We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

10 Best Non Toxic Waterproof Mascara 2025 in the United States

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

headphones-stars

Our Top Picks

#1

Winner

L'Oreal Paris Makeup Original Telescopic Lengthening Mascara, Waterproof Black

Rating
9.9
Chosen by1,367
Waterproof Formula
Brush Type
Ease of Removal

Most important from
73654 reviews

Waterproof Formula
Despite its excellent performance, removal can be a bit challenging, especially with the waterproof formula.
Brush Type
The wand design is perfect, providing the same results as using multiple mascaras in one go.
Ease of Removal
Despite its excellent performance, removal can be a bit challenging, especially with the waterproof formula.
Longevity
This mascara not only lengthens lashes but keeps them lifted all day long, even with glasses on.

The L'Oreal Paris Makeup Original Telescopic Lengthening Mascara stands out for those seeking a non-toxic, waterproof option that enhances lash length without clumping. One of its main strengths is the unique brush design, which features a flat side for lengthening and a comb side for separating lashes, allowing a precise application that can boost lash length by up to 60%. This makes it a great choice for anyone wanting defined, elongated lashes. Additionally, it is ophthalmologist and allergy tested, making it suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, addressing a key concern for many users.

The waterproof formula ensures longevity, making it ideal for all-day wear, whether you're at work or enjoying a night out. Plus, it's fragrance-free, catering to those who might be sensitive to scents. However, ease of removal can be a drawback, as waterproof formulas generally require a specialized makeup remover, which might be cumbersome for some users.

While the mascara does a fantastic job of enhancing lashes, it may not offer the dramatic volume some users desire, especially if they're accustomed to thicker, more voluminous mascaras. Pairing it with the L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Primer can help address this issue, providing an extra boost in volume for a more dramatic effect.

Rating
9.9
Chosen by1,367
Waterproof Formula
Brush Type
Ease of Removal

Most important from
73654 reviews

Waterproof Formula
Despite its excellent performance, removal can be a bit challenging, especially with the waterproof formula.
Brush Type
The wand design is perfect, providing the same results as using multiple mascaras in one go.
Ease of Removal
Despite its excellent performance, removal can be a bit challenging, especially with the waterproof formula.
Longevity
This mascara not only lengthens lashes but keeps them lifted all day long, even with glasses on.
#2

L’Oreal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Volume Building Waterproof Mascara, Black, 0.28 fl. oz.

Rating
9.8
Waterproof Formula
Brush Type
Ease of Removal

Most important from
116915 reviews

Waterproof Formula
It remains intact during water activities or emotional moments, proving its waterproof reliability.
Brush Type
The brush effectively picks up every lash, creating a fuller and longer appearance.
Ease of Removal
Although waterproof, it can be easily removed with an oil-based eye makeup remover, making the process hassle-free.
Color
The burgundy shade subtly enhances green and hazel eyes, offering a unique alternative to the classic black.

The L’Oreal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Volume Building Waterproof Mascara is designed to give your lashes a significant boost in volume and length. One of its standout features is its ability to build lashes up to four times their natural thickness without clumping, which is great for achieving a dramatic eye look. The volumizing brush complements the formula well, ensuring even application and leaving lashes feeling soft instead of brittle, which is a common issue with some other mascaras.

This mascara is also waterproof, making it suitable for various occasions, including those tear-jerking moments or humid days. It can be easily removed with a waterproof eye makeup remover, which adds to its convenience, especially for people with sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses.

There are a few considerations to keep in mind. While the waterproof formula is excellent for durability, some may find it challenging to remove without the right makeup remover, which could lead to some tugging on the lashes. Additionally, although the formula is designed to be flake-free, some users have reported minor flaking after long wear, which can be a drawback for those looking for all-day perfection. In terms of color, it comes in a classic waterproof black, appealing to those who prefer a bold look. The packaging is also compact, making it easy to carry in a purse for touch-ups. This product is a solid choice for anyone seeking a volumizing mascara that delivers impressive results, particularly for those who value waterproof formulas. However, if ease of removal is your top priority, it might require a bit more effort than non-waterproof options.

Rating
9.8
Waterproof Formula
Brush Type
Ease of Removal

Most important from
116915 reviews

Waterproof Formula
It remains intact during water activities or emotional moments, proving its waterproof reliability.
Brush Type
The brush effectively picks up every lash, creating a fuller and longer appearance.
Ease of Removal
Although waterproof, it can be easily removed with an oil-based eye makeup remover, making the process hassle-free.
Color
The burgundy shade subtly enhances green and hazel eyes, offering a unique alternative to the classic black.
#3

Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara | Lengthening, Volumizing, Smudge-Proof + Safe For Sensitive Eyes, Black, 0.28 Fl Oz

Rating
9.5
Waterproof Formula
Longevity
Brush Type

Most important from
2445 reviews

Waterproof Formula
It is waterproof and it doesn't flake. Never smears.
Longevity
This mascara delivers on its promise of long-lasting wear, staying put through humidity, tears, and even workouts without smudging or flaking.
Brush Type
The brush applicator is easy to use and coats each lash evenly, making it perfect for both everyday wear and special occasions.

The Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara stands out for its strong non-smudging, waterproof formula that promises up to 12 hours of wear, making it suitable for those with a busy or active lifestyle. Its volumizing and lengthening properties can help achieve both natural and bold lash looks. The twisted wire brush is designed to comb and define lashes effectively, ensuring even application.

This mascara is also notable for being safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, as it is ophthalmologist-tested and free from phthalates, fragrance, and parabens. The black color adds a dramatic touch to the lashes, enhancing their appearance. However, while the waterproof nature is a significant benefit for longevity, it might pose a challenge for ease of removal. Users might need a specialized eye makeup remover to take it off completely.

Additionally, the 0.28 Fl Oz size might seem small to some, requiring more frequent repurchases. Nonetheless, for those prioritizing waterproof, non-toxic, and eye-safe options, this mascara is a strong contender.

Rating
9.5
Waterproof Formula
Longevity
Brush Type

Most important from
2445 reviews

Waterproof Formula
It is waterproof and it doesn't flake. Never smears.
Longevity
This mascara delivers on its promise of long-lasting wear, staying put through humidity, tears, and even workouts without smudging or flaking.
Brush Type
The brush applicator is easy to use and coats each lash evenly, making it perfect for both everyday wear and special occasions.

Buying Guide for the Best Non Toxic Waterproof Mascara

Choosing the right non-toxic waterproof mascara can be a game-changer for your makeup routine. It's important to find a product that not only enhances your lashes but also aligns with your health and lifestyle preferences. Here are some key specifications to consider when selecting the best non-toxic waterproof mascara for you.
IngredientsIngredients are crucial because they determine how safe and non-toxic the mascara is. Look for mascaras that are free from harmful chemicals like parabens, phthalates, and synthetic fragrances. Instead, opt for products with natural and organic ingredients. If you have sensitive eyes or skin, this is especially important to avoid irritation. Always check the ingredient list and look for certifications like 'organic' or 'natural' to ensure you're getting a truly non-toxic product.
Waterproof FormulaThe waterproof formula is what keeps your mascara from smudging or running when exposed to water, sweat, or tears. This is particularly important if you have an active lifestyle, live in a humid climate, or need long-lasting wear. Waterproof mascaras can vary in their staying power, so read reviews and product descriptions to find one that meets your needs. If you need a mascara that lasts through intense activities, look for those specifically designed for high durability.
Brush TypeThe brush type affects how the mascara is applied and the final look of your lashes. There are various brush shapes, such as curved, straight, thick, and thin. A curved brush can help lift and curl your lashes, while a straight brush might be better for lengthening. If you want volume, look for a thicker brush with dense bristles. Consider your natural lash type and the look you want to achieve when choosing the brush type.
Ease of RemovalEase of removal is important because waterproof mascaras can be more challenging to take off. A mascara that is difficult to remove can lead to eye irritation and damage to your lashes. Look for products that are designed to be easily removed with gentle makeup removers or warm water. If you have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses, this is especially important to prevent discomfort.
LongevityLongevity refers to how long the mascara will last on your lashes without flaking or smudging. A good waterproof mascara should last all day without needing touch-ups. If you have long days or special events, you’ll want a mascara that promises long wear. Check product claims and user reviews to gauge the longevity of the mascara.
ColorColor is a personal preference but can also impact the overall look. While black is the most common and versatile color, brown can offer a more natural look, and other colors like blue or green can add a fun pop to your makeup. Consider your daily makeup routine and the occasions you’ll be wearing the mascara to choose the best color for you.

FAQ

Most Popular Categories Right Now