10 Best Above Ground Pool Winter Covers 2025 in the United States

The Robelle 5124-4 Ultimate Winter Pool Cover is designed for 24-foot round above-ground swimming pools. The cover is made from premium-grade polyethylene with a 14 x 14 scrim, which contributes to its durability and solid construction. This material ensures that water will not pass through, providing effective water resistance. Additionally, the cover includes a 4-foot overlap, making it easier to install and ensuring a secure fit.

The inclusion of a winch and cable further aids in the installation process and helps to keep the cover in place through winter weather conditions. With a 20-year warranty, the Robelle 5124-4 provides long-term assurance against defects and wear and tear, which speaks to the manufacturer's confidence in the product's durability. The product care instructions recommend hand washing with a mild cleaner and ensuring the cover is completely dry before storing, which might require additional effort.

The winch and cable system, while secure, may not be intuitive for all users and might require careful handling to avoid damage. The need to purchase an ice equalizer pillow separately could be seen as an inconvenience. This pool cover is best suited for those looking for a durable and secure winter solution for their above-ground pool, especially if they are willing to invest the time in proper installation and maintenance.

The Winter Pool Cover 24 ft Round by Yankee Pool Pillow is a solid choice for above-ground pool owners looking to protect their pool during the winter months. The cover is made from polyethylene (PE) and boasts a 14 x 14 scrim count and 185 GSM density, indicating that it is extra thick and durable. This makes it highly resistant to tears and wear, which is crucial for enduring harsh winter conditions. Additionally, the cover is designed to handle extreme temperatures, from as low as -10°F (-25°C) to as high as 180°F (80°C), ensuring it will perform well regardless of the weather.

The LDPE coating provides protection against UV radiation, preventing sunlight from promoting algae growth in the pool water, while the black underside further inhibits overgrowth by blocking light. The cover's water resistance is also a strong point, as it effectively keeps contaminants out of the pool during the off-season. Installation is made easy with a steel-core cable and reinforced metal grommets for a secure fit, and a molded winch ensures the cable tightens smoothly. The cover also comes with a generous 4-foot overlap, making it easier to secure and providing extra protection. However, it's important to note that the pool pillow is not included and must be purchased separately.

The Robelle 33 ft Heavy Duty Winter Pool Cover is designed for above-ground pools around 33 feet in diameter, featuring a 4-foot overlap to facilitate easier installation. It is made from solid polyethylene material with an 8 x 8 scrim pattern weighing 2.36 oz/yd², providing strength and durability to resist tears and weather damage. Its solid design prevents water from passing through, effectively keeping debris and rainwater out of the pool during winter.

Included with the cover is a winch and cable system that helps secure it tightly around the pool, adding convenience and security. The cover floats on the water, which is typical for winter covers. For pools with large top rails, selecting a slightly larger cover may provide a better fit. Although the product does not specifically claim UV protection, polyethylene covers generally offer some resistance to sunlight damage, enhancing longevity.

The manufacturer provides a 10-year warranty, indicating confidence in the cover's durability. It is important to note that the ice equalizer pillow, which helps manage ice pressure on the cover, is sold separately and may be an additional expense for those in very cold climates. This winter cover is a reliable choice for pool owners seeking a durable, water-resistant, and easy-to-install solution to protect their above-ground pool throughout the winter months.