10 Best panettone 2025 in the United States

The Fiasconaro Panettone Traditional Italian Christmas Cake is a highly-rated option for those looking to experience a genuine Italian holiday treat. Imported from Sicily, this panettone is praised for its top-tier ingredients and traditional baking methods. It's baked slowly over 36 hours to ensure optimal quality, taste, and freshness. The flavor is traditional, which should appeal to those familiar with classic Italian panettone.

The texture is typically light and airy, as expected from a high-quality panettone. The size is substantial at 35.27 ounces, making it a generous treat for gatherings or gifting during the holidays. Packaging is practical, coming in a pouch, although some users may prefer more festive or decorative packaging for gift-giving.

One downside is its limited availability, only offered once a year, which can make it hard to acquire outside of the holiday season. Additionally, being heat-sensitive, it requires careful storage to maintain its quality. For anyone with a fondness for Italian desserts or looking for an authentic gourmet gift, this Fiasconaro Panettone is a stellar choice.

The Tre Marie Panettone Re Noir is a naturally leavened, traditional Italian Christmas cake weighing 900 grams (about 31.7 ounces), making it a generous size for sharing during the holidays. Its standout feature is the dark chocolate flavor, which offers a richer twist compared to the more classic fruit-filled panettones. The texture stays true to the soft, fluffy characteristic expected from a quality panettone.

Being made in Italy and packaged in a stylish box adds to its appeal as a gift or festive treat. The packaging and flavor reflect a premium product, which may be priced accordingly. This panettone suits those looking for an authentic Italian experience with a chocolatey flavor, perfect for holiday celebrations or gifting to friends and family who appreciate traditional yet slightly different panettone varieties.

The Fabbri Amarena Cherries Panettone is a charming Italian holiday cake featuring their famous candied Amarena cherries, which have been made with the same recipe since 1915. These cherries add a unique, slightly tart sweetness that pairs well with the traditional panettone dough. The cake is hand-wrapped in attractive white paper with blue accents, making it a lovely gift option or festive treat. Weighing 1.1 pounds, it’s a moderately sized panettone suitable for sharing or enjoying over several days.

Texture-wise, you can expect the classic light and airy crumb typical of good panettone, enriched by the juicy bursts of candied cherries throughout. One thing to note is that, while the flavor is centered on the cherries, some might find the overall sweetness on the higher side, which is common for this type of dessert. Also, the packaging in a simple pouch keeps it protected but might not feel as luxurious as some other gift-ready options.

Since it’s imported from Italy and made by a well-respected brand, you can trust its quality and authenticity. This panettone is ideal for those who enjoy a traditional Italian holiday cake with a fruity twist and appreciate artisanal touches like hand-wrapping.