10 Best Puppy Teething Toys 2025 in the United States

The KONG Puppy Natural Teething Rubber Chew Toy is specifically designed for small puppies, making it a great option in the puppy-teething-toys category. One of its standout features is the customized natural rubber material that is soft enough for a puppy's delicate teeth yet durable enough to withstand plenty of chewing. This ensures that the toy is gentle on their gums while helping to relieve teething discomfort, a key requirement for new puppy parents.

The toy's size is appropriate for small breeds, which enhances its effectiveness during playtime. It also provides a fun bounce, encouraging interactive games like fetch, which can be great for bonding and exercise. Additionally, the ability to stuff the toy with treats or food is a big plus, as it not only keeps puppies engaged but can also aid in crate training, making it a versatile choice for pet owners.

The KONG Puppy Chew Toy is a solid choice for small puppies, offering comfort, engagement, and some training benefits. Just keep an eye on it during play to ensure it remains safe and intact.

The Benebone Puppy 2-Pack Maplestick/Zaggler chew toys are designed specifically for small teething puppies under 15 pounds. Made with a softer nylon material compared to adult chew toys, these are gentle enough to soothe tender puppy teeth without being too hard. The size is small and lightweight, making it easy for little pups to grip and chew comfortably.

What stands out is the use of real food ingredients for flavor — the Zaggler is infused with real bacon scent, while the Maplestick includes real maple wood, which helps keep puppies interested and encourages healthy chewing habits. Safety is a key point: these toys aren’t edible, so puppies should be supervised during play, and the toys should be replaced if damaged. Since they are tiny, they’re best kept away from larger dogs to avoid accidental swallowing.

Made in the USA, this pack comes with two different shapes that offer varied textures to keep chewing fun and engaging. While the toys are durable for gentle chewers, aggressive chewers might wear them down faster. If you have a small puppy who loves to chew and needs something safe and flavorful to help with teething, these are a reliable and thoughtfully designed choice.

The Benebone Puppy 2-Pack Dental Chew/Wishbone Dog Chew Toys are designed specifically for teething puppies, making them a solid choice for pet owners looking for effective chew toys. One of the standout features is the use of 100% real bacon flavor, which puppies love, ensuring they stay engaged while chewing. The toys are made from durable nylon, which can withstand the enthusiastic chewing of determined puppies. This durability is essential for lasting use, but it also has a slight give to accommodate teething, striking a balance between firmness and comfort.

Their size is suitable for medium breed puppies, with dimensions that make them easy for little paws to grip. The curved design promotes a natural chewing position, making it easier for puppies to hold and chew, which is important as they don't have thumbs.

On the safety front, the fact that these toys are made in the USA adds an element of trust regarding material quality and manufacturing standards. The company also emphasizes customer service, with a happiness guarantee, giving pet owners an avenue for support if any issues arise.

However, there are some considerations to keep in mind. While the toys are designed for durability, some overly aggressive chewers may still manage to damage them. Additionally, while they're great for medium breeds, larger or more powerful puppies may need sturdier options. Lastly, the price point may be higher than some other chew toys, which could deter budget-conscious buyers.

The Benebone Puppy Chew Toys are ideal for medium breed puppies, offering a tasty and durable option that supports their teething needs while ensuring safety and ease of use. Just be mindful of the individual chewing habits of your puppy to ensure the best fit.