10 Best Electric Pizza Maker 2025 in the United States

The Breville Smart Oven Pizzaiolo is designed for pizza lovers who want the experience of a brick oven in a countertop appliance. One of its standout features is its impressive temperature range, reaching up to 750°F, which allows for authentic wood-fired style pizzas in just 2 minutes. This rapid cooking is aided by its Element IQ system, which optimally adjusts heating elements based on your pizza type, ensuring an evenly cooked pizza every time.

The variety of preset cooking functions—such as Wood Fired, New York, and Thin & Crispy—adds convenience, making it easy for users to select the right setting for different pizza styles. Plus, the combination of conductive, radiant, and convective heating ensures a charred base and perfectly browned toppings, making your homemade pizzas restaurant-quality.

The Pizzaiolo has a relatively large footprint, weighing 32.3 pounds and requiring a considerable amount of counter space. While it comes with useful accessories like a pizza peel and pan, the price point may be higher than some casual users are willing to spend on a pizza maker. Additionally, it is primarily tailored for pizza, so if you're looking for a more versatile appliance, this might not fit the bill. Some users may find the manual mode challenging, as it requires experimentation to achieve the desired results.

The Presto 03434 Pizzaz Plus Rotating Oven is a versatile pizza maker that stands out with its special Green and Gold edition, making it an attractive addition to any kitchen. Designed to fit a 12-inch pizza, it is compact enough for countertop use, and its lightweight design makes it easy to move and store. With its rotating nonstick tray, the oven ensures even cooking, eliminating the need for preheating, which can be a great time saver. The dual heating elements, located on the top and bottom, offer customizable cooking options, allowing you to select between the top, bottom, or both elements, which is ideal for those who like to experiment with different cooking textures.

The built-in timer and auto shut-off feature add a layer of convenience and safety, preventing overcooking and conserving energy. Cleanup is straightforward thanks to the removable, PFAS-free nonstick pan, which also supports easy storage. While primarily marketed as a pizza oven, its versatility extends to various game day snacks, making it suitable for small gatherings or family use.

However, it lacks a wider temperature range, which might limit more specific cooking requirements, such as baking pastries or roasting. Additionally, as it is an electric pizza maker, it may not achieve the high temperatures that are possible with traditional pizza ovens, which could affect the crispiness some users desire. It's noteworthy that the oven's capacity is limited to a single 12-inch pizza at a time, which might not meet the needs of larger families or those entertaining multiple guests.

Given its ease of use, quick operation, and compact size, this product is ideal for small households, students, or anyone frequently making quick, simple meals. Its strengths in even cooking and easy maintenance make it a popular choice, as reflected in its high customer ratings.

The Cuisinart Indoor Pizza Oven (CPZ-120) is a versatile and quick option for pizza enthusiasts. It allows you to bake 12-inch pizzas in as little as 5 minutes, although it does require up to 30 minutes of preheating. The temperature range is impressive, reaching from 350°F to 700°F, which ensures you can achieve a crispy crust and melted cheese for various pizza styles.

The oven size of 18.39" x 19.17" x 10.75" makes it suitable for most countertops, and the 25-pound weight is manageable for portability. The large viewing window and interior light are convenient for monitoring your pizza without opening the oven. User-friendly features like the integrated cooking guide, easy-to-use controls, and an independent countdown timer make the cooking process straightforward.

The included 12.5-inch pizza stone, deep dish pan, and pizza peel are great additions for both standard and specialty pizzas. However, some users might find the preheating time a bit long. Additionally, there is no mention of an auto shut-off feature, which could be a safety concern. The stainless steel construction and adjustable thermostat add to the durability and functionality of the product. This pizza oven ranks highly among countertop ovens, making it a solid choice for anyone looking to make delicious home-made pizzas.