie Irons Cast Iron Sandwich Maker - Mountain Pie Maker, Japanese Sandwich Maker with Recipe Book, Campfire Cooking Equipment - Mountain Pie Maker Cast Iron

Rating
9.9
Material
Size and Shape
Handle Length

Most important from
1250 reviews

Material
The cast iron design ensures durability and the ability to cook super crispy, golden brown sandwiches.
Size and Shape
The Uno Casa XL Pie Iron makes a grilled Reuben perfectly with no iron taste, thanks to its excellent seasoning.
Handle Length
The option to switch between two handle lengths makes it versatile for both fireside and stove cooking.
Hinge Type
It can be unhinged to create two smaller rectangular pans, adding to its versatility.

The Uno Casa XL Pie Irons Cast Iron Sandwich Maker is designed to enhance your camping and outdoor cooking experience. Made from durable, pre-seasoned cast iron, it promises longevity and resistance to high heat and rust, provided it is kept dry. The large, square-shaped head is double the size of average pie irons, making it versatile for cooking various meals and not just sandwiches. The built-in grill grid adds flavor to your food, which is a nice touch.

The design features two removable handles, measuring 13.8 and 21.6 inches, which makes it easy to clean and pack. The secure hook ensures the head stays closed, keeping your food protected during cooking. On the downside, it is relatively heavy at 5.72 pounds, which might be a consideration for backpackers. Additionally, it requires hand washing and is not dishwasher safe, which might be inconvenient for some users.

The product's non-stick qualities are derived from the pre-seasoned cast iron, but it may still require occasional re-seasoning to maintain its non-stick properties. While it's not suitable for oven use, this pie iron excels in outdoor settings, making it a great choice for campers and outdoor cooking enthusiasts.

Rating
9.9
Material
Size and Shape
Handle Length

Most important from
1250 reviews

Material
The cast iron design ensures durability and the ability to cook super crispy, golden brown sandwiches.
Size and Shape
The Uno Casa XL Pie Iron makes a grilled Reuben perfectly with no iron taste, thanks to its excellent seasoning.
Handle Length
The option to switch between two handle lengths makes it versatile for both fireside and stove cooking.
Hinge Type
It can be unhinged to create two smaller rectangular pans, adding to its versatility.

Buying Guide for the Best Pie Irons

Pie irons, also known as campfire sandwich makers, are a fantastic tool for outdoor cooking. They allow you to make delicious, toasted sandwiches, pies, and other treats over an open flame. When choosing a pie iron, it's important to consider several key specifications to ensure you get the best fit for your needs. Here are the main factors to consider when selecting a pie iron.
MaterialPie irons are typically made from either cast iron or aluminum. Cast iron is known for its durability and excellent heat retention, which ensures even cooking. However, it is heavier and requires seasoning to maintain its non-stick properties. Aluminum pie irons are lighter and easier to handle, but they may not retain heat as well and can be less durable over time. If you plan to use your pie iron frequently and want a long-lasting option, cast iron is a great choice. If you prefer something lightweight and easy to use, aluminum might be more suitable.
Size and ShapePie irons come in various sizes and shapes, including square, round, and rectangular. The size and shape you choose will depend on what you plan to cook. Square and rectangular pie irons are ideal for making sandwiches and larger meals, while round pie irons are perfect for pies and smaller treats. Consider the types of food you want to prepare and choose a size and shape that will accommodate your cooking needs. If you enjoy a variety of foods, you might even consider getting multiple pie irons in different shapes.
Handle LengthThe handle length of a pie iron is important for safety and convenience. Longer handles allow you to keep a safe distance from the fire, reducing the risk of burns. They also provide better leverage for flipping and handling the pie iron. However, longer handles can be more cumbersome to pack and transport. If you often cook over large campfires, a longer handle is beneficial. For smaller fires or portability, a shorter handle may be more practical.
Non-Stick CoatingSome pie irons come with a non-stick coating, which can make cooking and cleaning easier. Non-stick coatings prevent food from sticking to the surface, reducing the need for excessive oil or butter. However, these coatings can wear off over time and may not be as durable as uncoated options. If you prefer low-maintenance cooking and easy cleanup, a non-stick pie iron could be a good choice. If you prioritize durability and don't mind a bit of extra effort in seasoning and cleaning, an uncoated pie iron might be better.
Hinge TypePie irons can have either a fixed or removable hinge. Fixed hinges are more durable and less likely to break, but they can be harder to clean thoroughly. Removable hinges allow you to separate the two halves of the pie iron, making it easier to clean and store. If you value ease of cleaning and storage, a pie iron with a removable hinge is a good option. If you prefer a more robust and straightforward design, a fixed hinge might be more suitable.

FAQ

Most Popular Categories Right Now