10 Best Pool Gas Heaters 2025 in the United States

The Hayward W3H400FDN is a powerful gas pool heater, boasting a robust 400,000 BTU output which makes it suitable for large in-ground pools and spas. One of its standout features is the durable cupro nickel heat exchanger, designed to resist corrosion and ensure longevity, which is particularly beneficial for pools with fluctuating water chemistry. Its energy-efficient hydraulic design is a plus, as it minimizes the run time required by your circulation pump, potentially leading to lower energy costs over time.

Control-wise, the heater offers a user-friendly front-panel access and an intuitive control pad, making it easy to operate and maintain. This aspect can be particularly advantageous for pool owners who may not be very tech-savvy. Additionally, the unit adheres to low NOx emissions standards, making it an environmentally friendly choice in areas where air quality is a concern.

There are some considerations to keep in mind. Weighing in at 195 pounds and measuring nearly 40 inches in length, this heater may require significant space for installation and might be cumbersome to handle without proper equipment. If you have a larger in-ground pool or spa and prioritize efficiency and durability, the Hayward W3H400FDN is a strong contender in the pool gas heater market, provided you have the space for setup and installation.

The Hayward W3H250FDN pool heater is a strong choice if you have an in-ground pool or spa and need reliable, powerful heating. With 250,000 BTUs, it offers plenty of warmth to quickly raise your water temperature, making it suitable for medium to large pools. Its cupro nickel heat exchanger stands out because it resists corrosion better than standard materials, which means the heater can last longer even if your pool water chemistry isn’t perfectly balanced. This durability is a valuable advantage for long-term use.

The heater is designed for natural gas, so you'll want to ensure your home has that setup. It includes a user-friendly control panel located on the front, simplifying operation and maintenance without needing to open panels or frequently call for help. Another practical benefit is its efficient hydraulic design, which reduces how long your circulation pump runs, potentially saving you money on electricity. The unit meets low NOx emission standards, making it environmentally considerate and compliant with strict air quality requirements if you live in such an area.

The heater is fairly heavy and bulky (over 160 pounds and roughly 33 inches on each side), so installation might require professional assistance and some space consideration. It holds a solid customer rating around 4.1 stars, with some users noting that proper maintenance is key to keeping it running smoothly given its complexity and size. If you want a durable, high-powered, and energy-conscious natural gas heater for your in-ground pool or spa, this model fits well, but be prepared for installation effort and regular upkeep to maximize its lifespan.

The Raypak 206,000 BTU Digital Electronic Ignition Natural Gas Pool Heater is designed for those looking to heat their swimming pools efficiently. With a substantial BTU output, it can effectively warm pools of various sizes, making it a solid choice for both residential and commercial setups. One of its notable strengths is the intermittent spark ignition system, which enhances safety and efficiency, as the pilot light only activates when heating is needed. This feature can help reduce gas consumption and save on energy bills.

The heater is constructed from advanced materials that prevent heat retention, eliminating the need for expensive metal heat sinks. This not only simplifies installation but also contributes to its high efficiency and compact design, which is ideal for those with limited space. Additionally, its durability means it can withstand various weather conditions, providing reliable performance throughout the year.

While the heater may not be the most popular choice among consumers, it is still a dependable option. At 187 pounds and with dimensions of 40 x 28 x 20 inches, it may require assistance during installation due to its weight and size. For those seeking an efficient pool heater, Raypak’s offering is worth considering, especially for users who prioritize energy efficiency and durability in their pool heating solution.