10 Best Liquid Eyeliners 2025 in the United States

The NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner in Dark Chocolate is a waterproof liquid eyeliner that stands out for its precise, flexible brush tip, which makes it easy to apply smooth, accurate lines. The formula is vegan and cruelty-free, ideal for those who prefer ethical products. This eyeliner offers a matte finish in a rich dark brown shade, providing a natural yet defined look as a softer alternative to harsh black.

It features waterproof and smudge-resistant properties that allow it to last up to 24 hours without flaking, making it great for long-lasting wear throughout the day. Waterproof formulas like this typically dry quickly, helping to avoid smudging right after application. However, such formulas can sometimes require more effort to remove, so using a good makeup remover designed for waterproof eye makeup is recommended to prevent irritation.

If you want a reliable, cruelty-free eyeliner for precise, long-lasting eye looks in a softer color than black, this product is a strong choice.

The stila Stay All Day® Smudge & Set Waterproof Gel Eye Liner is a versatile option for those seeking a reliable liquid eyeliner. The applicator is a gel-based pencil, which makes it easy to apply smoothly without skipping. This feature can help you create various looks, whether you prefer a precise line or a smudged, smoky effect. The formula is impressive—it’s waterline-safe and waterproof, which means it won’t budge even in humid conditions or after a long day. Plus, it promises a long-lasting wear of up to 12 hours, so you won't need frequent touch-ups.

The color, Stingray Black, is rich and intense, providing immediate color payoff in just one swipe. This is great for those who need a bold look without much effort. It sets quickly and becomes smudge-resistant, making it a reliable choice for all-day wear. However, one potential drawback is that it might not be the easiest to remove due to its waterproof nature. You may need a good makeup remover to take it off completely. Another point to consider is its retractable design, which is convenient, but you must be careful to close the cap tightly to prevent the product from drying out.

In summary, the stila Stay All Day® Gel Eye Liner is a top choice for those looking for a long-lasting, versatile eyeliner that can handle both precise and smudged looks, though its ease of removal could be a minor inconvenience.

The Too Faced Better Than Sex Easy Glide Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner is a standout product for those seeking a highly pigmented, smudge-proof option. Its precise applicator allows for easy and accurate application, ideal for creating sharp lines or elaborate designs. The rich black color is bold and ensures a striking look that lasts all day without fading, smudging, or flaking, thanks to its long-wearing, waterproof formula. This makes it an excellent choice for those with busy lifestyles or those who need their makeup to withstand various conditions, including humidity or tears.

Additionally, the product is cruelty-free, which may appeal to ethically conscious consumers. The intense pigmentation and long-lasting formula can make removal a bit challenging, potentially requiring a good-quality makeup remover. The drying time is fairly quick, which is great for avoiding accidental smudges during application, but it also means you need to work swiftly to achieve your desired look. People who prefer a natural finish and are looking for an eyeliner that delivers on performance and durability will likely find this product highly satisfactory.