10 Best Softball Gloves 2025 in the United States

The Rawlings PLAYER PREFERRED Softball Glove is designed primarily for recreational use in baseball and slowpitch softball, making it a great choice for casual players. With a size of 14 inches and a basket web style, this glove offers versatility across different positions, although it is best suited for outfield play. Made from full grain leather, it promises durability, which is a significant plus for those who want a long-lasting glove. The zero shock palm padding is a standout feature, providing excellent impact protection and comfort when catching. This is particularly beneficial for those who may be prone to hand fatigue during play.

One of the glove's strengths is its game-ready feel, which means it comes mostly broken in, allowing players to use it right away with minimal additional effort. The adjustable wrist strap is another highlight, enabling a more personalized fit for different hand sizes, enhancing overall comfort during games.

The Rawlings PLAYER PREFERRED Glove stands out for amateur usage with its durable construction and comfort features. It's ideal for those looking for a reliable glove without breaking the bank.

The Rawlings LIBERTY ADVANCED Fastpitch Softball Glove, with its 12.5-inch size and basket web design, is versatile for use by pitchers, infield, and outfield players. This makes it a solid choice for utility players who need flexibility on the field. Crafted from quality full-grain leather, the glove promises durability and a comfortable feel, enhanced by its leather lining. The 70% factory break-in means it requires less player effort to make it game-ready, adding convenience for avid players ranging from high school to professional levels.

The pull strap closures are a thoughtful feature, allowing users to adjust and achieve a snug fit, ensuring comfort during play. The glove is designed for right-hand throwers, which means it is worn on the left hand. Endorsed by Team USA player Keilani Ricketts, this glove has credibility in performance circles. The 30% player break-in still required might not suit those looking for an immediately game-ready glove. Its 12.5-inch size may be less ideal for players who prefer a glove specifically tailored for infield or outfield positions.

This glove is particularly suited for dedicated softball players who demand quality and adaptability in their gear.

The Rawlings Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Catchers Glove is specifically designed for catchers, making it a great choice for players who take on that role in the game. Its 34-inch size and right-hand throw orientation cater perfectly to those looking for a reliable mitt. One of the standout features is the use of quality full-grain leather, which not only enhances durability but also ensures a comfortable feel when catching. The glove also includes pull-strap closures, allowing players to customize the fit for maximum comfort and security while playing.

A significant advantage of this glove is its quick break-in period, combining 70% factory and 30% player break-in. This means players can expect a game-ready feel much sooner than with many other gloves. There are a few potential drawbacks; while the glove is designed for optimal performance, those with larger hands may find the fit a bit snug, even when adjusted. Additionally, as it’s specifically a catcher's glove, it may not be suitable for players who play multiple positions, as its design caters exclusively to catching.

The Rawlings Liberty Advanced glove is an excellent choice for fastpitch softball catchers who prioritize comfort, fit, and durability. Its excellent break-in time and protective features make it appealing, while its specific design may limit its use for players who switch positions frequently.