10 Best Shaving Soaps 2025 in the United States

Lather & Wood Shaving Soap in Barbershop scent is a solid choice for anyone who enjoys traditional wet shaving. Its tallow-based formula, enriched with shea butter, creates a rich, dense lather that holds up well during your shave without breaking down quickly. This means you get smooth, effortless gliding of the razor with good protection for your skin. The bar is generously sized at 4.7 ounces, offering great value for the price, especially if you shave daily.

The scent captures the classic barbershop vibe—clean, fresh, and masculine—appealing to those who appreciate a timeless fragrance without overwhelming intensity. Because it’s handcrafted in small batches, you’re likely to get consistent quality and moisturizing benefits that leave your skin feeling refreshed rather than dry or tight. However, if you prefer ultra-scented or specialized formulas for sensitive skin, this might feel a bit basic. Also, it requires a shaving brush for best results, which could be a small extra step if you’re used to canned creams.

This soap is well suited for men looking to upgrade from drugstore shaving creams to a more traditional, effective, and skin-friendly soap at a reasonable cost.

The Art of Shaving Shaving Soap is designed especially for sensitive skin, featuring a formula free from synthetic dyes and alcohol, which helps reduce irritation and razor burn. It contains sandalwood essential oil, a classic scent appreciated for its warm and woody aroma, although the specs list the scent as coconut, which could cause some confusion. The soap is known for its protective qualities, making it a good option for those prone to skin sensitivity during shaving. It generally produces a rich lather that cushions the skin well, though some users might find it less quick to lather compared to softer soaps.

The moisturizing properties are decent thanks to the natural oils, helping to leave skin feeling smoother after shaving. The 3.3-ounce size offers a moderate amount that should last a fair while when used with a shaving brush and bowl. Price-wise, it tends to be on the higher side, reflecting its premium branding and quality ingredients, so it may be better suited for those willing to invest a bit more in their shaving routine. For those seeking a soap that focuses on gentle care and a traditional sandalwood scent without irritating additives, this product fits the bill well.

Proraso Shaving Soap is a solid choice for anyone seeking a reliable and effective product for their shaving routine. One of its standout features is the quality of the lather. It produces a rich and creamy foam that helps the razor glide smoothly, reducing the chances of irritation. The soap is easy to lather, making it suitable even for beginners or those who prefer a quick shave. With a scent of eucalyptus, it offers a refreshing aroma without being overpowering, which many users appreciate.

In terms of ingredients, Proraso has updated its formulation to be paraben-free, catering to those who are mindful of what they apply to their skin. Its moisturizing properties are also commendable; it leaves the skin feeling hydrated after shaving, which is a big plus for those with sensitive skin.

There are a couple of drawbacks to consider. While the 5.2 oz bar may seem adequate, some users might find it runs out quicker than expected, especially if used frequently. Additionally, although the scent is generally well-received, personal preferences vary; those who prefer unscented products may want to explore other options. Proraso Shaving Soap is competitively priced for a quality product, making it accessible to a wide range of consumers. It is a great option for those looking for a dependable shaving soap that balances performance and affordability. Whether you're a newcomer to wet shaving or an experienced shaver, Proraso could fit nicely into your grooming routine.