10 Best Shortbread Cookies 2025 in the United States

Walker's Shortbread Rounds are a classic choice for anyone seeking a traditional Scottish shortbread experience. Made with pure butter, these cookies boast a melt-in-the-mouth texture and a rich, buttery flavor that is hard to beat. The simplicity of the ingredients aligns well with those who prefer natural, high-quality treats, free from artificial additives.

The packaging is practical with a 5.3 Oz box in a pack of 4, making it convenient for sharing or gifting, although the exact packaging design may vary, which could be a minor inconvenience for some. Walkers is a well-established brand with a strong reputation for quality, providing added confidence in the purchase. However, the 21.2-ounce unit count might be more than casual snackers need, potentially making it a bit costly for those only looking for a small treat.

Perfect for special occasions or an everyday indulgence, Walkers Shortbread Rounds stand out in flavor and heritage but may not suit everyone’s quantity needs or texture preferences.

Walker’s All-Butter Shortbread Fingers are a well-regarded treat from Scotland, known for their high-quality ingredients and rich, buttery flavor. The use of simple, all-butter ingredients makes them vegetarian friendly and adheres to kosher standards, which can appeal to a wide range of dietary preferences. The texture is typically crisp and crumbly, a hallmark of traditional shortbread that many find delightful when paired with tea or coffee.

Each pack includes 24 individually wrapped 2-count snack packs, making them convenient for on-the-go snacking or portion control. The sturdy packaging also ensures freshness and prevents the cookies from breaking easily during transit or storage. However, these cookies may not appeal to those who prefer less buttery or healthier snack options, as they are quite rich and indulgent.

The brand, Walkers, is known for its long-standing reputation for quality shortbread, which can be a big plus for those seeking authentic Scottish cookies. Though the price point might be higher compared to generic brands, the quality and authenticity of Walker’s shortbread justify the cost for many. The product is not discontinued by the manufacturer and remains a popular choice among shortbread enthusiasts.

The Kirkland Signature Walkers Premium Shortbread Selection Gift Tin is a great choice for anyone who enjoys classic shortbread cookies. Made by Walkers, a well-known Scottish brand with a long history since 1898, it offers a reassuring level of quality and tradition. The selection includes chunky shortbread in ovals, rounds, and triangles, plus the traditional fingers, all with a rich full butter flavor that shortbread lovers appreciate. The texture is pleasingly crunchy while still maintaining that classic crumbly softness you expect from good shortbread.

It does contain milk, gluten, and wheat, so it’s not suitable if you have allergies or dietary restrictions related to these ingredients. The packaging as a gift tin makes it appealing for sharing or special occasions, keeping the cookies fresh and nicely presented. The weight of 2.73 pounds means you get plenty to enjoy.

This shortbread tin suits those looking for authentic, buttery Scottish shortbread in a convenient and attractive package.