We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

10 Best Pillows Similar To My Pillow 2025 in the United States

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

headphones-stars

Our Top Picks

#1

Winner

Beckham Hotel Collection Queen/Standard Size Memory Foam (Adjustable Fill) Bed Pillows Set of 2 - Cooling Shredded Foam Pillow for Back, Stomach or Side Sleepers

Rating
9.8
Chosen by1,188
Fill Material
Firmness
Adjustability

Most important from
1195 reviews

Fill Material
Adjusting the foam fill makes it perfect for avoiding snoring and maintaining comfort, especially for side sleepers.
Firmness
High-quality materials, though it can feel pretty stiff.
Adjustability
Adjusting the foam fill makes it perfect for avoiding snoring and maintaining comfort, especially for side sleepers.

The Beckham Hotel Collection Memory Foam Pillows offer a solid option for anyone looking for comfort and adjustability in their sleep. Designed to cater to back, stomach, or side sleepers, these pillows feature shredded foam that allows for customizable loft and firmness, making them suitable for a variety of sleeping positions. The breathable cotton cover adds to the comfort by helping to regulate temperature, which is a big plus for those who tend to sleep hot.

One of the standout features of these pillows is their adjustability. Users can easily modify the fill to achieve their preferred height and firmness, which can lead to better neck alignment while sleeping. Additionally, they are machine washable, making maintenance easier.

However, there are some drawbacks to consider. While the firmness is generally well-received, some users may find them a bit too firm for their liking, which can affect comfort. The weight of 4 pounds could also be a concern for those looking for lighter options. Moreover, although they are marketed as suitable for all types of sleepers, individual preferences vary significantly, so these pillows might not be the best fit for everyone. The Beckham Hotel Collection pillows are a good choice for those seeking breathable, adjustable support but may require some trial and error to find the perfect setup.

Rating
9.8
Chosen by1,188
Fill Material
Firmness
Adjustability

Most important from
1195 reviews

Fill Material
Adjusting the foam fill makes it perfect for avoiding snoring and maintaining comfort, especially for side sleepers.
Firmness
High-quality materials, though it can feel pretty stiff.
Adjustability
Adjusting the foam fill makes it perfect for avoiding snoring and maintaining comfort, especially for side sleepers.
#2

MyPillow Bedding Bed Pillows for Sleeping Queen Size, Perfect for Back, Stomach or Side Sleepers - My Pillow Classic Pillow [Queen, Firm]

Rating
9.6
Fill Material
Firmness
Size

Most important from
21473 reviews

Fill Material
The MyPillow Classic Pillow exceeded expectations after initial skepticism, particularly due to its unique foam fill that offers both firmness and comfort.
Firmness
Despite its firmness, the pillow provides ample 'give,' keeping the head supported throughout the night without sinking deeply.
Size
The pillow fits standard pillowcases and offers satisfactory comfort for side sleepers, even without addressing specific sleep issues like neck pain or snoring.

The MyPillow Classic Pillow in Queen size is designed for versatility, accommodating back, stomach, and side sleepers. It features a 100% cotton cover, which adds to its breathability and comfort throughout the night. The pillow's adjustable loft is a standout feature, allowing users to modify its height for personalized comfort. This can be particularly beneficial for those who need to customize their pillow’s height to support different sleeping positions or preferences.

Additionally, the pillow is machine washable, making it easy to maintain and ensuring long-lasting freshness. However, the fill material is foam, which may not appeal to everyone, particularly those who prefer natural or alternative fillings. The firmness of the pillow could also be a downside for some, especially if you prefer a softer pillow.

The queen size is a good middle-ground option, providing ample space without overwhelming the bed. The MyPillow Classic Pillow offers many benefits such as adjustability and ease of care, but its firmness and foam fill might not suit everyone’s needs.

Rating
9.6
Fill Material
Firmness
Size

Most important from
21473 reviews

Fill Material
The MyPillow Classic Pillow exceeded expectations after initial skepticism, particularly due to its unique foam fill that offers both firmness and comfort.
Firmness
Despite its firmness, the pillow provides ample 'give,' keeping the head supported throughout the night without sinking deeply.
Size
The pillow fits standard pillowcases and offers satisfactory comfort for side sleepers, even without addressing specific sleep issues like neck pain or snoring.
#3

MyPillow Bedding Bed Pillows for Sleeping King Size, Perfect for Back, Stomach or Side Sleepers - My Pillow Classic Pillow [King, Medium]

Rating
9.3
Firmness
Adjustability
Loft (Height)

Most important from
21473 reviews

Firmness
The pillow offers firm enough support for the head and neck while remaining soft enough to promote deep, uninterrupted sleep.
Adjustability
Adjustability and medium firmness suit various sleeping positions, including back, stomach, and side sleepers, easing neck pain and discomfort.
Loft (Height)
The pillow quickly puffs up and maintains its loft without feeling lumpy or flattening over time.
Size
Its larger king size provides ample space, enhancing overall comfort throughout the night.
Cover Material
The pillow supports a cool and comfortable sleep experience thanks to its breathable 100% cotton cover.

The MyPillow Classic King Size pillow offers a medium firmness that suits back, stomach, and side sleepers, making it versatile for various sleeping styles. Its adjustable loft is a strong point, allowing you to customize the pillow’s height to your comfort preference, which can help with neck support. Filled with foam and covered in a soft, breathable 100% cotton fabric, it promises a comfortable and cool sleep experience. The pillow measures 34 by 18.5 inches and has a 7-inch thickness, providing ample size for those who prefer a larger pillow. It’s also machine washable, which makes cleaning simple and convenient.

The foam fill might not provide the same plush softness some users expect from down or alternative fiber fillings. Also, while medium firmness is good for many, those wanting a very soft or very firm pillow might find it less suitable. The rolled packaging is eco-friendly but means the pillow needs time to fully fluff up after unpacking. For those seeking a straightforward, adjustable pillow in a standard king size with easy care, this MyPillow model is a solid choice worth considering.

Rating
9.3
Firmness
Adjustability
Loft (Height)

Most important from
21473 reviews

Firmness
The pillow offers firm enough support for the head and neck while remaining soft enough to promote deep, uninterrupted sleep.
Adjustability
Adjustability and medium firmness suit various sleeping positions, including back, stomach, and side sleepers, easing neck pain and discomfort.
Loft (Height)
The pillow quickly puffs up and maintains its loft without feeling lumpy or flattening over time.
Size
Its larger king size provides ample space, enhancing overall comfort throughout the night.
Cover Material
The pillow supports a cool and comfortable sleep experience thanks to its breathable 100% cotton cover.

Buying Guide for the Best Pillows Similar To My Pillow

Choosing the right pillow is essential for a good night's sleep and overall well-being. The right pillow can help maintain proper spinal alignment, reduce neck and back pain, and improve sleep quality. When selecting a pillow, consider your sleeping position, any specific health concerns, and personal comfort preferences. Here are some key specifications to consider when choosing a pillow similar to MyPillow.
Fill MaterialThe fill material of a pillow determines its feel, support, and durability. Common fill materials include memory foam, down, down alternative, latex, and polyester. Memory foam offers excellent support and conforms to the shape of your head and neck, making it ideal for those with neck pain. Down and down alternative pillows are soft and fluffy, providing a luxurious feel, but may not offer as much support. Latex pillows are durable and provide good support, while polyester pillows are affordable and easy to care for. Choose a fill material based on your comfort preference and any allergies you may have.
Loft (Height)The loft of a pillow refers to its height or thickness. It is important because it affects the alignment of your head, neck, and spine. Pillows with a high loft are best for side sleepers as they provide the necessary support to keep the spine aligned. Medium loft pillows are suitable for back sleepers, offering a balance between support and comfort. Low loft pillows are ideal for stomach sleepers, as they prevent the neck from being pushed too far back. Consider your sleeping position when choosing the loft of your pillow to ensure proper alignment and comfort.
FirmnessPillow firmness affects the level of support and comfort. Firm pillows provide more support and are suitable for side sleepers who need to keep their head and neck aligned with their spine. Medium-firm pillows offer a balance of support and comfort, making them ideal for back sleepers. Soft pillows are best for stomach sleepers, as they allow the head to sink in slightly, reducing strain on the neck. Choose a firmness level based on your sleeping position and personal comfort preference.
SizePillows come in various sizes, including standard, queen, and king. The size of the pillow should match the size of your bed and your personal preference. Standard pillows are the most common and fit well on twin and full beds. Queen pillows are slightly longer and provide more surface area, making them suitable for queen-sized beds. King pillows are the largest and offer the most surface area, ideal for king-sized beds. Consider the size of your bed and how much space you prefer when choosing the size of your pillow.
AdjustabilitySome pillows offer adjustability, allowing you to add or remove fill to achieve your desired loft and firmness. This feature is important for those who want a customizable sleep experience. Adjustable pillows can accommodate different sleeping positions and preferences, making them versatile and suitable for various needs. If you prefer a pillow that can be tailored to your specific comfort requirements, consider choosing an adjustable pillow.
Cover MaterialThe cover material of a pillow affects its breathability, softness, and durability. Common cover materials include cotton, polyester, bamboo, and blends. Cotton covers are soft, breathable, and hypoallergenic, making them a popular choice. Polyester covers are durable and easy to care for but may not be as breathable. Bamboo covers are eco-friendly, soft, and moisture-wicking, ideal for hot sleepers. Choose a cover material based on your comfort preference and any specific needs, such as breathability or hypoallergenic properties.

FAQ

Most Popular Categories Right Now