10 Best Non Toxic Waterproof Mascara 2025 in the United States

The L'Oreal Paris Makeup Original Telescopic Lengthening Mascara stands out for those seeking a non-toxic, waterproof option that enhances lash length without clumping. One of its main strengths is the unique brush design, which features a flat side for lengthening and a comb side for separating lashes, allowing a precise application that can boost lash length by up to 60%. This makes it a great choice for anyone wanting defined, elongated lashes. Additionally, it is ophthalmologist and allergy tested, making it suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, addressing a key concern for many users.

The waterproof formula ensures longevity, making it ideal for all-day wear, whether you're at work or enjoying a night out. Plus, it's fragrance-free, catering to those who might be sensitive to scents. However, ease of removal can be a drawback, as waterproof formulas generally require a specialized makeup remover, which might be cumbersome for some users.

While the mascara does a fantastic job of enhancing lashes, it may not offer the dramatic volume some users desire, especially if they're accustomed to thicker, more voluminous mascaras. Pairing it with the L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Primer can help address this issue, providing an extra boost in volume for a more dramatic effect.

Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara is designed to give your lashes volume and length while resisting smudges for up to 12 hours, even through heat and humidity. Its waterproof formula makes it a good choice if you need makeup that lasts all day without running. The twisted wire brush helps separate and define each lash, allowing you to build from a natural look to a more dramatic one.

This mascara is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, as it’s allergy tested and fragrance-free, which is a big plus if you’re prone to irritation. Being waterproof can sometimes mean it’s a bit harder to remove compared to non-waterproof mascaras, so you might need a good eye makeup remover. The color offered is a rich black/brown shade that suits most looks.

If you want a mascara that combines lash drama with safety and long-lasting wear, Clinique’s product is a solid pick. However, if easy removal is your top priority, keep in mind that waterproof formulas generally require more effort to take off.

The Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara promises high-performance volume and length with its unique formula. It is infused with porcelain flower extract and omega oils, which can be beneficial for nourishing lashes. Additionally, the unique peptides included help achieve an intense black color, making your lashes stand out. One of the biggest strengths of this mascara is its waterproof formula, designed to withstand tears and sweat without smudging or running. This makes it an excellent choice for those needing long-lasting wear throughout the day or during special occasions where crying happy tears might be involved.

The liquid form ensures smooth application, and the brush is designed to thicken, lengthen, and curl lashes, providing a dramatic look. However, being waterproof, the mascara can be slightly more challenging to remove compared to non-waterproof options. This may require a good quality makeup remover or oil-based cleanser, which some users might find inconvenient. The longevity of the product is another plus, as it tends to stay put for extended periods without flaking or fading.

It is cruelty-free, which is a significant advantage for those who prioritize ethical beauty products. The color black is the only option available in this product, which might not offer versatility for users looking for other color choices. In summary, the Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara is a great pick for those seeking a long-lasting, intense black mascara that can withstand moisture while providing volume and length. However, users should be prepared for a bit more effort in the removal process.