9 Best Energy Star Toaster 2026 in the United States

The Breville Joule Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro is a versatile kitchen appliance that combines multiple functionalities, including air frying, dehydrating, and traditional baking. Its standout feature is the Element IQ system, which ensures precise cooking by distributing power where needed. The oven also offers 13 pre-set cooking functions, making it user-friendly for a variety of cooking tasks. The guided recipes and voice activation with Google Assistant or Amazon Alexa add convenience, especially for busy home cooks.

Additionally, the Joule Autopilot feature automates multi-step cooking processes, allowing for a hands-free experience. The app connectivity enables remote monitoring and progress notifications, making it easy to keep track of your cooking from anywhere. Constructed with brushed stainless steel, this oven is both durable and stylish, fitting well into modern kitchens.

However, it is important to note that this product is relatively heavy at 38.9 pounds, which may make it less portable. Also, it requires an AC adapter for power, which could be a limitation for users with limited outlet availability. While the oven offers many advanced features, its primary function as a toaster might be overshadowed by its extensive capabilities, potentially making it more suitable for users looking for a multifunctional appliance rather than a straightforward toaster. Finally, the price point and complexity might be higher than traditional toasters, which could be a drawback for users seeking simplicity.

The KitchenAid KMT2115SX is a reliable two-slice toaster with extra-wide slots that handle thicker breads, bagels, and English muffins with ease. Its special bagel setting gently toasts the inside while keeping the outside from getting too dark, which is great if you enjoy bagels. The adjustable browning control offers five levels, allowing you to get your toast from light to dark according to your preference. A high lift lever makes it easy to remove smaller pieces without burning your fingers, and the removable crumb tray helps keep your kitchen cleaner, although it requires hand washing.

Made from brushed stainless steel, this toaster has a sturdy, classic look that fits most kitchens and is easy to wipe down. It weighs just under 5 pounds, making it stable but not too heavy to move. It does not include a dedicated defrost or reheat function, so it may not fully meet the needs of those who frequently toast frozen bread or want quick reheating. The toaster includes a cancel button for safety, providing basic protection during use.

Operating at 900 watts, it balances efficient heating with reasonable energy use. This model is well suited for straightforward, durable use primarily with bagels and everyday bread. For those seeking more specialized functions or larger capacity, exploring other options might be advisable.

The Mueller UltraToast Full Stainless Steel Toaster is a versatile and stylish kitchen gadget suitable for families and individuals who enjoy a variety of toasted foods. Its primary strength lies in its functionality, boasting four extra-wide slots that accommodate different types of bread, bagels, and waffles. The six browning levels offer customizable toasting to suit personal preferences, and the memory recall feature is a convenient touch for frequent users.

The toaster is equipped with essential functions like Cancel, Defrost, and Reheat, ensuring it meets multiple toasting needs efficiently. The LED display and sleek touch buttons make it user-friendly and modern in design. Safety and cleanliness are prioritized with features such as self-centering slot guides and a removable crumb tray, which simplifies maintenance. The under-base cord storage is a thoughtful addition, helping keep countertops tidy.

Crafted from stainless steel, it promises durability and a stylish look for any kitchen. However, at 1300 watts, it might consume more power than simpler models, something to consider for energy-conscious users. The product's size might be a constraint for smaller kitchens, and it may not be the best option for those looking for a compact appliance. This toaster is ideal for larger households or those who frequently entertain guests and require a reliable, multifunctional toaster that combines style with practicality.