10 Best Eyeliner Pencils 2025 in the United States

The Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil in 'Perversion' is a standout product for those seeking a versatile and reliable eyeliner. One of its major strengths lies in its award-winning, long-lasting, and waterproof formula. It promises up to 16 hours of wear, making it ideal for long days or events where you need your makeup to stay put. The color 'Perversion' is a matte blackest black, offering a bold and intense look that suits various styles and occasions.

Another benefit is its creamy, glide-on formula enriched with hydrating ingredients like Vitamin E, jojoba oil, and cottonseed oil, which not only ensure smooth application but also condition the delicate skin around your eyes. This eyeliner is smudge-proof and transfer-proof, reducing the need for frequent touch-ups. Additionally, it can be used in multiple ways, such as an eye liner, eye shadow, or base, adding to its versatility.

While its creamy texture makes for easy application, some users might find it can smudge during application if not careful. Furthermore, the pencil's softness might require frequent sharpening, which can be a minor inconvenience. Those looking for vibrant color options will appreciate the variety in this product line, though the specific color in this review is limited to matte black. This eyeliner is well-suited for those who prioritize long wear, ease of use, and a bold finish, with the added benefit of hydration and skin conditioning.

The Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner is a solid choice if you want an eyeliner pencil that lasts throughout the day without smudging or fading. It’s designed to be waterproof and transfer-proof, offering up to 24 hours of wear, which is great if you need your eye makeup to stay put from morning till night. The formula glides on smoothly, making application easy even if you’re not an expert. Plus, it comes with a built-in sharpener and smudger, so you can create anything from a subtle line to a more dramatic look. The color black is rich and intense, suitable for defining your eyes clearly. You can choose between matte or shimmering finishes, adding some variety to your makeup style.

It’s also ophthalmologist tested, so it’s safe for use around the eyes, including the waterline. On the downside, while having a built-in sharpener is convenient, sharpening a pencil may still take a bit more time compared to retractable eyeliners. Also, the product comes in a pack of two, which is good value but might be more than needed if you just want one pencil.

This eyeliner represents a dependable option for anyone looking for long-lasting, smudge-proof eye makeup with ease of use and safety in mind.

The Urban Decay 24/7 Waterproof Waterline Eyeliner Pencil in the shade Tootsie (a medium brown matte) is designed for those who want a long-lasting, versatile eyeliner that works well for tightlining and defining the eyes. This pencil is waterproof and made specifically to be safe on the waterline, meaning it’s gentle enough to apply inside the eye without irritation. Its creamy formula glides on smoothly without tugging, which makes it easier to apply even if you’re not an expert. Thanks to hydrating ingredients like Vitamin E and jojoba oil, it also helps keep the delicate skin around your eyes nourished.

The color is a neutral medium brown, great for adding subtle definition without being too harsh, making it suitable for everyday looks. The finish is matte, so it doesn’t shine or smudge easily, which helps the eyeliner stay put throughout the day and night. Urban Decay claims it can last up to 24 hours without needing touch-ups, supported by its waterproof, sweat-proof, and transfer-resistant properties. Additionally, it can be used in multiple ways – not just as an eyeliner but also as a base for eyeshadow, which adds to its versatility.

While the pencil is praised for its smooth application, very creamy formulas sometimes require sharpening more often, which can be a minor inconvenience. Also, although it performs well on the waterline, some users with very sensitive eyes might still want to test it first. This eyeliner pencil is a reliable choice for those seeking a dependable, long-wearing, and easy-to-use product with a natural color that enhances the eyes without overpowering them.