We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

10 Best 1911 Holsters 2025 in the United States

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

headphones-stars

Our Top Picks

#1

Winner

Safariland 6360 ALS/SLS Mid-Ride, Level 3 Retention Duty Holster, Colt 1911 Government, Mid-Ride, STX Basketweave Black, Right Hand

Rating
10.0
Chosen by1,430
Material
Retention
Concealment

Most important from
5003 reviews

Material
Solidly built, adjustable to my liking, and the retention mechanisms are great.
Retention
Both retention mechanisms being positioned for thumb release means a person looking to snatch my sidearm would struggle for a minute or so.
Concealment
Close to the body and doesn't stick out like some other level 3 holsters.
Draw Speed
This holster is exactly what I'm looking for; it allows almost as fast a draw as level one once you get used to the mechanism.

The Safariland 6360 ALS/SLS Mid-Ride, Level 3 Retention Duty Holster is designed for the Colt 1911 Government. It uses SafariLaminate material, which is known for its durability and quality. The holster features a mid-ride design, making it slim and compact, allowing the weapon to ride close to the body for improved concealment and comfort.

With a Level III Retention system, it ensures the weapon is securely held with both Automatic Locking System (ALS) and Self Locking System (SLS) mechanisms. This high level of security is beneficial for law enforcement or security personnel who require maximum retention to prevent unauthorized access to the firearm. The 2.25-inch belt slots give a sturdy and reliable fit on standard duty belts. However, the multi-step process to release the weapon might slow down the draw speed compared to simpler holsters. It's important to practice the draw sequence to achieve a quick and smooth release.

The holster's weight is relatively light at 0.75 pounds, which adds to the comfort during long hours of wear. The STX Basketweave Black finish gives it a professional and appealing look. While it excels in retention and comfort, it may not be the best option for someone looking for rapid, one-step access to their firearm. This holster is best suited for those in professions where weapon security is paramount, such as police officers or security personnel.

Rating
10.0
Chosen by1,430
Material
Retention
Concealment

Most important from
5003 reviews

Material
Solidly built, adjustable to my liking, and the retention mechanisms are great.
Retention
Both retention mechanisms being positioned for thumb release means a person looking to snatch my sidearm would struggle for a minute or so.
Concealment
Close to the body and doesn't stick out like some other level 3 holsters.
Draw Speed
This holster is exactly what I'm looking for; it allows almost as fast a draw as level one once you get used to the mechanism.
#2

Safariland 6360 Duty Holster, Fits Springfield Operator, Surefire X200 & X300 Light, Level III Retention™, STX Tactical Black, Right Hand

Rating
9.4
Material
Retention

Most important from
5003 reviews

Material
Highly durable holster, suitable for various demanding situations.
Retention
The ALS and SLS systems are easy to use and provide a very secure fit.

The Safariland 6360 Duty Holster is made from SafariLaminate, which is known for its durability and robust performance, making it a solid choice for tactical and military use. Its primary carry position is on the right side, suitable for right-handed users, and it features a slim and compact design that helps the weapon ride close to the body, enhancing comfort and concealment.

The holster's Automatic Locking System (ALS) and Self Locking System (SLS) provide a high level of retention, ensuring the firearm is secure once holstered. Additionally, the holster offers Level IV retention with an optional Sentry installed, which is a significant advantage for those needing maximum security for their firearm. For users unfamiliar with these locking systems, there may be a learning curve to achieve a smooth and quick draw.

Despite the safety features, the holster allows for a straight-up draw once all releases are deactivated, which is advantageous in high-pressure situations. The material, SafariLaminate, contributes to the holster's robust and reliable build, though it might not be as flexible or lightweight as other materials. The Safariland 6360 is a highly secure and durable holster well-suited for tactical and military personnel who prioritize firearm security and durability over lightweight and flexibility.

Rating
9.4
Material
Retention

Most important from
5003 reviews

Material
Highly durable holster, suitable for various demanding situations.
Retention
The ALS and SLS systems are easy to use and provide a very secure fit.
#3

We The People Holsters - Black - Left Hand - IWB Holster Compatible with 1911 Commander/Colt 1911 Commander/Kimber 1911 / Springfield 1911 4" 45ACP No Rail Only RDS

Rating
9.4
Material
Carry Position
Retention

Most important from
3760 reviews

Material
Made from durable Kydex material, it provides a snug and reliable fit for your firearm.
Carry Position
The adjustable ride height, cant, and retention allow for a highly customizable carry experience.
Retention
The retention is really good and adjustable, ensuring your firearm is secure yet accessible.
Comfort
The holster offers both comfort and security, making it a great choice for concealed carry.
Concealment
With its slim profile, it stays discreet under clothing, ideal for all-day wear without printing.

The We The People Holsters IWB Holster is a versatile option for left-handed users who carry a 1911 Commander/Colt 1911 Commander/Kimber 1911/Springfield 1911 4" 45ACP without a rail. The holster is made from durable Kydex material, which is both waterproof and washable, ensuring longevity and ease of maintenance.

This holster is designed to be worn inside the waistband (IWB), offering multiple carry positions including appendix, strong side, behind the hip, and cross draw, which can be adjusted for height and angle to fit personal preferences. This adaptability helps in achieving comfort and a smooth draw, crucial for self-defense situations. The thick wall Kydex construction ensures good retention, keeping the firearm secure while also allowing quick access.

The holster's design helps in effective concealment with an un-tucked shirt, making it suitable for discreet carrying. However, the rigid Kydex material may not be as comfortable as softer materials like leather, especially when worn for extended periods. Also, as it is specifically designed for certain models without a rail, it may not be suitable for users with different configurations. This holster would be a good choice for those prioritizing durability and retention in an IWB holster, suitable for everyday concealed carry.

Rating
9.4
Material
Carry Position
Retention

Most important from
3760 reviews

Material
Made from durable Kydex material, it provides a snug and reliable fit for your firearm.
Carry Position
The adjustable ride height, cant, and retention allow for a highly customizable carry experience.
Retention
The retention is really good and adjustable, ensuring your firearm is secure yet accessible.
Comfort
The holster offers both comfort and security, making it a great choice for concealed carry.
Concealment
With its slim profile, it stays discreet under clothing, ideal for all-day wear without printing.

Buying Guide for the Best 1911 Holsters

Choosing the right 1911 holster is crucial for ensuring comfort, accessibility, and safety when carrying your firearm. The 1911 is a popular and classic handgun, and there are many holster options available to suit different needs and preferences. To make an informed decision, you should consider several key specifications that will help you find the best fit for your lifestyle and carrying requirements.
MaterialThe material of the holster affects its durability, comfort, and retention. Common materials include leather, Kydex, and nylon. Leather holsters are known for their comfort and classic look, but they may require a break-in period. Kydex holsters are durable, offer excellent retention, and are easy to clean, but they can be less comfortable against the skin. Nylon holsters are lightweight and affordable, but they may not offer the same level of retention as leather or Kydex. Choose a material based on your comfort preference, retention needs, and how you plan to use the holster.
Carry PositionThe carry position refers to where on your body you will wear the holster. Common positions include inside the waistband (IWB), outside the waistband (OWB), appendix carry, and shoulder carry. IWB holsters are popular for concealed carry as they offer good concealment and security. OWB holsters are more comfortable for extended wear and are easier to draw from, but they may be harder to conceal. Appendix carry offers quick access but can be uncomfortable when sitting. Shoulder holsters distribute weight well and are good for long periods of wear but require a cover garment. Consider your daily activities and clothing style when choosing a carry position.
RetentionRetention refers to how securely the holster holds the firearm. There are passive retention systems, which rely on the holster's shape and material to hold the gun, and active retention systems, which use additional mechanisms like straps or buttons. High retention is important for activities involving a lot of movement to prevent the firearm from falling out. Lower retention may be acceptable for casual wear or situations where quick access is more critical. Assess your need for security versus speed of draw when considering retention.
ComfortComfort is a key factor, especially if you plan to carry your 1911 for extended periods. The holster should fit your body shape and not cause discomfort or irritation. Consider the holster's design, padding, and how it distributes weight. Try different holsters to see which one feels the most comfortable during your typical activities. Remember that a holster that is uncomfortable is less likely to be worn consistently, which can compromise your safety and readiness.
ConcealmentConcealment is important if you plan to carry your 1911 concealed. The holster should minimize printing (the outline of the gun showing through clothing) and be easy to hide under your typical wardrobe. IWB holsters generally offer better concealment than OWB holsters. Consider the size and shape of the holster, as well as how it fits with your clothing choices. A holster that offers good concealment will allow you to carry discreetly and comfortably.
Draw SpeedDraw speed refers to how quickly you can access and draw your firearm from the holster. This is crucial in self-defense situations where every second counts. Holsters with less retention and simpler designs generally allow for faster draws. However, you must balance draw speed with retention and safety. Practice drawing from different holsters to find one that offers a good balance of speed and security for your needs.

FAQ

Most Popular Categories Right Now