10 Best Non Toxic Pillows 2025 in the United States

The puredown® Goose Feather Down Pillows come in a set of two, featuring a soft yet supportive feel thanks to their 95% goose feathers and 5% goose down filling. This blend creates a plush, cloud-like comfort that suits people who enjoy a softer pillow but still need some structure for neck support. The pillows are encased in a 100% organic cotton cover, which is breathable and gentle on the skin, promoting a healthier sleep environment and making them a good choice for those sensitive to synthetic fabrics.

These pillows are marketed as luxury hotel quality, though their plush firmness might not work for everyone, especially if you prefer a firmer pillow for better spine alignment. The organic cotton cover adds to breathability. The pillows are machine washable, which makes maintenance easier, but care must be taken to dry them completely to avoid any moisture issues. The reinforced double-stitched edges and piped seams contribute to durability, ensuring they hold up with regular use.

If you want a cozy, soft pillow made with natural materials and don’t require a firm or hypoallergenic option, these pillows provide a comfortable and eco-friendly choice.

The Saatva Latex Pillow (High Loft) is a choice for those seeking a natural, non-toxic pillow focused on comfort and health. Its core is made of shredded natural latex, known for durability, support, and natural hypoallergenic properties, reducing the likelihood of allergic reactions. The plushness leans towards softer firmness, suited for side and combination sleepers desiring a higher pillow for improved neck and head alignment.

This pillow features a Fair Trade Certified organic cotton cover, enhancing its eco-friendly and safe material profile. Breathability is supported by the open latex core and moisture-wicking cotton cover, promoting a cool and comfortable sleep environment. It is also machine washable, providing convenience for maintaining hygiene.

Measuring King size (34"x18") with a height of 6-7", the pillow fits larger beds and offers a loftier feel. It serves as a natural, breathable pillow with good support and easy care, making it especially suitable for side and combination sleepers. Those who require a firmer or lower profile pillow might consider other options.

The MyPillow Bedding Bed Pillow in Queen Size with Firm support is a versatile option for those seeking a non-toxic pillow. The premium 100% cotton cover is a strong point, ensuring good breathability and comfort, which are important for a restful sleep. The pillow is designed to accommodate various sleeping positions—side, back, or stomach—making it suitable for different types of sleepers.

The machine-washable feature adds to its convenience, allowing easy maintenance and long-lasting freshness. The adjustable loft is another beneficial aspect, enabling users to customize the pillow’s height to their preference, which can help in achieving better individual comfort. However, the firmness might not be ideal for those who prefer a softer pillow.

The fill material is foam, a common choice, but it lacks specific certifications or mentions of allergen resistance, which might be a drawback for individuals with severe allergies or those specifically looking for certified non-toxic materials. This pillow offers good breathability and versatility in sleeping positions, but potential buyers should consider the firmness level and lack of allergen-specific features.