4 Best Martha Stewart Pillows 2025 in the United States

The Martha Stewart Hotel Collection Medium Soft Feather Down Pillows offer a blend of comfort and luxury. With a fill material comprised of feathers and down, these pillows strike a balance between softness and support, making them suitable for various sleeping positions, including back, side, and stomach sleepers. The medium-soft loft ensures they provide adequate support without being too firm or too plush.

The 500 thread count damask stripe fabric cover, made from 100% cotton, is breathable and promotes airflow, which helps maintain a comfortable sleeping temperature throughout the night. Additionally, the pillows feature a polyester outer wrap to prevent feathers from poking through, enhancing sleep quality and comfort. One notable strength is the use of the FreshLOFT process, which cleans the down and feathers to remove dust, dander, and potential allergens, appealing to those with allergies or sensitivities.

These pillows are also Oeko-Tex certified, ensuring they meet high safety and environmental standards. The elegant silver embroidery and matching piping add a touch of sophistication, making them a stylish addition to any bedroom decor. However, some users might find the medium-soft firmness level insufficient for their needs if they prefer a firmer pillow. Also, as with most feather and down pillows, these may require regular fluffing to maintain their shape. In summary, these pillows are an excellent choice for those seeking a luxurious, breathable, and allergen-resistant option with a medium-soft feel.

The Martha Stewart Down Alternative Pillows King Size Set offers a plush and cooling comfort suitable for back, stomach, or side sleepers. These pillows are filled with polyester, providing a memory foam-like feel that is soft yet supportive. The king size dimensions (20" x 36") are generous, making them ideal for larger beds.

The cover is made from a blend of 52% polyester and 48% cotton, which is both breathable and machine washable, adding to the convenience of product care. The pillows also boast hypoallergenic properties, making them a good choice for allergy sufferers. However, some users might find the loft (4 inches thick) either too high or too low depending on personal preference. While the firmness is described as plush, it may be too soft for those seeking firmer support.

The Dobby stripe pattern adds a subtle touch of style, and the removable cover is a practical feature. These pillows are made in the USA and come in a set of two, which is great for those looking to update their bedding. In essence, these pillows are well-suited for individuals looking for a plush, hypoallergenic option with easy maintenance, but may not cater to those who prefer firmer support.

The Martha Stewart Square 2 Pack Throw Pillow Inserts offer a quality option for decorative pillows, especially if you're looking for hypoallergenic natural fill. These pillows are filled with 100% small waterfowl feathers, which are cleaned through the FreshLoft process to remove allergens and dirt, making them a good choice for allergy sufferers.

With dimensions of 26x26 inches and a fill weight of 36oz, they provide substantial back support while maintaining softness, which is ideal for use on couches or beds. The cotton cover with a 233-thread count ensures breathability and durability, although it requires dry cleaning, which might be a bit inconvenient for everyday maintenance. The pillows are designed to regain their shape easily, which is a plus for maintaining their look over time.

Considering that they are a Martha Stewart product, you can expect a certain level of quality and style, but be prepared for the premium pricing that often accompanies such a brand. These pillow inserts are well-suited for those who value natural materials and hypoallergenic properties, with the added benefit of solid support for both decorative and functional use.