10 Best 4 Slice Toasters 2025 in the United States

The Cuisinart CPT-180WP1 4-Slice Toaster is a solid choice for anyone needing a reliable and versatile toaster for multiple slices at once. It has four extra-wide 1.5-inch slots, which easily fit a variety of bread types, from thin sliced bread to thicker bagels and pastries. The dual control panels with 6-level browning dials allow you to customize how light or dark you want your toast, which is helpful if you like different settings for each pair of slices. This model also includes defrost and reheat functions with dedicated buttons and LED lights, so you can safely toast frozen bread or warm up toast without burning it.

Cleaning won’t be a hassle thanks to the slide-out crumb tray, and the extra-lift lever makes it easier to remove smaller items without burning your fingers. The stainless steel build gives it a classic, durable look, while the compact footprint and cord wrap help save countertop space. It uses 180 watts, which is quite low compared to many others, so toasting might take a bit longer. Some users might find this a minor drawback if they want very quick toasting. Additionally, while the toaster is well-made, the classic design may not fit a more modern or sleek kitchen aesthetic for some.

It comes with a 3-year warranty, which adds peace of mind. If you want an easy-to-use, dependable toaster that handles different bread types and functions well with straightforward controls, this Cuisinart model fits the bill nicely.

The Breville 4-Slice BTA840XL Die-Cast Smart Toaster in brushed aluminum is a high-quality appliance designed to cater to various toasting needs. Its four extra-wide slots are suitable for different bread types, including thick bagels and artisanal bread. The toaster’s standout features include the 'Lift and Look' and 'A Bit More' functions, which offer convenient control over the toasting process without interrupting the cycle.

This makes it easy to achieve your desired browning level with the variable browning control and monitor progress through the LED indicator. The toaster also comes with dedicated settings for bagels, defrosting, and fruit bread, adding to its versatility. The automatic control with auto lift and look makes toasting hassle-free and ensures consistent results. Cleaning is straightforward with a front pull-out crumb tray, eliminating the need to lift the toaster.

The build quality is solid, thanks to its metal construction, and the brushed aluminum finish adds a stylish touch to any kitchen. However, the toaster's relatively high price and weight (9.55 pounds) might be a drawback for some users. Additionally, it requires a 120-volt power supply and delivers 1800 watts of power, which is quite powerful for a toaster. With a 1-year limited warranty, the Breville BTA840XL offers reliability but may be considered an investment rather than a budget-friendly option. Ideal for those who prioritize consistency, convenience, and high build quality in their kitchen appliances.

The Smeg 50's Retro 4-slice toaster stands out mainly for its stylish design and solid build. It has 2 extra-wide slots with self-centering racks, which makes it easier to toast thicker bread or bagels evenly. While it says 4-slice in the category, this model actually toasts 2 slices at a time, so it might not be the best choice if you often need to toast four slices simultaneously. It offers 6 browning levels, giving you good control over how light or dark you want your toast. The toaster has three convenient preset programs for defrosting frozen bread, reheating toast without burning, and toasting bagels, which adds useful versatility.

The removable stainless steel crumb tray is easy to clean, helping keep your countertop tidy. Its anti-slip feet help keep it stable during use. The stainless steel body with a black retro finish is attractive and should be durable. At 7.5 pounds and a larger footprint (16 inches wide), it’s somewhat bulky for smaller kitchens.

If you need true 4-slice toasting at once, this unit falls short since it has only 2 slots. For those prioritizing style, solid performance, and extra features like bagel and defrost modes, this toaster is a great fit for small households or anyone looking to add a retro flair to their kitchen.