10 Best Retro Looking Toasters 2025 in the United States

The Smeg 50's Retro 4-slice toaster in Pastel Green offers a charming vintage design that stands out in any kitchen. It features two extra wide slots with self-centering racks that accommodate various bread sizes, making it versatile for both regular slices and bagels. The toaster provides six browning levels, which is great for customizing toast to your preference. Additionally, it includes three pre-set programs for reheating, defrosting, and toasting bagels, adding extra convenience.

Automatic slice pop-up and anti-slip feet enhance usability and safety. The removable stainless steel crumb tray makes cleaning straightforward, which is an essential feature for maintenance. However, it only has two slots, meaning it might not be ideal for larger families or gatherings where more toast is required quickly.

The toaster's sturdy stainless steel construction and polished finish ensure durability, though its weight (7.5 pounds) might be cumbersome to move frequently. Despite being slightly high on the price spectrum, its aesthetic appeal and reliable performance justify the investment for those who value retro design and high-quality construction in their kitchen appliances.

The Cuisinart 4-Slice Metal Classic Toaster in metallic red brings a charming retro look combined with modern convenience. Its stainless steel body and vibrant color stand out nicely on kitchen counters, fitting well for those who want a toaster with classic style. With four slots that are 1.5 inches wide, it can handle a variety of bread types, from thin slices to thicker bagels or artisan bread.

The toaster offers six browning settings, giving you good control to achieve your preferred toast color, whether light or dark. A handy high-lift lever makes it easier to remove smaller pieces without burning fingers. One of its strengths is the range of toasting functions, including options for bagels, defrosting frozen bread, reheating, and canceling mid-cycle, which adds useful flexibility for different needs. Cleaning is simplified by a removable crumb tray that catches crumbs before they pile up.

The build feels solid and durable, backed by a 3-year limited warranty for added peace of mind. Its size is somewhat larger than some other toasters, so it needs a bit more counter space. Also, while the design is classic, it might not appeal if you’re looking for something ultra-modern or minimalist. The 1800-watt power means it toasts efficiently but requires a suitable outlet. This toaster is ideal for anyone who appreciates a retro aesthetic but still wants multiple toasting options and reliable performance in everyday use.

The SMEG 2 Slice Toaster stands out with its retro aesthetic, making it an attractive addition to any kitchen with a fondness for vintage style. It features two generously sized slots that accommodate various bread types and thicknesses, which is a great feature if you enjoy different kinds of bread. The toaster allows you to choose from six browning levels, giving you control over how light or dark your toast turns out. Its stylish chrome knob enhances its visual appeal and offers four practical functions: Reheat, Defrost, Cancel, and Bagel. This versatility is convenient for different toasting needs.

Ease of cleaning is addressed with a removable stainless-steel crumb tray, making it simple to maintain cleanliness on your countertop. The self-centering racks help ensure that your bread is evenly toasted, which is a beneficial feature for achieving consistent results.

In terms of build quality, the toaster combines stainless steel and plastic materials, suggesting a fair level of durability. However, it's important to note that this model weighs 5.4 pounds, which might be a bit heavier than some other options if mobility is a concern for you. Although it offers numerous features, the SMEG toaster's retro style and functionality might carry a premium price relative to other models, especially if you're looking for basic toasting without the frills. Despite this, its combination of style and functionality makes it an appealing choice for those who appreciate both form and function in a kitchen appliance.