10 Best Oil Based Fence Stains 2025 in the United States

The Ready Seal 512 5-Gallon Pail Natural Cedar Exterior Stain and Sealer for wood offers several advantages for those looking to protect and enhance their wooden fences. Its oil-based formula does not require a primer and can be applied using various methods like a sprayer, roller, or brush. This product is particularly user-friendly as it does not need back brushing, blending seamlessly without leaving runs, laps, or streaks.

It is also versatile in terms of application temperature and does not require dilution or thinning for spray applications, making it a 'goof proof' option for DIY enthusiasts. Moreover, it is UV resistant, which helps in prolonging the color and life of the wood surface. The stain reaches its true color in approximately 14 days, starting darker initially and gradually lightening to its final shade of natural cedar.

However, one must be aware that it cannot be applied over painted or newly stained surfaces, as sealed surfaces inhibit penetration. In terms of durability, the product is highly rated by customers, holding a 4.6 out of 5 stars from over 8,575 ratings, indicating strong performance and satisfaction. Its drying time might be a concern for those needing a quicker turnaround, and maintenance could be required periodically to ensure the wood remains protected and aesthetically pleasing. Additionally, the volume of 5 gallons might be excessive for smaller projects, and the container is subject to recycling fees in certain states. This stain is ideal for users seeking an easy-to-apply, durable, and visually appealing finish for their exterior wood projects, especially large-scale ones.

The #1 Deck Premium Semi-Transparent Outdoor Wood Stain and Sealer offers a blend of beauty and protection for your outdoor wooden structures like decks, fences, and sidings. As a semi-transparent stain, it allows the natural wood grain to shine through, maintaining the aesthetic appeal of your wood with a lovely cedar color. One of its standout features is the ultimate UV protection, which helps prevent the wood from fading or graying over time.

This stain also serves as a sealer, providing deep penetration into the wood for added longevity and protection against the elements. A notable benefit of this product is its low VOC content, making it a more environmentally friendly choice compared to traditional oil-based stains. This water-based formula is also effective on damp wood, speeding up your project as you don't have to wait long after cleaning to apply the stain.

While water-based stains like this one are easier to clean up and less harmful to the environment, they may not offer the same level of durability as oil-based stains, especially in harsh weather conditions. Maintenance might be required more frequently to keep your wood looking its best. Additionally, drying times can vary, and while it's designed for ease of application, some users might find the process requires more frequent reapplication. This product is ideal for those looking for a quick, eco-friendly staining solution that highlights the natural look of the wood, but may not be the best choice for those looking for long-term durability in extreme weather conditions.

Thompson’s WaterSeal Semi-Transparent Waterproofing Wood Stain and Sealer in Chestnut Brown is a versatile option for those looking to protect and enhance their outdoor wood structures. One of the key strengths of this product is its waterproofing capability, making it suitable for areas exposed to the elements. The semi-transparent finish adds a soft tint of color while still allowing the natural wood grain to show through, which could be appealing for those wanting a natural look with a touch of color.

Additionally, the advanced polymers used in the stain provide a fade-resistant finish, ensuring the color remains vibrant over time despite exposure to sunlight, thanks to its UV-resistant properties. The ease of application is another highlight, as it can be applied to both damp and dry wood, simplifying the staining process. With coverage ranging from 150 to 400 square feet per gallon, it offers flexibility depending on the wood's porosity and application method.

However, there are some points to consider. The semi-transparent finish means it won't completely hide imperfections in the wood, which might be a drawback if you need to conceal significant blemishes. Also, maintenance might require periodic reapplication to maintain its protective and aesthetic qualities. While it excels in waterproofing and UV protection, users might find the need for thorough surface preparation before application somewhat time-consuming. This product is ideal for those seeking a balance between natural appearance and protective features in an outdoor wood stain, making it a solid choice for fences, decks, and other wooden structures.