We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

10 Best Softball Catchers Mitts 2025 in the United States

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

headphones-stars

Our Top Picks

#1

Winner

Rawlings | LIBERTY ADVANCED Fastpitch Softball Catchers Glove | 34" | Pro H Web | Right Hand Throw

Rating
10.0
Chosen by1,227
Break-in Time

Most important from
1214 reviews

Break-in Time
The glove is beautifully made and fits perfectly, though it does require some breaking in.

The Rawlings Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Catchers Mitt is a solid choice for those looking for a reliable and well-crafted glove designed specifically for catchers. At 34 inches, this mitt offers ample coverage and protection, making it suitable for players who need to handle fast pitches effectively. The use of quality full-grain leather adds to its durability while ensuring a comfortable fit. The pull-strap closures are a thoughtful feature, allowing players to customize the fit to their hand, which is crucial for performance behind the plate.

One of the standout features is its quick break-in time, with a unique 70% factory and 30% player break-in ratio. This allows players to enjoy a game-ready feel right away, which is often a pain point for many catchers who have to deal with stiff gloves initially.

However, there are some considerations to keep in mind. The mitt is designed for right-hand throwers, which limits its use for left-handed players. Additionally, while the leather is durable, some users may prefer a mitt with more advanced padding for additional impact protection, especially during intense games.

Rating
10.0
Chosen by1,227
Break-in Time

Most important from
1214 reviews

Break-in Time
The glove is beautifully made and fits perfectly, though it does require some breaking in.
#2

Rawlings | Liberty Advanced ColorSync Fastpitch Softball Glove | Right Hand Throw | 34" | Catcher | Modified Pro H Web | White/Purple/Gold

The Rawlings Liberty Advanced ColorSync Fastpitch Softball Glove is tailored for fastpitch softball catchers, particularly female athletes. With its 34-inch size, it's designed to offer ample catchability, fitting well for adult users who prioritize a comprehensive reach. The glove is constructed from high-quality full-grain leather, promising both a soft feel and durable longevity. This material choice is excellent for those who value a glove that can withstand rigorous use over time.

A standout feature is the Poron XRD Padding, which provides significant impact protection. This padding is particularly beneficial in reducing sting from fast pitches, a crucial factor for catchers who face frequent high-speed impacts. The Modified Pro H Web design is favored for its balance between flexibility and stability, making it a suitable choice for those needing a reliable catch-and-release action.

The glove comes in a vibrant color scheme of white, purple, and gold, which adds a stylish touch, appealing to players who enjoy personalization. The adjustable pull strap is a practical addition, allowing for a customizable and snug fit, enhancing performance and comfort. However, a potential drawback is the break-in time typically associated with leather gloves, which might require some patience and effort before reaching optimal performance. This aspect could be a consideration for users seeking a glove that is game-ready out of the box. Additionally, it’s important to note the glove is designed for right-hand throwers only, which limits its accessibility for left-handed players.

In essence, the Rawlings Liberty Advanced ColorSync glove is an excellent option for female softball catchers looking for durability, protection, and style. Its features align well with the demands of fastpitch softball, though users should be prepared for a break-in period to fully enjoy its benefits.

#3

Easton | GHOST NX Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt | 34" | H-Web | Right Hand Throw

Rating
9.9
Size
Material
Break-in Time

Most important from
112 reviews

Size
Great quality glove, fits perfectly, easy to break in, comfortable, and holding up well.
Material
Perfect fit and comfort, excellent glove for the cost, and the leather quality is impressive.
Break-in Time
Great quality glove, fits perfectly, easy to break in, comfortable, and holding up well.

The Easton GHOST NX Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt is designed specifically for the fastpitch softball game, making it a great fit for players seeking a reliable catcher’s mitt. One of its standout features is the size—34 inches—ideal for adult female players, particularly those with smaller hands. The mitt is made from high-quality Diamond Pro Steer USA Leather, which not only contributes to its durability but also enhances playability. The Flex Notch Closure system allows for easy squeezing, making it accessible for quick plays.

Another strength is the Quantum Closure System, which provides an adjustable back for a secure fit, ensuring comfort during extended use. Additionally, the rolled leather welting helps retain the glove's shape and reduces the break-in time, which is a significant advantage for players eager to get on the field right away.

The mitt is specifically designed for right-hand throwers, which might limit options for left-handed players. The Easton GHOST NX is a solid choice for adult female fastpitch players looking for a durable, comfortable, and easy-to-use catcher’s mitt. It balances quality materials with thoughtful design features, though the break-in period and right-hand orientation might not suit everyone’s needs.

Rating
9.9
Size
Material
Break-in Time

Most important from
112 reviews

Size
Great quality glove, fits perfectly, easy to break in, comfortable, and holding up well.
Material
Perfect fit and comfort, excellent glove for the cost, and the leather quality is impressive.
Break-in Time
Great quality glove, fits perfectly, easy to break in, comfortable, and holding up well.

Buying Guide for the Best Softball Catchers Mitts

Choosing the right softball catcher's mitt is crucial for any player behind the plate. A good mitt can enhance your performance, provide better protection, and make catching more comfortable. When selecting a mitt, consider factors such as size, material, webbing, padding, and break-in time. Understanding these key specifications will help you find the best fit for your needs and playing style.
SizeThe size of a catcher's mitt is measured in inches and refers to the circumference of the mitt. This spec is important because it affects your ability to catch and control the ball. Mitts typically range from 32 to 34 inches. Smaller mitts (32-33 inches) offer better control and are suitable for younger players or those with smaller hands. Larger mitts (33-34 inches) provide a bigger target and are ideal for more experienced players or those with larger hands. Choose a size that feels comfortable and allows you to catch the ball effectively.
MaterialCatchers' mitts are usually made from leather, which can vary in quality. This spec is important because it affects the durability and feel of the mitt. Full-grain leather is the highest quality and offers the best durability and performance, but it requires a longer break-in period. Steerhide leather is also durable and offers a good balance between performance and break-in time. Synthetic materials are less durable but require minimal break-in time and are often more affordable. Choose a material that matches your level of play and how often you play.
WebbingThe webbing of a catcher's mitt is the part that connects the thumb and fingers, forming a pocket to catch the ball. This spec is important because it affects the mitt's flexibility and ability to secure the ball. Closed webbing provides more support and is better for catching fast pitches, while open webbing offers more flexibility and is easier to break in. Choose a webbing style that suits your playing style and the type of pitches you typically catch.
PaddingPadding in a catcher's mitt is crucial for protecting your hand from the impact of fast pitches. This spec is important because it affects your comfort and ability to catch the ball without injury. Mitts with more padding offer better protection but may feel bulkier and take longer to break in. Mitts with less padding are lighter and easier to maneuver but provide less protection. Choose a level of padding that balances protection and comfort based on the speed of pitches you catch and your personal preference.
Break-in TimeBreak-in time refers to the period it takes for a new mitt to become flexible and comfortable to use. This spec is important because it affects how quickly you can start using the mitt effectively. Mitts made from higher-quality leather typically require a longer break-in time but offer better performance and durability once broken in. Synthetic mitts require minimal break-in time but may not last as long. Choose a mitt with a break-in time that fits your schedule and how soon you need to use it in games.

FAQ

Most Popular Categories Right Now