We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

10 Best Electric Insert For Fireplace 2025 in the United States

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

headphones-stars

Our Top Picks

#1

Winner

Touchstone Smart Electric Fireplace-The Sideline 36" Wide-in Wall Recessed - 30 Realistic Ember Color/Flame Options - 1,500W Heater w/Thermostat - Log & Crystal Hearth Options - Alexa/WiFi Enabled

Rating
9.9
Chosen by1,121
Heating Capacity
Flame Effect and Realism
Installation and Venting

Most important from
3429 reviews

Heating Capacity
The heater fan is very quiet and has two fan speeds, high and low.
Flame Effect and Realism
The Sideline flames look better than any of the other brands I checked out.
Installation and Venting
Installation was actually a piece of cake once I carved out the opening in the drywall.
Controls and Features
Multiple dimming options and the ability to choose blue-only flames for a cool look during movie nights.

The Touchstone Smart Electric Fireplace - The Sideline 36" offers a stylish and functional addition to any room, particularly benefiting those who want a cozy atmosphere without the hassle of traditional fireplaces. With 30 ember and flame options, it creates a realistic look that can enhance any home décor. The 1,500W heater can efficiently warm a room up to 400 square feet, making it suitable for living areas or bedrooms, although it won't replace a primary heat source entirely.

One of its strong points is the installation flexibility; it can be recessed into a wall or mounted on the surface, fitting seamlessly in existing fireplace openings. Plus, the ventless design ensures that you won’t need to worry about exhausting air or complicated venting systems, which can simplify setup. The fireplace is also equipped with smart features, allowing you to control it through Alexa, Google Home, or a mobile app, adding a modern touch to its operation.

However, there are a few considerations. The fireplace requires a minimum 8 inches of clearance from a TV or other heat-sensitive items, which may limit placement options in some rooms. While it provides a pleasant warmth, users need to keep in mind that it’s not intended to warm larger spaces or replace central heating. Some users might find the reliance on AAA batteries for the remote a bit inconvenient, as these are not included with the product.

The Touchstone Sideline Electric Fireplace is a great choice for those seeking a blend of ambiance and modern convenience, especially if you appreciate the aesthetic of a traditional fireplace without the maintenance. It's ideal for anyone looking to enhance their home environment while enjoying the benefits of a safe, ventless heating option.

Rating
9.9
Chosen by1,121
Heating Capacity
Flame Effect and Realism
Installation and Venting

Most important from
3429 reviews

Heating Capacity
The heater fan is very quiet and has two fan speeds, high and low.
Flame Effect and Realism
The Sideline flames look better than any of the other brands I checked out.
Installation and Venting
Installation was actually a piece of cake once I carved out the opening in the drywall.
Controls and Features
Multiple dimming options and the ability to choose blue-only flames for a cool look during movie nights.
#2

Touchstone Smart Electric Fireplace-The Sideline 50" Wide-in Wall Recessed - 30 Realistic Ember Color/Flame Options - 1,500W Heater w/Thermostat - Log & Crystal Hearth Options - Alexa/WiFi Enabled

Rating
9.8
Heating Capacity
Flame Effect and Realism
Installation and Venting

Most important from
3429 reviews

Heating Capacity
Despite its beauty, the heat function is adequate but not overly powerful, making it more suited for ambiance than primary heating.
Flame Effect and Realism
The Sideline flames surpass other brands with their stunning, realistic appearance.
Installation and Venting
Installation is straightforward, but it's advisable to handle with care to avoid damaging the glass facade.
Controls and Features
The fireplace provides a modern aesthetic with customizable flame options, including a unique blue-only flame setting.

The Touchstone Smart Electric Fireplace, known as The Sideline 50", is a versatile option for those seeking an electric insert for a fireplace. Designed for in-wall mounting, it offers a modern aesthetic while aiming to create the cozy atmosphere of a traditional fireplace. The Sideline is equipped with 30 ember color and flame options, providing a realistic and customizable flame effect that can be controlled via a remote, Alexa, or WiFi-enabled apps.

Heating capacity is suitable for areas up to 400 square feet, making it a good supplementary heater for small to medium rooms. However, it may not serve as a primary heating source in colder climates. The installation is straightforward, with the unit being vent-free and capable of fitting existing fireplace openings. Users should ensure there's enough clearance between the fireplace and any overhead items like TVs or mantels.

The fireplace includes both log and crystal hearth options, enhancing the visual appeal. It is energy-efficient with a max power consumption of 1500 watts and offers safety features like a cool-touch exterior and front-facing heater vents. However, it's essential to ensure the appropriate circuit is used as it draws a maximum of 12 amps. Safety and convenience are enhanced with a range of control features, including the ability to adjust flame intensity and set timers. Those who prioritize aesthetics and smart home integration in an electric fireplace will find the Sideline 50" ideal, blending modern technology with classic ambiance.

Rating
9.8
Heating Capacity
Flame Effect and Realism
Installation and Venting

Most important from
3429 reviews

Heating Capacity
Despite its beauty, the heat function is adequate but not overly powerful, making it more suited for ambiance than primary heating.
Flame Effect and Realism
The Sideline flames surpass other brands with their stunning, realistic appearance.
Installation and Venting
Installation is straightforward, but it's advisable to handle with care to avoid damaging the glass facade.
Controls and Features
The fireplace provides a modern aesthetic with customizable flame options, including a unique blue-only flame setting.
#3

R.W.FLAME Electric Fireplace 50 inch Recessed and Wall Mounted,The Thinnest FireplaceLow Noise, Fit for 2 x 6 Stud, Remote Control with Timer,Touch Screen,Adjustable Flame Colors and Speed

Rating
9.7
Size and Dimensions
Heating Capacity
Flame Effect and Realism

Most important from
8713 reviews

Size and Dimensions
The quality is impressive, and the fireplace is a great value for its size and appearance.
Heating Capacity
Despite its modern look, the heater is effective and quiet enough to be a barely heard background sound.
Flame Effect and Realism
The different flame and rock color options, along with the variable heater, make it perfect for creating the right ambiance in any room.
Installation and Venting
The fireplace insert fits perfectly and its installation instructions are easy to follow, making it a breeze for anyone with basic carpentry skills.
Energy Efficiency
Using this heater with community solar power means it's carbon-free, adding an eco-friendly bonus.
Safety Features
It offers a beautiful alternative to a dusty, smoky, dangerous wood-burning fireplace, adding to its appeal.

The R.W.FLAME Electric Fireplace is designed to provide both aesthetic appeal and functional heating to a space. One of its standout features is its ultra-thin design at 3.86 inches depth, making it less intrusive while maintaining a modern look. It's capable of being recessed or wall-mounted, which offers flexibility in installation and ensures it can fit a variety of room styles or sizes.

In terms of heating, it offers two adjustable power modes, 750W and 1500W, which should be sufficient for warming areas up to 400 square feet. This makes it a good option for typical living rooms or bedrooms. However, larger spaces might find the heating output less effective. The fireplace excels in its flame effect realism, offering 12 flame and LED flame bed color modes, along with five flame speed and brightness levels. This customization can enhance the ambiance of the room according to your mood or the season.

Another benefit is the remote control and touch screen operation, allowing for ease of use and convenience. Safety is another priority, with an auto-heat kill feature that prevents overheating, and it has an ETL certification, ensuring it meets certain safety standards. The device is vent-free, which simplifies installation and maintenance but requires it to be used in spaces where good air circulation is present.

While the R.W.FLAME Electric Fireplace is energy-efficient, offering flexibility between warmth and energy savings, it might not be the best option if you are looking to heat spaces beyond its 400 square feet coverage. It includes a limited warranty, which is standard but something to consider depending on your expectations and usage. It is a well-rounded option for those seeking both functionality and style in an electric fireplace insert.

Rating
9.7
Size and Dimensions
Heating Capacity
Flame Effect and Realism

Most important from
8713 reviews

Size and Dimensions
The quality is impressive, and the fireplace is a great value for its size and appearance.
Heating Capacity
Despite its modern look, the heater is effective and quiet enough to be a barely heard background sound.
Flame Effect and Realism
The different flame and rock color options, along with the variable heater, make it perfect for creating the right ambiance in any room.
Installation and Venting
The fireplace insert fits perfectly and its installation instructions are easy to follow, making it a breeze for anyone with basic carpentry skills.
Energy Efficiency
Using this heater with community solar power means it's carbon-free, adding an eco-friendly bonus.
Safety Features
It offers a beautiful alternative to a dusty, smoky, dangerous wood-burning fireplace, adding to its appeal.

Buying Guide for the Best Electric Insert For Fireplace

Choosing the right electric insert for your fireplace can transform your living space into a cozy and warm environment. Electric inserts are a great alternative to traditional wood or gas fireplaces as they are easier to install, require less maintenance, and are more energy-efficient. When selecting an electric insert, it's important to consider several key specifications to ensure you get the best fit for your needs and preferences.
Size and DimensionsThe size and dimensions of the electric insert are crucial because they need to fit perfectly into your existing fireplace opening. Measure the height, width, and depth of your fireplace to ensure the insert will fit. Inserts come in various sizes, so choose one that matches your fireplace dimensions. If you have a larger space, a bigger insert will provide more heat and a more impressive visual effect, while a smaller insert is suitable for compact spaces.
Heating CapacityHeating capacity is measured in British Thermal Units (BTUs) and indicates how much heat the insert can produce. This is important because it determines how effectively the insert can warm your room. For small rooms, an insert with a lower BTU rating (around 4,000-5,000 BTUs) is sufficient. For larger rooms or open-plan areas, look for an insert with a higher BTU rating (up to 10,000 BTUs or more). Consider the size of the area you want to heat when choosing the right heating capacity.
Flame Effect and RealismThe flame effect and realism of the electric insert contribute to the overall ambiance and aesthetic appeal. Some inserts use LED technology to create realistic flame effects, while others may have more basic designs. If you want a more authentic fireplace experience, look for inserts with advanced flame technology that offers adjustable brightness, color options, and realistic ember beds. If the visual effect is less important to you, a simpler model may suffice.
Installation and VentingElectric inserts are generally easier to install than traditional fireplaces, but it's still important to consider the installation process. Some inserts are plug-and-play, requiring only a standard electrical outlet, while others may need hardwiring by a professional. Additionally, electric inserts do not require venting, making them more versatile and easier to install in various locations. Choose an insert that matches your installation capabilities and preferences.
Controls and FeaturesModern electric inserts come with a variety of controls and features that enhance convenience and functionality. Common features include remote controls, adjustable thermostat settings, timers, and multiple heat settings. Some models also offer smart home compatibility, allowing you to control the insert via a smartphone app. Consider which features are important to you and how they will fit into your lifestyle when selecting an electric insert.
Energy EfficiencyEnergy efficiency is an important consideration as it affects your electricity consumption and overall cost of operation. Look for inserts with energy-saving modes, programmable timers, and adjustable heat settings to optimize energy use. An energy-efficient insert will provide adequate warmth while minimizing electricity usage, making it a more sustainable and cost-effective choice in the long run.
Safety FeaturesSafety features are essential to ensure the safe operation of your electric insert. Look for models with automatic shut-off mechanisms, overheat protection, and cool-to-the-touch surfaces. These features help prevent accidents and ensure that the insert operates safely, especially if you have children or pets in the home. Prioritize safety features to ensure peace of mind while using your electric insert.

FAQ

Most Popular Categories Right Now