10 Best Pellet Pistols 2025 in the United States

The Sig Sauer P320 M17 CO2-Powered .177 Cal Semi-Automatic Air Pistol is a well-rounded choice for anyone looking to practice with a realistic and reliable air pistol. Modeled after the U.S. Army P320-M17, this air pistol provides an authentic training experience. The .177 caliber and semi-automatic action make it suitable for target practice and recreational shooting. With a velocity of up to 380 fps, it offers decent power for an air pistol in this class, though it may not be the highest available in the market.

The CO2 power source is convenient and allows for consistent performance, but users will need to ensure they have CO2 cartridges on hand as they are essential for operation. Accuracy is supported by the use of premium pellets, as recommended by the manufacturer, which can help achieve better performance. The 20-round magazine capacity is generous, allowing for extended shooting sessions without frequent reloading.

Ergonomics are well-considered, with a weight of 34 oz and a design that mimics the real P320-M17, offering a realistic feel. However, the frame material is plastic, which might not appeal to users looking for an all-metal construction. The included accessory rail also adds versatility for attaching additional components like sights. The Sig Sauer P320 M17 is a highly rated air pistol that balances authenticity, performance, and convenience, making it a solid choice for both beginners and enthusiasts.

The Umarex Colt Peacemaker Revolver is a standout choice for those seeking a pellet pistol that combines historical appeal with enjoyable shooting performance. One of its major strengths is its realistic design, mimicking the iconic Frontier Six-Shooter, which not only makes it aesthetically pleasing but also enhances the shooting experience. With an all-metal frame and realistic action, it’s perfect for enthusiasts and collectors alike.

In terms of performance, it shoots .177 caliber pellets at an impressive velocity of up to 380 fps, making it suitable for light target practice or plinking. The 6-round capacity, using individual pellet cartridges, adds to the authentic revolver feel. Additionally, it’s powered by 12-gram CO2 cartridges, which are readily available and economical, though you will need to purchase these separately.

There are some drawbacks to consider. The limited magazine capacity means you’ll need to reload after every six shots, which can be a bit of a hassle for those looking for extended shooting sessions without interruptions. While the pistol is relatively lightweight at 2 pounds, some users may find it a bit bulky compared to other air pistols on the market. Also, while it is praised for accuracy, results can vary based on user skill and pellet quality. This air pistol is best suited for hobbyists, history buffs, or casual shooters who appreciate the classic design and are looking for a fun way to practice their aim. It might not be ideal for competitive shooting or those seeking advanced features, but for its intended purpose, it offers a delightful shooting experience with a touch of nostalgia.

The Umarex Walther PPQ M2 .177 Caliber Pellet Gun Air Pistol is an authentic replica designed to mimic the real firearm closely. It's CO2 powered, which means you'll need to purchase CO2 cartridges separately for operation. The gun features a rifled metal barrel which enhances accuracy, making it a good choice for target shooting.

With a 20-round belt-driven magazine, you can enjoy extended shooting sessions before needing to reload. The pistol weighs 2 pounds, offering a realistic feel that can help with training and practice. However, the frame is made of plastic, which might not appeal to those looking for a more durable all-metal construction. The blowback feature adds to the realism, but it could also lead to faster CO2 consumption.

In terms of ergonomics, the design is true to the PPQ M2, which is known for its comfortable grip. This gun is best suited for enthusiasts and those looking to practice target shooting with a realistic-feeling air pistol. However, if you’re looking for something with higher durability or less CO2 dependency, you might need to consider other options.