10 Best Makeup Pencil Sharpener 2025 in the United States

The Julep Cosmetic Makeup Pencil Sharpener is designed for those who regularly use eyeliners, lip liners, and eyebrow pencils. Its standout feature is the high-quality carbon steel blades which ensure a sharp point without breaking the pencil tips. This is particularly beneficial for users who often struggle with dull or broken tips from other sharpeners. The built-in shavings container is another plus, as it keeps everything tidy and makes clean-up easy, especially when you're on the go. It's compact and travel-friendly, addressing a common concern for makeup lovers who want to maintain their looks while out and about.

There are a few considerations to keep in mind. While it excels with wood and plastic pencils, some users might find that it takes a bit of practice to get a perfect point with gel pencils, as gel formulas can be trickier to sharpen. Additionally, while the shavings collector is a great feature, it may require occasional manual cleaning to prevent buildup. The product is marketed as durable, but like any sharpener, the blades can wear over time, so users should expect to replace it eventually.

This sharpener is an excellent choice for makeup enthusiasts looking for a reliable tool that delivers consistent results. It's especially tailored for those who prioritize cleanliness and ease of use, but users of gel pencils should be prepared to adjust their sharpening technique to achieve the best results.

The e.l.f. Dual-Pencil Sharpener is an essential tool designed for sharpening various sizes of makeup pencils. The sharpener's standout feature is its dual blades which accommodate both standard and larger pencils, making it versatile for different makeup products. The blade quality ensures a clean and precise cut. Its compact and travel-friendly size adds to the convenience for users on the go.

This sharpener includes a small, detachable sharpener as a bonus, providing additional functionality. The shavings container is easy to remove and clean, which is further aided by a small pick for reaching stubborn shavings. Durability is positive, with the plastic build being lightweight yet sturdy. Additionally, the product is 100% vegan and cruelty-free, aligning with ethical consumer values.

However, the plastic construction, while durable, may not be as long-lasting as metal alternatives. The ease of cleaning is a strong point, but some users mention that the shavings compartment might be small for heavy use. It is an affordable, reliable tool that suits everyday makeup needs both at home and during travel.

The Sun's Out Beauty Precision 2-in-1 Cosmetic Pencil Sharpener is a versatile tool designed for makeup enthusiasts who use both standard and jumbo cosmetic pencils. One of its standout features is the dual-size holes, which accommodate a variety of pencil sizes, making it suitable for most users. The high-quality stainless-steel blades ensure an effective sharpening process, allowing you to create a fine point while minimizing waste. This can save you both product and money over time, a definite plus for anyone who uses expensive makeup pencils.

The sharpener's durable aluminum body adds to its longevity, and the diamond pattern offers a non-slip grip that can be very helpful during use. It is compact in size, easily fitting into most makeup bags without taking up much space. Additionally, the design is quite simple to clean, which is always a bonus for maintaining hygiene.

There are a few considerations to keep in mind. While the sharpener fits most standard pencils, it may not work with certain non-standard sizes from different manufacturers, which could be a drawback if you own a diverse collection of cosmetic pencils. You also need to chill gel pencils before sharpening to achieve optimal results, which might not be convenient for everyone.