10 Best Milkshake Makers 2025 in the United States

The Ninja NC301 CREAMi Ice Cream Maker is an exciting option for anyone looking to whip up delicious milkshakes, frozen desserts, and more right at home. With its powerful 800-watt motor and 7 one-touch programs, it allows for a variety of treats, including gelato, sorbet, and smoothies. This versatility is a significant strength, as it accommodates both indulgent and healthier, low-sugar options, making it great for families with different dietary preferences. The CREAMi also features a unique Creamify Technology, ensuring your frozen creations have a smooth, creamy texture, essential for delightful milkshakes.

In terms of capacity, it comes with two 16-ounce pint containers, which is perfect for personal servings or sharing small batches. The need to freeze your base overnight may be a drawback for those looking for instant gratification, as it requires some planning ahead.

The ease of cleaning is commendable, as most parts are top-rack dishwasher safe, making post-use clean-up a breeze. The compact design is another plus, especially for smaller kitchens or for those who want to store it easily. Some users may find the compatibility limitations frustrating, as the pint containers are only designed for specific Ninja models, restricting future upgrade options. Additionally, while the 7 different settings provide flexibility, beginners might feel overwhelmed by the range of choices at first.

The Ninja NC301 CREAMi is ideal for those who enjoy creating customized frozen treats at home, particularly milkshake enthusiasts looking for versatility and quality in their desserts. It may require a bit of planning and can be somewhat limiting in terms of compatible accessories.

The Hamilton Beach HMD400 is a robust triple spindle milkshake maker designed for commercial use, making it ideal for cafes, diners, or any high-volume setting. One of its standout features is the powerful 3 1/3-horsepower motors, which allow for efficient mixing with three-speed settings and a pulse option for added control. This means you can whip up delicious shakes quickly, which is a plus for busy environments.

The heavy-duty die-cast metal construction ensures durability, and the sealed rear housing helps prevent water damage, which could be a concern for machines in a kitchen setting. Cleaning is straightforward, thanks to the smooth surface and removable cup guide that is dishwasher safe, making maintenance a breeze.

The 96-ounce capacity is fantastic for making multiple shakes at once, but this may be overkill for casual users who only need a milkshake maker for occasional use. Additionally, the price point reflects its commercial-grade quality, so it may not be the most budget-friendly option for home use. The Hamilton Beach HMD400 excels in a commercial context, offering speed, power, and durability, making it perfect for users in the food service industry or high-volume settings but may be more than what a casual user needs at home.

The Hamilton Beach Commercial Drink Mixer is a solid choice for anyone running an ice-cream shop or bar, thanks to its robust construction and practical features. The 1/3-horsepower motor ensures powerful performance, ideal for creating smooth, consistent milkshakes. With three speed settings and a pulse function, it provides good control over the mixing process, allowing for versatility in beverage preparation.

The hands-free operation is a big plus, as it enables multitasking, which can be crucial in a busy commercial environment. Additionally, the two-way motor activation and two-level cup rest make it convenient to use. The 28-ounce stainless-steel mixing cup is a decent capacity for commercial use, and the die-cast metal construction promises durability.

Cleaning is straightforward, with a smooth housing and dishwasher-safe cup guide, making maintenance manageable even during peak hours. However, at 14.4 pounds, it is relatively heavy, which might make it less portable if you need to move it frequently. The mixer measures 8.6 x 8.1 x 22 inches, so it requires a bit of counter space. Despite these minor drawbacks, the Hamilton Beach Commercial Drink Mixer is designed for reliability and efficiency, making it a suitable addition to any commercial setting where creating quality milkshakes is a priority.