10 Best Rare Beanie Babies 2026 in the United States

The Ty Ice Age Manny the Wooly Mammoth Beanie Baby is a modestly popular collectible, especially among fans of the Ice Age franchise or Ty products. It is not discontinued, which usually means it’s more accessible compared to rare retired Beanie Babies. Its size and light weight make it an easy display item. With a decent customer rating of 4.4 stars, buyers generally find it satisfying, though it isn’t considered a highly sought-after rare piece in the Beanie Baby community.

The product ranks relatively low in the Toys & Games category but performs better within the Stuffed Animals & Teddy Bears niche, indicating moderate market demand. Authenticity is less of a concern since it’s made by Ty and not discontinued, reducing the risk of counterfeit issues that often affect rare Beanie Babies. If you’re looking for a lightly collectible item linked to a popular movie, Manny is a fair choice, but it’s unlikely to appreciate much in value compared to classic rare Beanie Babies.

Ideal buyers include casual collectors or Ice Age fans rather than serious investors.

The Halo II 2000 Beanie Baby is a notable collectible, especially because of its super rare brown nose production, which makes it stand out among typical Beanie Babies. Created around the year 2000, this version includes P.V.C. pellets inside, contributing to its authentic feel and weight. Its rarity is supported by the absence of factory errors other than the unique brown nose, helping confirm its originality—a key point for collectors.

Market demand seems moderate, reflected by its ranking in stuffed animals and toys, and positive customer reviews (4.7 out of 5) suggest many buyers are satisfied with its quality and authenticity. While it is not discontinued, which sometimes affects collectible value, the distinct brown nose feature adds a layer of scarcity. This Beanie Baby is best suited for collectors who appreciate small variations and limited editions in their collection.

It may not appeal as much to casual buyers looking for common or widely available Beanie Babies. If you’re interested in rare toys with verified authenticity and a unique twist, this Halo II version is worth considering.

The TY Treehouse The Squirrel Beanie Baby is a small, lightweight collectible toy made by Ty, designed for children aged 3 and up. It stands out in the rare Beanie Babies category primarily due to its strong customer ratings, with an excellent 4.9 out of 5 stars from buyers, which indicates many users find it enjoyable and well-made.

This model is somewhat lower ranked in the Toys & Games category but holds a more respectable position among Stuffed Animals & Teddy Bears, making it a decent collectible choice. While it is not among the rarest in the Beanie Baby lineup, it still offers charm and appeal to collectors and fans alike. Authenticity is generally reliable with Ty products, though the market includes many fakes, so attention to tags and markings is important.

Market demand for this squirrel Beanie Baby appears moderate; it is appreciated by fans of Beanie Babies but is not one of the most sought-after models. It balances collectibility with affordability, making it a charming option for collectors or gift buyers, though those seeking high rarity or investment potential might want to explore other, less common Beanie Babies.