We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

10 Best Pillows Similar To My Pillow 2025 in the United States

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

headphones-stars

Our Top Picks

#1

Winner

Beckham Hotel Collection Bed Pillows Standard/Queen Size Set of 2 - Original Down Alternative Pillow for Sleeping - Bedding for Back, Stomach or Side Sleepers

Rating
10.0
Chosen by1,390
Fill Material
Loft (Height)
Firmness

Most important from
253923 reviews

Fill Material
These pillows maintain their fluffiness and shape even after multiple washes, coming out looking as good as new.
Loft (Height)
The pillows recover quickly after use, returning to their original loft within minutes, making them feel fresh all night long.
Firmness
The pillows provide a soft yet supportive feel that perfectly cradles the head and neck, suitable for back and side sleepers.
Cover Material
Durable stitching and breathable cotton covers help the pillows stay cool throughout the night, enhancing comfort.

The Beckham Hotel Collection Bed Pillows come as a set of two standard/queen size pillows filled with a down alternative, making them a good hypoallergenic option compared to traditional down. Their 250 thread count cotton covers are breathable and help keep sleepers cool, which is beneficial for those who tend to overheat at night. The pillows have a plush firmness that offers a soft but supportive feel, suitable for back, side, and stomach sleepers because they maintain their shape without shifting.

These pillows are machine washable, making maintenance easier compared to memory foam pillows that require special care. While they do not offer adjustability in terms of loft or firmness, the moderate loft provides a comfortable height for most users, though it may not meet the preferences of those who want very high or very flat pillows. The pillows feature a classic hotel-style design with a sewn seam closure, contributing to their durability without additional features like cooling gel or shredded fill for extra contouring.

These pillows represent a practical choice for individuals seeking a soft, breathable, and easy-care option that works well across different sleeping positions. They provide a straightforward, no-fuss alternative similar to My Pillow but with a plush feel.

Rating
10.0
Chosen by1,390
Fill Material
Loft (Height)
Firmness

Most important from
253923 reviews

Fill Material
These pillows maintain their fluffiness and shape even after multiple washes, coming out looking as good as new.
Loft (Height)
The pillows recover quickly after use, returning to their original loft within minutes, making them feel fresh all night long.
Firmness
The pillows provide a soft yet supportive feel that perfectly cradles the head and neck, suitable for back and side sleepers.
Cover Material
Durable stitching and breathable cotton covers help the pillows stay cool throughout the night, enhancing comfort.
#2

Coop Home Goods Original Adjustable Pillow, King Size Bed Pillows for Sleeping, Cross Cut Memory Foam Pillows - Medium Firm Back, Stomach and Side Sleeper Pillow, CertiPUR-US/GREENGUARD Gold

Rating
9.1
Fill Material
Loft (Height)
Firmness

Most important from
63927 reviews

Fill Material
Extra stuffing included ensures long-term fluffiness and lets you tailor the pillow as your needs change.
Loft (Height)
Customizable fill allows precise adjustment for perfect firmness and loft, supporting side sleepers especially well.
Firmness
Customizable fill allows precise adjustment for perfect firmness and loft, supporting side sleepers especially well.
Adjustability
Customizable fill allows precise adjustment for perfect firmness and loft, supporting side sleepers especially well.
Cover Material
The breathable, soft cover keeps the pillow cool throughout the night without causing overheating.

The Coop Home Goods Original Adjustable Pillow is a king-size bed pillow known for its customizability. Users can easily add or remove its unique cross-cut memory foam and microfiber fill to match their preferred firmness—whether sleeping on the back, side, or stomach. This adaptability makes it suitable for a wide range of sleepers seeking personalized comfort and proper neck support. The pillow measures about 6 inches thick and includes an extra fill bag, giving even more control over its loft and firmness.

Its cover is made from a soft, breathable blend of polyester and rayon, called Lulltra fabric, which helps keep you cool and comfortable throughout the night. The materials are CertiPUR-US and GREENGUARD Gold certified, ensuring no harmful chemicals are present—ideal for those sensitive to allergens or chemicals. The pillow weighs approximately 4.5 pounds, which may make it less convenient to move frequently.

Care instructions require attention: the outer cover is machine washable, but the inner pillow must be removed with specific drying guidelines to maintain its quality. If you want a pillow that adjusts easily to your comfort needs with breathable, high-quality materials and don't mind the extra care, this pillow is an excellent option for a restful night’s sleep.

Rating
9.1
Fill Material
Loft (Height)
Firmness

Most important from
63927 reviews

Fill Material
Extra stuffing included ensures long-term fluffiness and lets you tailor the pillow as your needs change.
Loft (Height)
Customizable fill allows precise adjustment for perfect firmness and loft, supporting side sleepers especially well.
Firmness
Customizable fill allows precise adjustment for perfect firmness and loft, supporting side sleepers especially well.
Adjustability
Customizable fill allows precise adjustment for perfect firmness and loft, supporting side sleepers especially well.
Cover Material
The breathable, soft cover keeps the pillow cool throughout the night without causing overheating.
#3

Coop Home Goods Original Crescent Adjustable Pillow, King Bed Pillows for Shoulder, Neck & Head Support, Crescent Foam Pillows - Medium Firm for Back & Side Sleeper, CertiPUR-US/GREENGUARD Gold

Rating
8.8
Fill Material
Loft (Height)
Firmness

Most important from
63927 reviews

Fill Material
The pillow’s adjustable fill allows finding the perfect loft and firmness, delivering just the right amount of support without excessive pushback or flattening.
Loft (Height)
The pillow’s adjustable fill allows finding the perfect loft and firmness, delivering just the right amount of support without excessive pushback or flattening.
Firmness
The pillow’s adjustable fill allows finding the perfect loft and firmness, delivering just the right amount of support without excessive pushback or flattening.
Adjustability
The pillow’s adjustable fill allows finding the perfect loft and firmness, delivering just the right amount of support without excessive pushback or flattening.
Cover Material
The breathable Lulltra fabric cover keeps the pillow from feeling overly warm, appealing to those sensitive to heat while sleeping.

The Coop Home Goods Original Crescent Adjustable Pillow is designed to offer good support for back and side sleepers, thanks to its medium firmness and crescent shape that cushions the neck and shoulders. Its fill is made of cross-cut memory foam and microfiber, which can be adjusted easily by adding or removing material to find the perfect loft and firmness for your needs. This adjustability is a major strength, helping users achieve better neck alignment and comfort compared to fixed pillows.

The pillow comes in a king size, providing ample space for various sleeping positions. The cover is made from a breathable blend of polyester and rayon (Lulltra fabric), promoting airflow and staying soft, which is nice for those who tend to sleep warm. Plus, it’s machine washable, but you need to separate the cover from the foam to keep it in good condition. One thing to note is that the pillow weighs about 6 pounds, which is heavier than traditional pillows, so it might feel a bit bulky to some. While the medium firmness suits most sleepers, those who prefer very firm or very soft pillows might want to look elsewhere.

This pillow is notable for its customizable comfort and supportive shape, making it a solid choice for people who experience neck or shoulder discomfort and want a versatile pillow that adapts to their sleeping style.

Rating
8.8
Fill Material
Loft (Height)
Firmness

Most important from
63927 reviews

Fill Material
The pillow’s adjustable fill allows finding the perfect loft and firmness, delivering just the right amount of support without excessive pushback or flattening.
Loft (Height)
The pillow’s adjustable fill allows finding the perfect loft and firmness, delivering just the right amount of support without excessive pushback or flattening.
Firmness
The pillow’s adjustable fill allows finding the perfect loft and firmness, delivering just the right amount of support without excessive pushback or flattening.
Adjustability
The pillow’s adjustable fill allows finding the perfect loft and firmness, delivering just the right amount of support without excessive pushback or flattening.
Cover Material
The breathable Lulltra fabric cover keeps the pillow from feeling overly warm, appealing to those sensitive to heat while sleeping.

Buying Guide for the Best Pillows Similar To My Pillow

Choosing the right pillow is essential for a good night's sleep and overall well-being. The right pillow can help maintain proper spinal alignment, reduce neck and back pain, and improve sleep quality. When selecting a pillow, consider your sleeping position, any specific health concerns, and personal comfort preferences. Here are some key specifications to consider when choosing a pillow similar to MyPillow.
Fill MaterialThe fill material of a pillow determines its feel, support, and durability. Common fill materials include memory foam, down, down alternative, latex, and polyester. Memory foam offers excellent support and conforms to the shape of your head and neck, making it ideal for those with neck pain. Down and down alternative pillows are soft and fluffy, providing a luxurious feel, but may not offer as much support. Latex pillows are durable and provide good support, while polyester pillows are affordable and easy to care for. Choose a fill material based on your comfort preference and any allergies you may have.
Loft (Height)The loft of a pillow refers to its height or thickness. It is important because it affects the alignment of your head, neck, and spine. Pillows with a high loft are best for side sleepers as they provide the necessary support to keep the spine aligned. Medium loft pillows are suitable for back sleepers, offering a balance between support and comfort. Low loft pillows are ideal for stomach sleepers, as they prevent the neck from being pushed too far back. Consider your sleeping position when choosing the loft of your pillow to ensure proper alignment and comfort.
FirmnessPillow firmness affects the level of support and comfort. Firm pillows provide more support and are suitable for side sleepers who need to keep their head and neck aligned with their spine. Medium-firm pillows offer a balance of support and comfort, making them ideal for back sleepers. Soft pillows are best for stomach sleepers, as they allow the head to sink in slightly, reducing strain on the neck. Choose a firmness level based on your sleeping position and personal comfort preference.
SizePillows come in various sizes, including standard, queen, and king. The size of the pillow should match the size of your bed and your personal preference. Standard pillows are the most common and fit well on twin and full beds. Queen pillows are slightly longer and provide more surface area, making them suitable for queen-sized beds. King pillows are the largest and offer the most surface area, ideal for king-sized beds. Consider the size of your bed and how much space you prefer when choosing the size of your pillow.
AdjustabilitySome pillows offer adjustability, allowing you to add or remove fill to achieve your desired loft and firmness. This feature is important for those who want a customizable sleep experience. Adjustable pillows can accommodate different sleeping positions and preferences, making them versatile and suitable for various needs. If you prefer a pillow that can be tailored to your specific comfort requirements, consider choosing an adjustable pillow.
Cover MaterialThe cover material of a pillow affects its breathability, softness, and durability. Common cover materials include cotton, polyester, bamboo, and blends. Cotton covers are soft, breathable, and hypoallergenic, making them a popular choice. Polyester covers are durable and easy to care for but may not be as breathable. Bamboo covers are eco-friendly, soft, and moisture-wicking, ideal for hot sleepers. Choose a cover material based on your comfort preference and any specific needs, such as breathability or hypoallergenic properties.

FAQ

Most Popular Categories Right Now