10 Best Eyebrow Pencils 2025 in the United States

The L'Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer is an eyebrow pencil designed with an ultra-fine mechanical tip that helps you draw tiny, natural-looking brow hairs. This precision tip is great for filling in sparse spots and creating defined yet soft brows, especially in the Brunette shade which suits darker hair tones nicely. Its texture is smooth and easy to apply, allowing for controlled strokes without dragging on the skin. One of the standout features is its waterproof formula, meaning your brows are less likely to smudge or fade throughout the day, making it a reliable choice if you need long-lasting wear.

The pencil also includes a built-in spoolie brush that helps blend the color and shape your brows for a polished finish. Because it’s a mechanical pencil, the tip is thinner and more delicate compared to traditional pencils, requiring a gentle hand to avoid breakage. While it’s marketed as natural-looking, those seeking a more dramatic or bold brow might find this pencil less suitable. Its formula is gentle enough for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, which adds to its appeal.

This eyebrow pencil is a solid pick for anyone wanting a subtle, natural brow enhancement that lasts, especially suited for everyday use and those with sensitive skin or eyes.

The L'Oreal Paris Makeup Brow Definer is a good choice if you're looking for an eyebrow pencil that helps create natural-looking brows. Its ultra-fine, mechanical tip is designed to draw tiny brow hairs, which makes it easier to fill in sparse spots with precision. The soft black color suits those wanting defined but subtle brows. The pencil includes a built-in spoolie brush, which helps style and blend the brows for a polished finish.

One key strength is that it is waterproof, so your brows are more likely to stay put throughout the day without smudging, and it's suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. The texture appears smooth and natural, not heavy or cakey, which helps achieve a soft finish rather than a harsh line. However, since it is an ultra-fine tip, it may take a little extra time to fill very large sparse areas compared to thicker pencils. Also, while the waterproof feature adds durability, some users might find removal a bit more challenging.

If you prefer quick application or intense color payoff, this might not be the fastest option. This pencil works well for anyone wanting a natural, long-lasting look with easy shaping, especially if you value a product gentle on sensitive eyes.

The e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil is a popular choice for shaping and defining eyebrows, especially for those who want a natural yet polished look. It comes in a neutral brown shade that suits many hair colors and skin tones. The pencil features a fine, precision tip that makes it easy to apply color smoothly and fill in sparse areas with control, helping you create either a bold or subtle brow look.

One end of the pencil has a spoolie brush, which is great for grooming and blending the product for a more natural finish. The texture delivers rich color that is budge-proof, meaning it tends to stay put through the day without smudging. Being dual-ended, it offers convenience by combining application and blending tools in one. Additionally, the formula is vegan, cruelty-free, and free from harsh toxins, appealing to those who prefer ethical beauty products.

The neutral brown shade works well for many, though it may not perfectly match very dark or very light hair tones. While the pencil holds up well for daily wear, oily skin or humid conditions might influence its longevity. This pencil is ideal for beginners or anyone looking for an affordable, easy-to-use product that delivers natural-looking brows with minimal effort.