We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

10 Best Commander Decks 2025 in the United States

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

headphones-stars

Our Top Picks

#1

Winner

Magic: The Gathering Modern Horizons 3 Commander Deck Bundle - Includes All 4 Decks (Graveyard Overdrive, Tricky Terrain, Creative Energy, and Eldrazi Incursion)

Rating
10.0
Chosen by1,268
Commander
Theme and Strategy
Mana Curve

Most important from
953 reviews

Commander
It's perfect for anyone who loves Commander and Eldrazi, definitely worth the retail price.
Theme and Strategy
The Eldrazi Incursion deck is amazing, featuring lots of great cards and a solid strategy.
Mana Curve
The deck is well-designed and plays very well, with 5+ mana spells cast easily thanks to the lands, mana rocks, and token mana dorks.

The Magic: The Gathering Modern Horizons 3 Commander Deck Bundle is a great choice for both new and experienced players looking to engage in multiplayer battles. With four diverse decks - Graveyard Overdrive, Tricky Terrain, Creative Energy, and Eldrazi Incursion - each offering unique strategies, players can enjoy a variety of gameplay experiences. The decks are ready to play right out of the box, making them convenient for immediate use.

The inclusion of 60 new Commander cards, 15 per deck with 2 foil Legendary Creatures, adds an exciting element for collectors and players alike. Additionally, the 2-card Collector Booster Sample Pack in each deck enhances the collection with rare and foil cards from the Modern Horizons 3 set.

While the decks offer strong themes and strategies, some players might find the pre-constructed nature limiting if they prefer customizing their decks extensively. The decks' mana curves and land bases are well-balanced for their respective strategies but may require tweaking for optimal performance in competitive play. As a comprehensive bundle, it's ideal for those seeking varied and thematic gameplay experiences in the Commander format.

Rating
10.0
Chosen by1,268
Commander
Theme and Strategy
Mana Curve

Most important from
953 reviews

Commander
It's perfect for anyone who loves Commander and Eldrazi, definitely worth the retail price.
Theme and Strategy
The Eldrazi Incursion deck is amazing, featuring lots of great cards and a solid strategy.
Mana Curve
The deck is well-designed and plays very well, with 5+ mana spells cast easily thanks to the lands, mana rocks, and token mana dorks.
#2

Magic: The Gathering Fallout Commander Deck Bundle – Includes All 4 Decks (1 Hail Caesar, 1 Scrappy Survivors, 1 Science!, and 1 Mutant Menace)

The Magic: The Gathering Fallout Commander Deck Bundle offers a unique experience for fans of both Magic and the Fallout series. This bundle includes four preconstructed 100-card decks: Hail Caesar, Scrappy Survivors, Science!, and Mutant Menace. Each deck features new Magic cards with beloved Fallout characters, thematic mechanics, and beautiful art that captures the post-nuclear world of Fallout.

The decks are ready-to-play, making them great for both new and experienced players who want to jump straight into the game with friends. A key strength is the inclusion of Collector Booster Sample packs with special alt-frame cards, providing added value for collectors. Additionally, each deck comes with essential accessories like double-sided tokens, a life tracker, and a strategy guide, which enhances the playing experience.

On the downside, while the decks are well-crafted, some players might find the themes and strategies too niche if they aren't fans of the Fallout series. Moreover, the preconstructed nature of the decks might not appeal to those who enjoy customizing their Commander decks extensively. It’s best suited for casual to moderately competitive players who appreciate the crossover between Magic and Fallout, as well as collectors looking for unique card treatments.

#3

Magic: The Gathering Fallout Commander Deck - Scrappy Survivors (100-Card Deck, 2-Card Collector Booster Sample Pack + Accessories)

Rating
9.9
Commander
Theme and Strategy
Card Synergy

Most important from
2451 reviews

Commander
This deck is a very good start for a commander deck and worth the cost.
Theme and Strategy
The Mutant Menace preconstructed commander deck is very on-theme for the Fallout franchise, featuring memorable characters like The Wise Mothman and The Master, Transcendent.
Card Synergy
The new and unique mechanic called Radiation encourages milling yourself and/or your opponents for great value.

The Magic: The Gathering Fallout Commander Deck - Scrappy Survivors is an exciting addition for fans of both MTG and the Fallout series. One of its main strengths lies in the thematic integration of Fallout elements, featuring 38 new cards that introduce beloved characters and mechanics inspired by the post-apocalyptic world. This deck is designed for 3-5 players, making it perfect for casual and strategic gameplay sessions with friends, allowing for fun interactions and social intrigue right out of the box.

The deck is labeled as a ‘ready-to-play’ option, which is great for newcomers who may feel overwhelmed by building decks from scratch. It also includes useful accessories like double-sided tokens, a life tracker, and a strategy guide, enhancing the experience of play. The inclusion of a Collector Booster Sample pack adds extra excitement, with special alt-frame cards that collectors will appreciate.

The Scrappy Survivors deck is a fantastic choice for fans of Fallout or those new to Magic: The Gathering. It offers a fun way to dive into the game with friends but may not satisfy players looking for a highly competitive experience. Its thematic richness and ease of use make it a solid pick for casual gatherings.

Rating
9.9
Commander
Theme and Strategy
Card Synergy

Most important from
2451 reviews

Commander
This deck is a very good start for a commander deck and worth the cost.
Theme and Strategy
The Mutant Menace preconstructed commander deck is very on-theme for the Fallout franchise, featuring memorable characters like The Wise Mothman and The Master, Transcendent.
Card Synergy
The new and unique mechanic called Radiation encourages milling yourself and/or your opponents for great value.

Buying Guide for the Best Commander Decks

Commander decks, also known as EDH (Elder Dragon Highlander) decks, are a popular format in the Magic: The Gathering card game. When choosing a Commander deck, it's important to consider various factors to ensure that the deck aligns with your play style, preferences, and the type of games you want to play. Understanding the key specifications of a Commander deck will help you make an informed decision and enhance your gaming experience.
CommanderThe Commander is the legendary creature that leads your deck and sets the tone for your strategy. This spec is crucial because the abilities and color identity of your Commander will dictate the types of cards you can include in your deck and the overall strategy you will employ. Commanders can range from aggressive and combat-focused to control and combo-oriented. To pick the right one for you, consider what type of gameplay you enjoy. If you like fast-paced games, choose an aggressive Commander. If you prefer a more strategic and methodical approach, a control or combo Commander might be better.
Color IdentityColor identity refers to the colors of mana that your Commander can produce, which in turn determines the colors of the cards you can include in your deck. This is important because each color in Magic: The Gathering has its own strengths and weaknesses. For example, blue is known for control and card draw, while red is known for aggression and direct damage. To navigate this spec, think about which colors align with your preferred play style. If you like drawing cards and countering spells, blue might be a good choice. If you enjoy fast, aggressive play, consider red or green.
Theme and StrategyThe theme and strategy of a Commander deck refer to the overall game plan and the types of cards that support it. This is important because a cohesive theme and strategy will make your deck more effective and enjoyable to play. Themes can range from tribal (focusing on a specific creature type) to spell-slinging (focusing on casting lots of spells). To pick the right theme and strategy, think about what excites you the most. If you love a particular creature type, a tribal deck might be perfect. If you enjoy casting spells and controlling the game, a spell-slinging deck could be ideal.
Card SynergyCard synergy refers to how well the cards in your deck work together to achieve your strategy. This is important because a deck with high synergy will perform more consistently and powerfully. To navigate this spec, look for cards that complement each other and your Commander's abilities. For example, if your Commander benefits from gaining life, include cards that gain life or benefit from life gain. To pick the right cards, consider how each card fits into your overall strategy and whether it enhances your deck's performance.
Mana CurveMana curve refers to the distribution of cards in your deck based on their mana cost. This is important because a well-balanced mana curve ensures that you can play cards at every stage of the game. A deck with too many high-cost cards may struggle in the early game, while a deck with too many low-cost cards may run out of steam in the late game. To navigate this spec, aim for a mix of low, mid, and high-cost cards. To pick the right balance, consider your deck's strategy. Aggressive decks may want more low-cost cards, while control decks may prioritize higher-cost, powerful spells.
Land BaseThe land base refers to the lands in your deck that produce mana. This is important because a stable land base ensures that you can consistently cast your spells. To navigate this spec, include a mix of basic lands and non-basic lands that fit your deck's color identity. To pick the right land base, consider the colors of your deck and the mana requirements of your cards. Multi-color decks may need more dual lands or lands that produce multiple colors of mana, while mono-color decks can rely more on basic lands.

FAQ

Most Popular Categories Right Now