10 Best Makeup Pencil Sharpener 2025 in the United States

The Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner features a built-in sharpener designed for convenience and quick touch-ups on the go. This sharpener is compact and perfectly sized for the pencil, ensuring the tip is pointed for precise application. The blade quality is decent for a built-in sharpener, providing a clean and fine point, though it may not be as sharp or durable as a dedicated external sharpener.

Because it is integrated, there is no separate shavings container, so sharpening can be a bit messier compared to standalone sharpeners that collect shavings. Cleaning the sharpener might be challenging since it is part of the pencil and not removable, which could lead to buildup over time. The built-in sharpener is made to last the lifespan of the pencil but is not designed for heavy or repeated use beyond that.

This sharpener works well for users seeking a convenient all-in-one makeup pencil solution, especially for quick fixes during the day without carrying extra tools. However, for those wanting a sharper blade, less mess, or a longer-lasting sharpener, a separate, high-quality pencil sharpener might be a better choice. The built-in sharpener improves the pencil’s portability and ease of use, but comes with trade-offs in cleanliness and sharpening precision.

The Julep Cosmetic Makeup Pencil Sharpener is designed for those who regularly use eyeliners, lip liners, and eyebrow pencils. Its standout feature is the high-quality carbon steel blades which ensure a sharp point without breaking the pencil tips. This is particularly beneficial for users who often struggle with dull or broken tips from other sharpeners. The built-in shavings container is another plus, as it keeps everything tidy and makes clean-up easy, especially when you're on the go. It's compact and travel-friendly, addressing a common concern for makeup lovers who want to maintain their looks while out and about.

There are a few considerations to keep in mind. While it excels with wood and plastic pencils, some users might find that it takes a bit of practice to get a perfect point with gel pencils, as gel formulas can be trickier to sharpen. Additionally, while the shavings collector is a great feature, it may require occasional manual cleaning to prevent buildup. The product is marketed as durable, but like any sharpener, the blades can wear over time, so users should expect to replace it eventually.

This sharpener is an excellent choice for makeup enthusiasts looking for a reliable tool that delivers consistent results. It's especially tailored for those who prioritize cleanliness and ease of use, but users of gel pencils should be prepared to adjust their sharpening technique to achieve the best results.

The Palladio Double Barrel 3 in 1 Cosmetic Pencil Sharpener is a versatile tool designed for anyone who frequently uses lip liners, eyeliners, or brow pencils. One of its standout features is the stainless steel blade, which offers durability and precision, ensuring that your pencils are sharpened to a fine point for detailed application. Additionally, the sharpener accommodates both small and larger pencil sizes, making it convenient for a variety of products.

The design includes a protective cover that helps contain shavings, minimizing mess, and there's a handy pick included to assist in cleaning out any stubborn shavings. This is a thoughtful addition, as it simplifies maintenance and keeps your workspace tidy. Moreover, the commitment to clean beauty with paraben-free and cruelty-free assurances enhances its appeal to users who are conscious about the ingredients in their beauty tools.

While the manual operation is straightforward, it may not be as quick or effortless as some electric sharpeners, especially for users who prefer a faster routine. Some individuals might also find the size of the sharpener a bit larger than expected for on-the-go use. In terms of durability, while it’s made from quality materials, heavy daily use could lead to blade wear over time, which is a consideration for those who use it extensively.