10 Best Mahi Mahi Trolling Lures 2025 in the United States

The Madmacs 200mm High Speed Sinking Trolling Lure is designed with serious anglers targeting mahi-mahi, bluefin tuna, yellowfin, and wahoo in mind. Its 8-inch length and 11-1/4 ounce weight make it a substantial lure that can dive between 5 to 12 feet, thanks to its sinking action, allowing it to reach deeper water where these fast, powerful fish often roam. The lure’s metal construction adds durability, and the fitted BKK Diablo singles hooks (size 11/0) are strong and sharp, improving your chances of a secure catch.

The Phantom color is a balanced choice that mimics baitfish without being overly flashy, which can work well in various water conditions. Anglers trolling at speeds between 5 to 20 knots will find this lure performs reliably, offering a realistic action that attracts aggressive strikes. Its relatively heavy weight and size may not be ideal for beginner anglers or those trolling in very shallow waters.

Priced and positioned as a specialized lure rather than a casual fishing option, it may not be the top-selling lure in its category. For those seeking a strong, versatile lure for offshore trolling targeting large game fish, this Madmacs lure provides a solid balance of action, size, and build quality.

The Nomad Design Madmacs is a 6-inch, sinking trolling minnow lure designed for high-speed fishing, especially effective for species like mackerel. Its vibrant Orange Mackerel color helps attract fish visually, and it produces a strong vibrating action that works well across a wide range of trolling speeds—from as slow as 5 knots up to 15 knots. This versatility makes it useful whether you’re trolling slowly or fast. A standout feature is its Autotune system, which keeps the lure running straight and true at various speeds, maintaining an optimal depth between about 3 to 8 feet depending on trolling speed.

The lure’s build combines a tough ABS foam core with a stainless steel plate, making it durable enough for challenging offshore conditions. It also comes equipped with strong BKK hooks and heavy-duty split rings, ready for handling big, aggressive fish. Additionally, the lure can be used for casting, with an internal rattle to help attract predators when retrieved through the water.

Weighing only 6 ounces and designed primarily for trolling, it might not be the best choice if you want a heavier lure for very deep or heavy-current fishing. Also, while the vibrant color suits certain fish, other fishing conditions might call for different color options. This lure is a solid pick for anglers targeting mackerel and similar species who need a reliable, versatile trolling lure that performs well at different speeds and depths.

The Nomad Design DTX Minnow 200 Heavy Duty SNK 8 is a metal deep-diving trolling lure designed primarily for saltwater fishing, targeting species like tuna and mackerel. It measures 8 inches and weighs 0.35 pounds, making it a fairly substantial lure that can handle the demands of strong, fast-moving fish. The standout feature is its Autotune DTX technology, which helps the lure maintain a natural swimming action without the need for constant manual adjustments. This makes it easier to troll efficiently at speeds over 12 knots, which is useful when targeting fast fish like mahi-mahi or wahoo. The color option, named Wahooligan, is designed to attract predatory fish with a vibrant, eye-catching finish. The lure comes equipped with a J hook that has a spear point style, which is reliable for hooking and holding fish.

The lure is heavier, which means it might require a strong rod and reel setup and could be less suitable for beginners or those fishing in shallow or calm waters. Its price point reflects its advanced features and may be higher than basic lures. This lure is suitable for anglers looking for a durable, high-performance option for trolling in deep saltwater conditions, especially when targeting larger, fast species.