10 Best Softest Toilet Paper 2025 in the United States

Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper offers a large quantity with 12 mega rolls, each containing 425 sheets, which is about 30% more than typical rolls—great if you want to stock up and avoid frequent replacements. It is 1-ply, which means it’s a single layer of paper. Scott claims this product is 3 times thicker and 4 times stronger than other value brands in the same category, aiming to balance strength and softness.

The material is wood pulp and biodegradable, which is good for the environment and safe for septic systems. It’s unscented, making it suitable for those sensitive to fragrances. The brand emphasizes comfort and strength, suggesting a smooth feel without roughness, though it might feel thinner compared to very plush or multi-ply options. The sheets are standard size, and the product is designed to dissolve quickly in water to prevent clogging.

This toilet paper is ideal for people looking for a budget-friendly, reliable, and septic-safe option that still offers decent softness, while it may not fully satisfy anyone seeking the softest or thickest tissue available.

Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper is designed for those who prioritize softness and tissue quality. With 3-ply construction, it boasts three cushiony-soft layers, making it thicker and more absorbent than many other brands. This makes it ideal for people who prefer a luxurious feel and high-performance toilet paper.

The unscented and fragrance-free nature of this toilet paper also ensures it is gentle on sensitive skin, free from any irritants like inks or dyes. Each Mega Roll contains 255 sheets, translating to less frequent roll changes, which is convenient for busy households.

However, the increased thickness may mean it takes up more space on the holder, and some users might find it a bit too bulky. Additionally, premium features often come with a higher price tag, so budget-conscious buyers might find this product a bit expensive compared to other options. This toilet paper is a good choice for anyone looking for an indulgent, high-quality bathroom tissue that combines softness with strong absorption.

The Cottonelle Ultra Clean Toilet Paper offers 32 Family Mega Rolls, which is equivalent to 176 regular rolls, making it a very economical choice. Each roll contains 353 sheets, giving you a generous amount of paper per roll. The 1-ply rating means it is a single layer toilet paper, but it is designed to be 3 times thicker and stronger than leading value brands, so it still provides good durability and performance.

The unique CleaningRipples texture is a standout feature, helping to enhance cleaning efficiency and making it suitable for sensitive skin. Being unscented and free of added perfumes and dyes, it’s a good option for those with sensitive noses or skin allergies. Additionally, it's FSC certified and made from 100% plant-based fibers, supporting sustainable practices.

The 1-ply nature might not provide the same softness as multi-ply options, which could be a drawback for those seeking the softest experience. Despite this, its cleaning capability and thickness might compensate for the lack of extra layers. The paper is also septic safe, helping to avoid clogging issues. This toilet paper is best suited for households wanting a balance between strength, sustainability, and cost-efficiency.