10 Best Eyebrow Pencils 2025 in the United States

The Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz in Soft Brown is a great choice if you have light brown hair with either warm or cool undertones. Its color is designed to blend naturally with your brows, making it a good option for subtle definition rather than bold, heavy color. The ultra-slim, retractable pencil tip is one of its strongest points—it offers precise application and fine detail, which helps mimic natural eyebrow hairs rather than looking like a drawn line.

The wax-based formula ensures the pencil glides on smoothly and is comfortable on all skin types without smudging easily, so your brows can stay in place throughout the day. With a smudge-proof and long-wearing finish, you won’t have to worry about frequent touch-ups. The product is cruelty-free, which adds an ethical benefit if that’s important to you. On the downside, the pencil is quite slim, so it might take a bit longer to fill in very sparse or thick eyebrows compared to thicker pencils or powders. Also, while the wax formula works well for most, those with very oily skin might find it less durable in extreme heat or humidity.

Available in 10 shades, this pencil covers a nice range, but if your hair color falls outside of the common shades, finding an exact match might be challenging. This pencil is well suited for anyone looking for a detailed, natural-looking brow product that lasts all day without fuss.

The Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Definer in Dark Brown offers a versatile solution for eyebrow shaping and filling. Its triangular tip stands out, providing three different-sized edges that cater to various application needs – the flat side for shading, the medium side for defining, and the fine tip for detailed, hair-like strokes. This design adds a lot of flexibility and precision in creating the desired brow look.

The formula strikes a good balance between wax and pigment, making it easy to blend and apply without looking too harsh or unnatural. The included spoolie brush is another useful feature, designed to blend the product seamlessly into your brow hairs for a soft, natural finish. This all-in-one tool is particularly handy for on-the-go application, a plus for those with busy lifestyles.

The NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil in Espresso is a strong choice for anyone looking to shape and fill their brows with precision. Its standout feature is the super skinny retractable tip, which lets you draw very fine lines that mimic natural brow hairs, making it easier to achieve a realistic look. The texture is designed to be smooth and natural-looking, avoiding heavy or cakey buildup. This pencil comes in a waterproof formula, helping your brows stay put throughout the day without smudging, which is great for long-lasting wear.

The color Espresso is a deep, dark brown that works well for those with similarly dark hair tones, and NYX offers a broad shade range to suit many users. Being cruelty-free and vegan is a plus for those who prefer ethical beauty products. Some users might find the ultra-fine tip requires a steady hand to use effectively, and since it’s a pencil form, it may need periodic sharpening or twisting to maintain the perfect tip shape. Also, while the waterproof feature helps with longevity, removing it might need a good makeup remover.

This pencil is ideal for anyone wanting natural, defined brows with detailed control, especially if they prefer a lightweight, smudge-resistant product that lasts all day.