10 Best 1911 Holsters 2025 in the United States

The We The People Holsters IWB Holster is a versatile option for left-handed users who carry a 1911 Commander/Colt 1911 Commander/Kimber 1911/Springfield 1911 4" 45ACP without a rail. The holster is made from durable Kydex material, which is both waterproof and washable, ensuring longevity and ease of maintenance.

This holster is designed to be worn inside the waistband (IWB), offering multiple carry positions including appendix, strong side, behind the hip, and cross draw, which can be adjusted for height and angle to fit personal preferences. This adaptability helps in achieving comfort and a smooth draw, crucial for self-defense situations. The thick wall Kydex construction ensures good retention, keeping the firearm secure while also allowing quick access.

The holster's design helps in effective concealment with an un-tucked shirt, making it suitable for discreet carrying. However, the rigid Kydex material may not be as comfortable as softer materials like leather, especially when worn for extended periods. Also, as it is specifically designed for certain models without a rail, it may not be suitable for users with different configurations. This holster would be a good choice for those prioritizing durability and retention in an IWB holster, suitable for everyday concealed carry.

The Alien Gear Photon Holster offers a versatile and adaptable option for those seeking a reliable 1911 holster. Made from durable polymer, it is lightweight yet sturdy, ensuring durability and ease of use. One of its standout features is its ambidextrous design, making it suitable for both right and left-hand draws.

Additionally, it supports both IWB (Inside the Waistband) and OWB (Outside the Waistband) carry positions, providing flexibility in how you can carry your firearm. This holster is optic-ready and can accommodate most popular compact lights, which is a great advantage for those using optics or lights on their gun. The adjustable cant and ride height allow you to customize the draw angle and comfort to your preference, enhancing usability.

Moreover, it is compatible with suppressor-height sights, adding to its versatility. An optional sidecar attachment is available for extra storage, which can be useful for carrying spare ammunition. However, this holster uses Level 1 retention, which might not offer as much security as higher retention levels. While it provides a good balance between retention and quick draw speed, some users might prefer a holster with more secure retention features. Comfort and concealment are generally well-regarded, but the polymer material may not be as comfortable as some softer materials for extended wear. Despite these minor drawbacks, the Alien Gear Photon Holster is a strong contender for anyone looking for a versatile and customizable 1911 holster.

The Safariland 7378 holster is designed specifically for the Colt 1911 Commander with a 4.25-inch barrel, making it a good fit for owners of this particular handgun. Its standout feature is the ALS (Automatic Locking System), which securely locks the gun in place yet allows for a quick, smooth draw when needed. Made from a SafariSeven nylon-blend material rather than leather or hard plastic, it protects the gun's finish well and keeps the holster lightweight at just under 10 ounces. You get two carry options—a concealment paddle and a belt loop—allowing you to choose the most comfortable and stable position for your needs. This holster rides close to the body, which helps with concealment under clothing, an important factor if you want your firearm to remain discreet.

The retention system is reliable, balancing security and speed, though paddle-style holsters can sometimes shift slightly during movement compared to belt-only designs. Comfort-wise, the lightweight and slim profile add to wearability, but as with many paddle holsters, some users may find extended wear less comfortable than inside-the-waistband options. The hook and loop closure on the paddle helps keep the holster in place without damaging clothing. While the material is durable and protective, it’s plastic-based rather than leather, so it might lack the classic look some prefer.

The holster is right-handed and designed with a modern style, making it suitable for everyday carry or professional use. Supported by strong customer ratings and a two-year warranty, it represents a dependable, fast-access holster for your Colt 1911 Commander that balances concealment, retention, and comfort without being bulky.