10 Best Soft Eyeliner Pencil 2025 in the United States

The Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner in Black Violet stands out for its longwearing and waterproof formula, promising up to 24 hours of smudge-proof wear. This makes it an excellent choice for those who need their makeup to last throughout the day without touch-ups. The texture is smooth and creamy, ensuring a comfortable application that glides effortlessly along the eyelid.

Additionally, the built-in sharpener and smudger add convenience, making it easy to achieve precise lines or a smoky, blended look depending on your preference. With 14 intense shades available, there's plenty of variety for different styles and preferences.

However, some users might find the pigmentation to be slightly less intense compared to liquid eyeliners. Also, while the waterproof feature is beneficial for longevity, it could be challenging to remove without a good makeup remover. Those with sensitive eyes or skin might want to check the ingredients list to ensure there are no irritants. This eyeliner is a versatile and practical option for anyone looking for a reliable, everyday makeup staple.

The Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil in Perversion (blackest black matte) stands out for its award-winning formula that delivers intense, long-lasting color. Its ultra-creamy texture ensures smooth application, preventing any dragging or pulling on the delicate eye area, which is great for achieving precise lines or blended looks. The pencil's high pigmentation means you get a bold, defined color with just one swipe, which is ideal for dramatic eye makeup looks.

Longevity is another strong point, with the eyeliner promising to stay put for up to 16 hours without smudging or transferring, making it suitable for long wear throughout the day or night. The product is also hydrating, enriched with vitamin E, jojoba oil, and cottonseed oil, which not only condition the skin but also keep the lash line moisturized, preventing dryness and irritation. Additionally, the eyeliner is cruelty-free, which is a significant plus for ethically-conscious consumers.

However, one potential drawback is the pencil form, which might require frequent sharpening to maintain a precise tip, which can be a bit inconvenient for some users. While its creamy formula is advantageous for blendability, it may also make the pencil more prone to breaking if too much pressure is applied during application. Users looking for a versatile eyeliner that can double as an eyeshadow or base will find this product particularly beneficial. This eyeliner is best suited for those who value intense pigmentation, long-lasting wear, and hydrating ingredients in their eye makeup products.

The Clinique Quickliner For Eyes in Smoky Brown is a user-friendly, automatic eyeliner pencil that doesn't require sharpening. It promises a smooth application with a smudge-resistant and water-resistant formula, making it a reliable choice for long-lasting wear. The pigmentation is rich, allowing for versatile eye looks, whether you want a bold or subtle finish.

The silky texture makes it easy to blend, enhancing its versatility for different styles, from precise lines to smoky eyes. This eyeliner is particularly suited for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, thanks to its ophthalmologist-tested and allergy-tested formula. It's also 100% fragrance-free, adhering to Clinique's dermatological standards for safety and inclusivity of all skin types and tones.

While its luminous finish might appeal to many, it may not be the best choice for those who prefer a matte look. Additionally, the product dimensions and lightweight nature make it convenient to carry, but it might seem a bit small to some users. In summary, this eyeliner is ideal for users looking for a dependable, easy-to-apply pencil with good pigmentation and blendability, especially those with sensitive eyes or who wear contact lenses.