10 Best Puppy Chew Toys 2025 in the United States

The Benebone Maplestick is a small, durable chew toy designed especially for active puppies and small dogs. It’s made from real maple wood combined with nylon, which offers a natural wood flavor dogs tend to love—this makes it more appealing than typical plastic toys. Its unique shape makes it easy for dogs to grip and chew, helping keep them engaged longer. In terms of size, it’s compact enough for small breeds and puppies, but larger dogs might find it too small or wear it out faster.

The material is tougher than real sticks, so it’s less likely to splinter or break apart, which adds a safety edge by reducing choking hazards or sharp pieces. However, since it contains nylon, very aggressive chewers might eventually damage it, although it generally lasts for weeks. The texture mimics real wood but is smooth and consistent, so it’s less messy than natural sticks. One nice touch is the company’s customer support promise, which can be reassuring if you have any concerns.

If your puppy prefers softer or flavored rubber toys, this one’s natural wood flavor might not be as exciting. Additionally, it’s designed specifically for small dogs, so if your pup is bigger or super strong, you may want to look for a larger or more heavy-duty option. This chew toy is well suited for small puppies or small breed dogs that enjoy a wood-like chew and need something durable yet safe to keep them busy.

The Benebone Small 4-Pack Dog Chew Toys are designed especially for small dogs weighing up to 30 pounds, making them a great choice for puppies and smaller breeds who are tough chewers. Made from durable nylon, these chew toys are stronger than real bones and can last for weeks, which is ideal if your dog tends to chew aggressively. The size is small and manageable for little paws, and their unique shape helps dogs easily pick them up and chew comfortably, a thoughtful design considering dogs don’t have thumbs.

Safety is a priority here, as the materials are made in the USA and free from harmful additives, providing peace of mind. The texture is firm but chew-friendly, which helps satisfy your dog's natural urge to gnaw while protecting their teeth. One notable feature is the use of 100% real flavors like bacon and fish, which dogs find very appealing and hard to resist, unlike many synthetic-flavored toys. The pack includes four chew toys, adding good value and variety for your pet.

Nylon can be quite hard, so supervision is recommended to prevent any potential tooth damage if your dog chews too aggressively. Also, these chew toys are best suited for small dogs, so larger breeds might find them too small or less durable. Benebone offers a well-made and thoughtfully designed option that balances enjoyment and toughness for a long-lasting, flavorful chew toy suitable for small, strong-chewing dogs or puppies.

The Chuckit! Max Glow Ultra Fetch Stick is designed primarily as a fetch toy rather than a chew toy, making it a good choice for active play outdoors with dogs of all sizes. Made from natural rubber, it offers a durable and safe material that is gentle on your dog's mouth, which is important for puppies and adult dogs alike. Its 12-inch length and lightweight design (6.7 ounces) make it easy to throw and carry, suitable for various dog breeds.

One standout feature is its glowing ability, which recharges under light and offers 20 to 30 minutes of nighttime visibility without batteries—great for early morning or evening games. However, this toy is not meant for aggressive chewers, so if your puppy tends to tear up toys quickly, this might not hold up well. The texture is smooth rubber, which dogs tend to enjoy for fetching but may not satisfy strong chewing urges. It also lacks any added flavor, so it relies on interactive play rather than taste to keep your dog interested.

This fetch stick excels for energetic dogs who enjoy chasing and retrieving, especially in low light, but isn't the best fit if your puppy needs something to chew on extensively or feels bored without flavor stimulation.