10 Best Eyelash Mascaras 2025 in the United States

The Lancôme Monsieur Big Volumizing Mascara is designed to provide dramatic volume and length to your lashes. Its key strength lies in its volumizing formula, which claims to offer up to 12 times more volume and 24-hour wear. This makes it an excellent choice for anyone looking for a bold, false lash effect without the hassle of applying false lashes.

The ultra-black pigments and smudge-proof, flake-proof formula contribute to a long-lasting and intense look, which is perfect for all-day wear or special occasions. The wavy fiber bristles on the brush are designed to evenly coat each lash, reducing the chances of clumping and ensuring a smooth application. Additionally, the mascara is paraben-free, which may be appealing to those who are cautious about certain chemicals in their beauty products.

However, one potential downside could be the ease of removal, as long-wearing mascaras often require more effort to take off completely. If ease of removal is a priority for you, you might need a strong eye makeup remover. In summary, this mascara is ideal for those seeking significant volume and a dramatic look, but be prepared for a bit more effort when it comes to removal.

The Lancôme Définicils Mascara is designed for those seeking natural-looking lashes with added definition and length. The formula contains panthenol and vitamin B5, which condition the lashes while preventing clumping, ensuring a smooth application from root to tip. The black color is suitable for everyday wear, giving a noticeable but subtle enhancement to your lashes.

The fine, comb-like brush is a standout feature, ensuring each lash is coated evenly without excess product, which is ideal for a gradual, natural look. Longevity is one of its strengths, as it promises long wear without budging or flaking, making it reliable for all-day use. Additionally, it is fragrance-free and ophthalmologist-tested, making it safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

On the downside, users might find that its natural look might not be dramatic enough for those who prefer a more voluminous or intense lash effect. Also, while the mascara is designed to be long-lasting, it might require a bit more effort to remove fully at the end of the day despite not being a waterproof formula. This mascara is best suited for individuals who prioritize a refined, clean lash look over dramatic volume and for those who value conditioning benefits in their mascara.

The Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara Set offers two full-size mascaras in classic black, making it great value for anyone wanting dramatic and voluminous lashes. The formula features film-forming polymers that help lock in curl and peptides that condition lashes, adding some care benefits beyond just appearance. The hourglass-shaped brush is designed to separate and coat each lash thoroughly, which enhances volume and length effectively.

This mascara is also ophthalmologist tested and safe for contact lens wearers, a plus for sensitive eyes. Being cruelty-free is another appeal if you prefer ethical beauty products. In terms of longevity, it holds curl well thanks to its polymer components, though like many mascaras with intense pigment, removal might require a bit more effort and a good makeup remover to avoid lash breakage. The rich black color is highly pigmented, giving a bold look suitable for those who want their lashes to stand out. However, some users may find the formula a bit thick or prone to clumping if not applied carefully.

This set is ideal for anyone seeking a dramatic, long-lasting mascara while also appreciating lash conditioning and ethical considerations.