10 Best Sandwich Maker Grill 2025 in the United States

The George Foreman Fully Submersible Grill stands out primarily due to its ease of cleaning. The ability to remove the control panel and submerge the entire grill in the dishwasher simplifies the cleaning process, making it hassle-free. This model heats up 30% faster than some earlier George Foreman models, ensuring quicker meal preparation. Its 3/4 inch hinge is suitable for making thick sandwiches and burgers, accommodating a variety of recipes.

The non-stick coating is reported to be three times more durable than standard coatings, which may contribute to better longevity and less need for additional oils or cooking sprays. With a compact design and vertical storage capability, this grill is ideal for small kitchens or limited counter spaces. Despite its compact size, it can still prepare up to four servings, making it suitable for small families. However, it has only one temperature setting, reducing its versatility for different types of cooking.

The grill is PTFE and PFOA free, ensuring a safer cooking surface. At 188.4 watts, it’s not the most powerful option available but is sufficient for its intended use. It weighs in at 5.74 pounds, making it relatively light and easy to store. The build quality appears robust with a ceramic material that adds to its durability. While it has a modern, practical style in black and grey, some users may find the design a bit basic. It excels in ease of cleaning, quick heat-up, and compact storage, but is less versatile due to the single temperature setting.

The George Foreman Contact Submersible Grill is a solid choice for families or anyone wanting a larger appliance that can handle up to 5 servings at once. Its plates feature an advanced George Tough non-stick coating that is three times more durable than earlier versions, making it easier to cook without food sticking and simplifying cleanup. One standout feature is the ability to detach the control panel and place the rest of the grill in the dishwasher, which makes cleaning much less of a hassle compared to many other grills. The adjustable temperature control dial offers good precision, allowing you to customize cooking heat for different types of sandwiches or grilled items.

The grill heats up quickly—around 30% faster than some older models—meaning less waiting time before you start cooking. Indicator lights keep you informed when it’s ready to use, improving convenience. The build feels sturdy, combining ceramic and metal parts, and it weighs about 7 pounds, which is manageable for storing or moving around the kitchen. On the downside, its size, while great for multiple servings, means it may take up more countertop space than smaller sandwich makers, which could be a consideration for tight kitchens.

Also, while the removable plates and dishwasher-safe parts improve cleaning, the need to remove the control panel first might require extra care during washing. The grill runs at 1200 watts, which is efficient but not the most powerful on the market, so very thick sandwiches might need a bit more cooking time. This grill is well-suited for families or those who frequently prepare multiple sandwiches at once and appreciate easy cleanup and temperature control.

The T-fal OptiGrill 4in1 is a versatile and intelligent electric grill that can also function as a panini press, griddle, and sandwich maker. Its standout feature is the precision technology which calculates the thickness of the ingredients and adjusts the cooking process automatically, offering perfectly cooked meals from rare to well-done. The grill boasts 9 automatic cooking modes, catering to different types of foods such as hamburgers, poultry, fish, and more, making it ideal for varied daily meals.

With 1800 watts of power, it ensures fast and uniform cooking with minimal smoke, which is beneficial for indoor use. The non-stick removable plates and dishwasher-safe components make the cleaning process convenient. Additionally, its design helps reduce fat content in meals by facilitating the removal of excess fat through inclined plates and a juice tray.

However, the grill is relatively heavy at nearly 15 pounds, which might be cumbersome for some users to move around. Also, while it offers multiple functionalities, the initial setup and learning curve to utilize all its features might be slightly daunting for new users. The build quality, with a stainless steel finish, looks durable and adds a modern touch to the kitchen. This product is well-suited for those who want a multifunctional appliance that simplifies cooking with its smart features and easy maintenance.