10 Best Ice Cube Trays 2025 in the United States

The DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray set is designed to meet a variety of needs in the kitchen, especially for those who love to entertain or need ice for beverages. Made from premium, BPA-free silicone and plastic, these trays are robust and durable, designed to withstand long-term use without breaking. One of the standout features is the ease of ice removal, thanks to the soft silicone construction and wider base, making it a breeze to push the cubes out without any bending or twisting. This is great for anyone who finds traditional trays frustrating.

The trays come with a convenient lid that helps prevent spills and keeps the ice cubes fresh by avoiding freezer odors. Additionally, the included storage bin and scoop add to the convenience, allowing users to manage their ice more efficiently.

However, there are a few considerations. While the trays are labeled as dishwasher safe, some users might find that hand washing is more effective in maintaining the longevity of the silicone material. The trays are designed to be stackable, which is a plus for space-saving in the freezer, but stacking can sometimes lead to sticking if not handled carefully. This product fits well for families, party hosts, and those who enjoy mixing cocktails at home. The versatility to fill the trays with various liquids, from fruit juices to cocktails, is a nice touch.

The ChefAide Ice Cube Tray with Lid is a versatile and practical choice for anyone needing a reliable way to make ice cubes. With four trays included, each capable of producing 14 cubes, you can make a total of 56 ice cubes, making it suitable for parties or everyday use. The combination of silicone and plastic ensures durability, as the silicone bottoms allow for easy release of the cubes without the need for twisting or excessive force, which can often be a hassle with traditional rigid plastic trays.

This design is particularly handy for those using ice regularly for cocktails, coffee, or even baby food. The soft silicone bottom makes it easier to pop out the cubes, reducing the risk of breakage and increasing the tray's lifespan. The trays come with removable lids that help prevent freezer odors from contaminating the ice and enable efficient stacking, saving space in your freezer and keeping it organized.

A minor downside is the need to wait about 30 seconds before removing the lid to make it effortless, which might be slightly inconvenient for some users. Additionally, the rectangular shape of the ice cubes may not be everyone's preference. Despite these minor drawbacks, the easy-clean, dishwasher-safe design, and combination of materials make this product a strong contender for anyone looking for robust, user-friendly ice cube trays.

The ChefAide Ice Cube Tray set includes two durable trays made from a combination of plastic and silicone, offering a good balance of sturdiness and flexibility. The plastic top half keeps the shape firm, while the soft silicone bottom makes it easy to pop out ice cubes without twisting or struggling. Each tray makes 14 rectangular cubes, which are a nice size for many drinks like cocktails, coffee, soda, or whiskey. The trays come with removable lids, which help keep ice fresh and prevent freezer smells from affecting the cubes. The lids also allow the trays to stack neatly, saving space and keeping your freezer organized. These trays are fairly easy to use: fill to the max line, cover, freeze, then wait briefly before opening to release the ice smoothly. They are dishwasher safe, making cleanup simple. The compact size, measuring about 10 inches long and 4 inches wide, fits well in most freezers.

Some drawbacks include the rectangular shape, which might not be ideal for those who prefer traditional ice cube shapes, and the need to wait about 30 seconds after freezing before opening the lid to avoid difficulty. Although the trays are sturdy, the plastic top part is less flexible, so some care is needed when handling. This product is well suited for anyone looking for reliable, easy-release ice trays with a lid to keep ice clean and fresh. It is ideal for users who want neat stacking and straightforward cleaning. Those who prefer very large or unusually shaped ice cubes might want to consider other options.