10 Best Crib Mattresses 2025 in the United States

The Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress positions itself as a solid choice for parents looking for a safe and comfortable sleeping surface for their infants and toddlers. One of its most notable strengths is its certifications: it’s GREENGUARD Gold Certified, which means it helps ensure cleaner indoor air quality, and CertiPUR-US Certified for low emissions, making it a favorable option for health-conscious families. The mattress is designed to fit standard full-size cribs and toddler beds, so it should meet the size requirements of most cribs without issues.

In terms of comfort, the high-density foam provides a firm yet supportive surface that is essential for infant safety and proper spine development. Its waterproof outer cover is a big plus, as it keeps the mattress clean and dry from any spills or leaks, and the machine-washable feature makes maintenance easy for busy parents.

The mattress weighs in at a manageable 12-15 pounds, making it easy to handle, but it’s still advisable to ensure it’s the right fit for your crib. For parents looking for a reliable, safe, and easy-to-care-for crib mattress, the Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress is a commendable option.

The Newton Baby Crib Mattress stands out in the crib mattress category for its unique features aimed at ensuring safety and comfort for your baby. One of its most significant strengths is the patented Wovenaire core, which offers excellent breathability. This design reduces the risk of suffocation and overheating, addressing key safety concerns that parents often have. The mattress is also 100% washable, making it incredibly convenient for parents who want to maintain a clean sleeping environment by easily eliminating accidents, allergens, and dust mites. Its two-stage design caters to both infants and toddlers, providing the necessary firmness and support for growing children.

While the breathable and washable features are advantageous, the price point may be on the higher side compared to traditional crib mattresses. Some parents might find it a bit more expensive than they anticipated. Additionally, the mattress is designed specifically for cribs and toddler beds, which means it may not be as versatile for those looking for a multi-functional product that could fit other bed sizes.

In terms of materials, the Newton mattress is non-toxic and Greenguard Gold certified, ensuring that there are no harmful chemicals present, which is a huge plus for health-conscious parents. The lack of foam or springs also contributes to its breathability, but some may prefer a softer feel, especially for younger infants. This mattress is a great choice for parents prioritizing safety, cleanliness, and comfort for their babies, particularly if you’re willing to invest in a higher-end option. However, it may not suit every budget, and those seeking a more traditional feel might want to explore other alternatives.

The hiccapop Pack and Play Mattress Pad is a well-designed portable crib mattress that fits standard playards measuring 38" x 26" with its exact dimensions and rounded corners ensuring no gaps. Its 1.5-inch thickness is firm enough to support proper spinal alignment for babies, which is important for safe sleep and comfort. This mattress is notable for meeting the latest US federal safety regulations, being the only one on Amazon to pass the standard that limits playard mattress thickness to 1.5 inches, which means it's a reliable choice for safety-conscious parents.

The mattress uses polyurethane foam and is covered with an ultra-soft, waterproof polyester blend fabric that protects against leaks and is machine washable, making it practical for everyday use and easy to clean. Although the foam material is not specifically highlighted for breathability, the waterproof cover and hypoallergenic features suggest it aims to provide a healthy sleep environment. Weighing just 2.5 pounds, it’s lightweight and comes with a compact carry bag, adding to its portability for travel or moving between rooms.

One potential drawback is that the foam layer is relatively thin compared to some crib mattresses, which might feel less cushioned to some parents, but this is necessary to comply with safety rules. Parents looking for a safe, portable, and easy-to-maintain playard mattress will find hiccapop’s option a strong contender, especially for those prioritizing regulatory compliance and convenience.