10 Best Pillow Protectors 2025 in the United States

The FAUNNA Zippered Pillow Protectors are made from 100% long-staple cotton with a 600 thread-count sateen finish, offering a soft and luxurious feel. The material ensures a high level of comfort and durability, while the finely woven fabric provides effective protection for your pillows. The standard size (20x26 inches) fits most standard pillows, making it a versatile choice for many users.

One notable strength is the breathability of the cotton fabric, which helps maintain a cool and comfortable sleep environment. Additionally, the pillow protectors are designed to be quiet, which can contribute to a more restful sleep experience. While the product lacks waterproofing, which could be a drawback for users seeking protection against spills and stains, the ease of maintenance is a clear advantage, as the protectors are machine washable and feature a high-quality invisible zipper for easy removal.

The product is also certified by OEKO-TEX, ensuring it is safe and skin-friendly. The FAUNNA pillow protectors are a strong option for those looking for breathable, comfortable, and easy-to-clean pillow protection, although they may not be ideal for those prioritizing waterproof features.

The SureGuard Pillow Protectors come as a set of two king-size covers made from soft, smooth 100% cotton, which helps keep your pillows comfortable and breathable. They are completely waterproof, so they protect against sweat, spills, and stains, and they come with a reassuring 10-year warranty covering normal household use. These protectors are designed to block bed bugs tightly thanks to their special zip closure, making them a good choice if you want extra pest protection.

They are also hypoallergenic, shielding your pillows from dust mites, mold, pollen, and pet dander, which can benefit allergy sufferers. The cotton surface is quiet and moisture-wicking, maintaining the natural feel of your pillow without the crinkly noise some waterproof covers make. Machine washing and tumble drying is straightforward, making upkeep simple. On the downside, while the cotton fabric breathes well, fully waterproof covers can still feel a bit warmer than unprotected pillows. Also, the zipper must be handled carefully to maintain the bed bug-proof seal and avoid damage. Some users might find the white color prone to visible stains over time despite easy washing.

These pillow protectors represent a solid choice for king-size pillows if you want reliable waterproofing, allergen protection, and bed bug defense without sacrificing comfort or ease of care.

The AllerEase Pillow Protectors come in a set of four and are designed to fit Standard/Queen-sized pillows. Made from a blend of 88% polyester and 12% nylon, these protectors offer a durable and comfortable fabric that's also breathable. A key feature is their advanced allergy protection, using tightly woven material to keep out household particles that can cause allergies. These protectors are also allergist-recommended, which adds to their credibility for providing relief from allergens.

They are machine washable, making maintenance easy, and come with a lifetime limited warranty for added peace of mind. The temperature-balancing fabric is a standout, as it can help maintain comfortable pillow temperatures throughout the night, similar to high-performance athletic clothing. However, these protectors are not waterproof, which might be a drawback if you need that feature for spills or bedwetting concerns. Additionally, while they are designed to be quiet and soft, some users might find the polyester-nylon blend less luxurious compared to pure cotton options.

Weighing in at 14.6 ounces for the set, they are lightweight and convenient to handle. Ideal for those seeking allergy relief and a longer lifespan for their pillows, these protectors excel in breathability and comfort, though they might not be the best choice if waterproofing is a priority.