10 Best Rare Beanie Babies 2025 in the United States

The Ty Beanie Baby Ty2K bear is a collectible from the turn of the millennium, introduced in 1999 and retired by the end of that year. Its short production window and thematic connection to the millennium make it a sought-after item for collectors interested in Beanie Babies with a special story or limited availability. Standing about 9 inches tall, this bear features a colorful poem and vibrant design that reflect its festive theme.

It generally receives strong customer ratings, indicating satisfaction among buyers, which supports its appeal. However, its market rank suggests it’s moderately popular but not among the rarest or highest-demand Beanie Babies. Condition and presence of original tags are critical here — collectors will want this bear in a 'Mint With Mint Tags' (MWMT) state to maximize value. Authenticity can sometimes be a concern with Ty Beanie Babies, so verifying origin and tags is important to avoid counterfeits.

The packaging dimensions and lightweight make it easy to store or display. This Ty2K bear is a fine choice for collectors focused on millennium-themed or limited-time releases but may not suit those looking for extremely rare or top-tier investment pieces.

The TY Treehouse The Squirrel Beanie Baby is a small, lightweight collectible toy made by Ty, designed for children aged 3 and up. It stands out in the rare Beanie Babies category primarily due to its strong customer ratings, with an excellent 4.9 out of 5 stars from buyers, which indicates many users find it enjoyable and well-made.

This model is somewhat lower ranked in the Toys & Games category but holds a more respectable position among Stuffed Animals & Teddy Bears, making it a decent collectible choice. While it is not among the rarest in the Beanie Baby lineup, it still offers charm and appeal to collectors and fans alike. Authenticity is generally reliable with Ty products, though the market includes many fakes, so attention to tags and markings is important.

Market demand for this squirrel Beanie Baby appears moderate; it is appreciated by fans of Beanie Babies but is not one of the most sought-after models. It balances collectibility with affordability, making it a charming option for collectors or gift buyers, though those seeking high rarity or investment potential might want to explore other, less common Beanie Babies.

The BEANIE BABIES Ty Smoochy The Frog, made in 1997, is a collectible item appealing to both young children and collectors. Measuring 8 inches, it's appropriately sized for display or play. The product's condition is likely to be excellent given it's not discontinued and is still actively rated by customers.

The item's best sellers rank (#112,484 in Toys & Games and #5,393 in Stuffed Animals & Teddy Bears) suggests moderate popularity, which could mean it’s relatively easy to find on the market but still holds value for collectors. Authenticity is supported by the specific model number (4039) and ASIN (B001LDF6S6), which can be useful for verifying genuine products.

The market demand seems steady but not exceptionally high, making it accessible but potentially less lucrative as an investment. This Beanie Baby is a reliable choice for enthusiasts and those looking for a piece of nostalgia from the 90s.