10 Best Eyebrow Pencils 2025 in the United States

The Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz in Medium Brown is designed for anyone looking to shape and fill their eyebrows with precision. Its fine-tipped pencil is great for creating hair-like strokes, giving a natural and detailed look rather than a blocky or overly filled brow. The texture is a balanced mix of wax and color, which helps the pencil glide smoothly and stay put throughout the day, even resisting sweat. This means you can expect good longevity without frequent touch-ups. The matte finish keeps eyebrows looking natural and well-defined.

While Medium Brown is a popular and versatile shade, the brand offers a total of 10 shades, making it easier to find a match for different hair colors. One potential downside is that the pencil form means it requires sharpening, which can be less convenient compared to retractable options. Also, if you prefer a softer or creamier formula, this wax-based texture might feel a bit firm. This product is a solid choice for those who want precise application and a natural finish that lasts well.

The Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz in Dark Brown is a standout choice for anyone looking to achieve well-defined brows. One of its key strengths is its ultra-slim design, which allows for precise detailing, making it perfect for those who want to fill in sparse areas or create a natural look. The wax formula closely mimics brow hair, ensuring a seamless finish that works well for all skin types.

Plus, with a matte finish and sweat-proof feature, it promises longevity, so you can trust that your brows will stay in place throughout the day. The availability of 10 shades means there’s a good fit for many hair colors and undertones, allowing for a personalized touch. However, one potential drawback is that the pencil may require frequent sharpening for optimal use, which could be inconvenient for some.

Additionally, the price point might be higher compared to drugstore options, which could be a consideration for budget-conscious shoppers. The Brow Wiz is particularly suited for makeup enthusiasts who value precision and quality in their brow products, while those who prefer a more budget-friendly or user-friendly option might want to explore alternatives.

The e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil is a popular choice for shaping and defining eyebrows, especially for those who want a natural yet polished look. It comes in a neutral brown shade that suits many hair colors and skin tones. The pencil features a fine, precision tip that makes it easy to apply color smoothly and fill in sparse areas with control, helping you create either a bold or subtle brow look.

One end of the pencil has a spoolie brush, which is great for grooming and blending the product for a more natural finish. The texture delivers rich color that is budge-proof, meaning it tends to stay put through the day without smudging. Being dual-ended, it offers convenience by combining application and blending tools in one. Additionally, the formula is vegan, cruelty-free, and free from harsh toxins, appealing to those who prefer ethical beauty products.

The neutral brown shade works well for many, though it may not perfectly match very dark or very light hair tones. While the pencil holds up well for daily wear, oily skin or humid conditions might influence its longevity. This pencil is ideal for beginners or anyone looking for an affordable, easy-to-use product that delivers natural-looking brows with minimal effort.