10 Best Eyebrow Gels 2025 in the United States

The NYX The Brow Glue is designed for those looking for a strong hold eyebrow gel with a tinted finish. It provides an extreme 16-hour hold that is non-sticky, which means your eyebrows stay in place all day without feeling crunchy or uncomfortable. The tint in the shade Black adds color while still looking natural, making it suitable if you want both definition and control. The formula dries down nicely and is flake-resistant, so you won’t have to worry about powdery residue throughout the day.

The brush is typical of brow mascaras, allowing for precise application to shape and set each hair individually. Being vegan and cruelty-free adds a positive ethical aspect. However, if you prefer a lighter hold or more flexible feel, this product might feel a bit too firm for casual or softer brow looks. Also, the black tint is quite bold, so it may not be ideal for very light-haired users who want a subtle effect.

This gel is well-suited for anyone needing a reliable, long-lasting brow gel that holds brows firmly while adding color with a natural finish.

The Benefit Cosmetics Gimme Brow + Volumizing Eyebrow Gel in shade 4.5 Neutral Deep Brown is a solid choice for those looking to enhance their eyebrows. The gel provides a matte finish which is ideal for a natural look. Its formula is designed to be long-lasting, which means it should stay put throughout your day without needing frequent touch-ups. This is a great strength for those who have busy schedules and need their makeup to last.

The color, a neutral deep brown, is versatile and should suit a variety of skin tones and hair colors within that range, helping to create fuller-looking brows with a natural tint. The product's defining feature is its volumizing capability, which helps to make sparse brows look fuller and more defined. The brush type is another highlight, as it is designed to catch even the finest hairs, allowing for precise application.

However, there are a couple of potential drawbacks. First, the hold might not be strong enough for those with very unruly brows or in highly humid conditions. Secondly, while the tint is versatile, it might not be the perfect match for everyone, particularly those with very light or very dark hair. Despite these minor points, the Benefit Cosmetics Gimme Brow + Volumizing Eyebrow Gel is a strong contender for anyone seeking a long-lasting, natural-looking enhancement to their brows.

Benefit Gimme Brow Volumizing Fiber Gel in Medium Dark Warm is designed to add volume and shape to your eyebrows using a precision tip brush that allows for easy, controlled application. The gel’s formula includes natural fibers that help create the look of fuller brows without appearing heavy or fake. Its tint matches medium dark warm tones well, making it suitable for those with similar hair colors.

The brush type is a small, precise tip that helps define each brow hair for a natural finish rather than clumpy or rigid lines. This gel is lightweight and easy to blend, making it a good option for everyday use or for people who prefer a natural brow look instead of something too bold or dramatic.

Benefit Gimme Brow is a solid choice for those seeking a natural enhancement with added volume and a warm tint, but it might not fully satisfy users looking for maximum hold or waterproof formulas.