10 Best Trolling Reels 2025 in the United States

The Okuma Cold Water Linecounter Trolling Reel CW-453D is a solid choice for those in need of a reliable trolling reel. One of its standout strengths is its lightweight and corrosion-resistant frame and sideplates, making it durable and convenient for use in various fishing conditions. The multi-disc, carbonite drag system offers smooth and consistent drag, which is crucial for controlling and reeling in big catches.

The aluminum handle arm with Ergo grip handle knobs provides comfort and ease of use, especially during prolonged fishing sessions. Additionally, the line counter feature is very useful for precise line management, which is essential in trolling to ensure bait is placed at the correct depth. At 617 grams, the reel is moderately heavy, which might be an issue for those preferring lighter gear. Despite these minor drawbacks, the reel's build quality, advanced features, and the anti-reverse feature ensure that your line doesn't slip, providing additional reliability.

This reel is particularly beneficial for those who enjoy an outdoor lifestyle and engage in various fishing techniques, especially trolling.

The Okuma Cold Water Linecounter Trolling Reel CW-303D is built with high-quality, corrosion-resistant materials, making it durable and lightweight. Its frame and side plates resist rust, which is crucial for performance in saltwater environments. The reel features a multi-disc Carbonite drag system, which ensures smooth and precise control over drag settings, ideal for handling large fish. Additionally, the ratcheting drag star allows for fine-tuning the drag, which provides more accurate adjustments when needed.

The XL gearing and self-lubricating gear system enhance the reel's reliability and longevity, ensuring it maintains performance even with frequent use. The reel's construction material is composite, which combines strength and lightness, beneficial for extended fishing trips. One downside is that the reel supports only right-hand orientation, which could be a limitation for left-handed users. At 567 grams, it’s relatively lightweight, but some might find it slightly on the heavier side for continuous usage.

The line counter feature is practical for tracking how much line is out, aiding in better control and precision. With a maximum drag of 20 pounds, it’s well-suited for medium to large fish. The one-year warranty offers some peace of mind, though it’s on the shorter side compared to other products. Its gear ratio is not explicitly stated, but the emphasis on XL gearing suggests it is designed for efficient retrieval. This trolling reel is best for anglers looking for a durable, reliable option for both freshwater and saltwater fishing.

The PENN Squall II Level Wind Conventional Fishing Reel is a solid choice for anglers looking for a reliable and well-constructed reel. One of its standout features is the lightweight graphite frame and side plates, making it easier to handle during long fishing trips. The 3+1 shielded stainless steel ball bearings ensure smooth operation, which is essential for a seamless fishing experience. Additionally, the HT-100 carbon fiber drag washers provide a strong drag system with a maximum drag of 33 pounds, enabling you to tackle larger fish with confidence.

The reel also boasts a fast gear access side plate, which simplifies maintenance—a great feature for those who want to keep their gear in top condition. The ambidextrous handle design accommodates both left and right-handed users, enhancing versatility.

Some users might find the line capacity somewhat limited, especially when compared to larger models. The gear ratio, although decent, may not suit everyone’s fishing style, particularly those who prefer faster retrieves. Additionally, while the construction is robust, the graphite material, while lightweight, may not be as durable as full metal options in very rough conditions. The PENN Squall II is ideal for casual to intermediate anglers who enjoy spinning techniques and are looking for a dependable reel without breaking the bank.