10 Best Waterline Eyeliners 2025 in the United States

The Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner Micro Tip is designed for those seeking a reliable and long-lasting eyeliner option. One of its strongest features is its impressive longevity; it is specifically formulated to resist smudging and fading, making it a solid choice for all-day wear. The intense black pigmentation delivers a bold look without needing multiple applications. The micro tip design allows for precise application, ensuring that you can create fine lines or more defined looks with ease.

The glossy finish might not be to everyone's liking, especially for those who prefer a matte look. While the formula glides on smoothly, some users with sensitive eyes may find that it can be slightly irritating, particularly for use on the waterline. Additionally, while it is marketed as waterproof, some users have noted that it can be challenging to remove, requiring a strong makeup remover to fully cleanse the area.

This eyeliner is particularly well-suited for individuals looking for a dependable, long-lasting, and richly pigmented product. It performs admirably in delivering the defined eyes that many desire for a special occasion or everyday wear. Just keep in mind the potential sensitivities and removal concerns if you have delicate skin or prefer easier cleanup.

The Lancôme Le Stylo Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil is a top choice for those seeking a high-quality waterline eyeliner. One of its standout features is its creamy formula, which allows for smooth and easy application. This makes it perfect for both precise lines and more blended, smoky looks, thanks to its built-in smudger. The pigmentation of this eyeliner is another strong point, offering an intense matte black color (02 Noir Intense) that is highly visible and striking.

Users can expect the color to remain vibrant throughout the day without fading or flaking. The longevity of this product is excellent, as it sets to a waterproof formula that can withstand all-day wear, making it ideal for long workdays or nights out. However, one potential downside is that the waterproof nature of the eyeliner might make it a bit more challenging to remove, requiring a good quality makeup remover to ensure it comes off completely without harsh rubbing.

This eyeliner is best suited for anyone looking for a long-lasting, highly pigmented eyeliner that can be used for both subtle and dramatic eye looks.

The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner is a waterproof, matte liquid eyeliner that promises a long-lasting and precise application. One of its standout features is the ultra-precise, flexible tip, which allows for a highly controlled application, making it easy to achieve both fine and bold lines. This flexibility is great for users who enjoy experimenting with different eyeliner styles. The product’s black pigmentation is rich and intense, providing a dramatic look with just one stroke.

The fact that it is vegan and cruelty-free will appeal to ethically-minded consumers who are concerned about animal testing and ingredient sourcing. However, being a waterproof formula, it may be slightly more challenging to remove compared to non-waterproof eyeliners. Users may need a good quality makeup remover to effectively clean it off, which might not be convenient for everyone.

Additionally, while the product is designed to cater to a broad range of eye makeup preferences, those looking for a softer, less intense eyeliner might find the pigmentation too bold. Despite these minor drawbacks, the NYX Epic Ink Liner is an excellent choice for those seeking a highly pigmented, long-lasting, and versatile liquid eyeliner that can withstand water and wear throughout the day.