10 Best Puppy Chew Toys 2025 in the United States

The Benebone Puppy Holiday 4-Pack is designed specifically for puppies and modest chewers, making it an appealing choice for dog owners looking for safe and engaging chew toys. The set includes four items: three durable nylon chews flavored with real bacon and a softer Zaggler made of thermoplastic rubber (TPE). The inclusion of real bacon is a standout feature, as it ensures that the toys are not only tasty but also appealing for dogs, who have a keen sense of smell.

In terms of safety, these toys are made in the USA from high-quality materials, such as nylon and TPE, which are generally considered safe for dogs. The size of the toys, measuring approximately 6.5 x 5.75 x 3 inches, makes them suitable for all breed sizes, particularly for puppies under 30 pounds. The paw-friendly design helps puppies grip the toys easily, encouraging them to chew safely and effectively.

There are a few considerations to keep in mind. While the nylon chews are described as being more forgiving than adult versions, some dogs may still find them too tough, especially if they are aggressive chewers. The Zaggler, while softer, may not hold up as well under heavy chewing. Additionally, the price point for a pack of four may be higher than other options on the market, which could be a factor for budget-conscious pet owners.

The Chuckit! Ultra Squeaker Ball Dog Toy is a versatile fetch toy designed for medium breeds. Made of durable rubber, it can withstand enthusiastic play but is not suited for aggressive chewers. The ball’s 2.5-inch diameter is ideal for medium-sized dogs (20-60lbs), ensuring it is easy to carry without being a choking hazard.

Its high bounce and built-in squeaker keep dogs engaged, making fetch games lively and enjoyable. The ball’s buoyancy adds a fun element for water play, enhancing its versatility. However, it should not be used as a chew toy, and supervision is recommended during play to ensure safety.

The texture is soft enough for dogs' mouths, although it lacks any specific flavor, which could make it less appealing for some pups. With a long-standing reputation, Chuckit! continues to offer interactive toys that strengthen the bond between pets and their owners. This toy is a strong contender for active play but may not be the best choice for puppies who prefer chewing over fetching.

The Chuckit! Max Glow Ultra Fetch Stick is designed primarily as a fetch toy rather than a chew toy, making it a good choice for active play outdoors with dogs of all sizes. Made from natural rubber, it offers a durable and safe material that is gentle on your dog's mouth, which is important for puppies and adult dogs alike. Its 12-inch length and lightweight design (6.7 ounces) make it easy to throw and carry, suitable for various dog breeds.

One standout feature is its glowing ability, which recharges under light and offers 20 to 30 minutes of nighttime visibility without batteries—great for early morning or evening games. However, this toy is not meant for aggressive chewers, so if your puppy tends to tear up toys quickly, this might not hold up well. The texture is smooth rubber, which dogs tend to enjoy for fetching but may not satisfy strong chewing urges. It also lacks any added flavor, so it relies on interactive play rather than taste to keep your dog interested.

This fetch stick excels for energetic dogs who enjoy chasing and retrieving, especially in low light, but isn't the best fit if your puppy needs something to chew on extensively or feels bored without flavor stimulation.