10 Best Fly Reels 2025 in the United States

The Hatch Outdoors Iconic Plus Large Arbor Fly Reel is a solid choice for fly fishing enthusiasts who want a durable and reliable reel. Made from anodized aluminum, it offers good strength and corrosion resistance, which is important for long-term use, especially in different water conditions. Weighing about 1.2 pounds, it strikes a reasonable balance between sturdiness and portability, though it may feel a bit heavy compared to ultra-light reels. The large arbor design helps with faster line retrieval and reduces line memory, making it easier to manage your fly line during fishing.

It features a drag system designed for smooth performance. The reel is ambidextrous, so it suits both left- and right-handed anglers. Its build quality is enhanced by stainless steel or aluminum bearings, which contribute to smooth operation and durability. However, the reel is not compatible with older model spools, which could limit upgrade options if you already own previous Hatch models. It also comes with handy extras like a reel pouch and a cap wrench for adjustments.

Though it may not be the lightest or feature the most advanced drag system, its strong construction, user-friendly features, and lifetime warranty make it a dependable choice for both casual and serious fly fishers.

The Moonshine Rod Company The Creede Fly Fishing Reel is a well-constructed option for both novice and experienced anglers. Its fully machined 6061 forged aluminum body is robust and built to withstand various fishing conditions, making it a durable choice for outdoor enthusiasts. The large arbor design not only increases the retrieve rate, which is beneficial for quickly reeling in fish, but also allows for a greater line capacity, reducing the chances of tangles thanks to a larger center spool diameter. Additionally, the reel features a sealed carbon fiber stacked disc drag system, enhancing its performance and reliability in diverse environments.

One of the standout aspects is the ease of converting the retrieve from left to right hand, catering to individual preferences without needing special tools. The G10 handle adds a comfortable grip, which can be appreciated during extended fishing sessions.

While the reel is lightweight at 5.15 ounces, which is a plus for portability, some users may find it slightly less suited for heavier fishing lines or larger fish species due to its 3/4 size classification. The price point, while backed by a lifetime warranty, might also be seen as a drawback for those on a tighter budget. The reel's popularity is reflected in its moderately ranked position on sales charts, which could indicate competition from other brands. This reel is best suited for anglers looking for a lightweight, easy-to-use option that performs well in various fishing situations.

The Redington Behemoth Fly Fishing Reel is a strong choice for anglers who want a versatile reel suitable for both freshwater and saltwater fishing. It comes in a 7/8 size that fits well with medium-weight trout rods but can also scale up for larger saltwater game. At just 0.65 pounds, it’s lightweight enough to keep your setup balanced without feeling bulky. A standout feature is its heavy-duty carbon fiber drag system, which provides reliable and powerful resistance when fighting strong fish. This drag system helps prevent line breakage and gives you better control during the catch.

The large arbor spool design allows for quicker line retrieval and reduces the chance of line memory, meaning your line won’t twist or tangle as easily. The carbon construction is durable and built to withstand exposure to both fresh and saltwater environments, making it a solid choice for long-term use. The ambidextrous handle with a soft grip gives comfortable handling whether you’re left- or right-handed. Line capacity is generous for its size, holding 200 yards of 20 lb backing line in the 7/8 model, which is plenty for most fishing situations.

On the downside, the reel uses a die-cast construction that, while unique, may not feel as premium or lightweight as some machined aluminum reels. Some advanced anglers might prefer more finely tuned drag controls or a lighter overall weight for long days on the water. Also, although it’s labeled beginner-friendly, total beginners should still get comfortable with drag adjustment to avoid line issues. This reel delivers a strong, reliable drag and a solid build for anglers looking for a versatile, multipurpose fly reel that can handle a variety of fishing environments without being overly complicated.