10 Best Toaster Choices 2025 in the United States

The Amazon Basics 2 Slice Toaster offers several key features that make it a practical choice for everyday use. With two slots, it can handle one or two slices of bread at a time, which is suitable for small households or individuals. The six browning settings give users the flexibility to choose their preferred toast shade, and the extra-wide slots are perfect for bagels and thicker bread slices.

The toaster includes specific settings for bagels and defrosting, as well as a cancel function for added convenience. An extra-lift lever ensures safe removal of smaller pieces, which is a nice touch for ease of use. Cleaning is straightforward due to the removable crumb tray, although it is located at the back, which might be a minor inconvenience for some.

The toaster's design is compact, measuring approximately 11 x 6.5 x 7.5 inches, so it won't take up too much counter space. The black and silver color scheme is modern and should fit into most kitchen decor. Additionally, the 37-inch power cord with a cord wrap feature helps manage excess cord length when the toaster is not in use. On the downside, the toaster has a modest 900-watt power output, which might result in slightly longer toasting times compared to higher wattage models. However, for its price point and feature set, it provides good value. With a solid customer rating of 4.3 stars from over 35,000 reviews, it appears to be a reliable and popular choice among users.

The Smeg 50's Style Retro Aesthetic 4 Slice Toaster comes with two extra wide slots, making it suitable for a variety of bread types, including bagels and artisan breads. The self-centering racks ensure even toasting, while the automatic slice pop up feature adds convenience. Its anti-slip feet provide extra stability on your countertop. With six browning levels and three preset programs (reheat, defrost, and bagel), it offers good flexibility for achieving your desired toastiness. The removable stainless steel crumb tray makes cleaning straightforward and easy.

Measuring 8 inches deep, 16 inches wide, and 9 inches high, it's a bit large, so you’ll need ample counter space for this model. The vibrant red color and retro design are attractive and can add a pop of color to your kitchen decor. However, if you have limited counter space or prefer a more compact appliance, this toaster might not be the best fit. The lack of more than two slots may also be a drawback if you need to toast more slices simultaneously.

It's a stylish and functional choice for those who appreciate a vintage aesthetic and do not mind the larger size.

The SMEG 2 Slice Toaster in cream is a stylish kitchen appliance that is particularly well-suited for those who value aesthetics along with functionality. Featuring two large slots, this toaster can accommodate various types of bread, making it versatile for everyday use. The six browning levels offer customization, allowing users to achieve their preferred toast shade with ease. The chrome knob with Reheat, Defrost, Cancel, and Bagel functions adds convenience and adaptability for different toasting needs.

The toaster's self-centering racks ensure even browning, which can be a significant advantage for achieving consistent results. Additionally, the removable stainless-steel crumb tray simplifies cleaning, which is a practical feature for maintaining a tidy kitchen space. In terms of design, the SMEG toaster stands out with its retro style, making it a visually appealing choice for those who appreciate vintage-inspired appliances. However, it is somewhat on the heavier side at 7 pounds, which might be a consideration for those who need to frequently move it around their kitchen.

The toaster's anti-slip base and automatic shut-off feature enhance safety during use, and its polished finish provides a sleek look. However, it's worth noting that it is designed for two slices, which might not be ideal for larger households needing to prepare multiple slices simultaneously. Also, while it offers various functions, some may find the specific uses limited to bagels and bread. The SMEG 2 Slice Toaster is a dependable choice for those prioritizing design and performance in a compact, user-friendly appliance. Its features like browning control and ease of cleaning make it a practical addition to small to medium-sized kitchens.