10 Best Pumpkin Cookie Cutters 2025 in the United States

The Halloween Cookie Cutters 3-Pc. Set by Ann Clark includes pumpkin, ghost, and bat shapes, making it perfect for Halloween celebrations. These cutters are made in the USA from certified food-safe alloy steel, ensuring durability and safety. The material is polished, which adds a nice finish but requires hand washing, potentially making cleanup a bit more labor-intensive compared to dishwasher-safe options.

The size of each cutter is adequate for standard cookies, and the designs are classic and suitable for various festive baked goods or craft projects. The edge sharpness is effective for cutting through cookie dough, fondant, and similar materials, which is crucial for getting clean shapes without much effort. However, users should be mindful that sharp edges can be a safety concern, especially when involving children in baking activities.

With a longstanding reputation from the Clark family, this set is a reliable choice if you’re looking to create themed cookies and treats for Halloween. The biggest drawback is the cleaning requirement, which might not be ideal for everyone, but the cutters' functionality and design make them a worthy addition to your baking tools.

The Cookie Cutter Kingdom Halloween Cookie Cutters offer a solid choice for anyone wanting to make festive pumpkin-shaped treats. Made from high-quality stainless steel, they promise durability and a sharp edge that cuts through dough cleanly, which helps you get neat pumpkin shapes every time. The coated finish not only adds a nice look but also makes cleaning easier, although hand washing is recommended to keep them in good condition.

The size is quite convenient at about 3.5 inches, ideal for cookies, sandwiches, or even fondant, giving you versatility beyond just baking. The design is clearly Halloween-themed with a pumpkin shape that’s fun and recognizable, great for parties or seasonal baking. The cutters require gentle handling during cleaning to maintain the coated finish and sharp edges.

If you’re looking for a reliable, festive pumpkin cutter that’s easy to use and clean with a good shape and size, this product fits well. Just be aware it’s best to hand wash and handle carefully to keep it lasting through many Halloween seasons.