10 Best True Crime Audiobooks 2025 in the United States

'If You Tell: A True Story of Murder, Family Secrets, and the Unbreakable Bond of Sisterhood' by Gregg Olsen is a gripping true-crime audiobook. Narrated by Karen Peakes, the audiobook runs for 10 hours and 34 minutes, providing a substantial amount of content for listeners who enjoy deep dives into real-life crime stories.

Karen Peakes' narration is clear and engaging, making it easier for listeners to follow the complex and often disturbing storyline. Gregg Olsen, a well-known author in the true-crime genre, delivers a compelling narrative that keeps the audience hooked from start to finish. The story itself is intricate, exploring dark family secrets and the strong bond between sisters amidst horrifying circumstances.

The production quality is high, with clear audio and professional editing, ensuring a smooth listening experience. However, it's important to note that the content is quite sensitive, dealing with themes of murder and family trauma, which might be distressing for some listeners. This audiobook is well-suited for true-crime enthusiasts who appreciate detailed and emotionally intense stories. While it may not be suitable for those who are sensitive to graphic content, it stands out as a top choice for its high-quality production, compelling narration, and intricate storytelling.

The Most Bizarre True Crime Stories Ever Told is an audiobook that will likely cater to enthusiasts of the true-crime genre. Narrated by Moose Warywoda, the audiobook offers a 4 hour and 30 minute journey through 20 twisted and unforgettable true crime cases. The narration by Warywoda is engaging and brings the chilling stories to life, making it a captivating listen.

Author Jack Rosewood, known for his extensive work in true crime, provides well-researched and detailed accounts, adding to the audiobook’s credibility and allure. The production quality is solid, with clear audio and a professional finish, ensuring an immersive experience for the listener. However, given the nature of the content, it includes sensitive and potentially disturbing material, which may not be suitable for all audiences.

Those with a strong interest in serial killers and criminal biographies will find this collection particularly compelling, as evidenced by its rankings in these categories. One potential drawback is the relatively short length, which might leave some listeners wanting more depth and detail in the stories. Nonetheless, it serves as a concise and intriguing introduction to some of the most bizarre and haunting true crime stories ever recorded.

One Lost Soul is a British detective crime thriller and the first book in The Hidden Norfolk Murder Mystery Series by J.M. Dalgliesh. The audiobook promises a chilling story set in Norfolk, England, which will likely appeal to fans of British crime fiction. The narrative complexity seems well-suited for those who enjoy intricate plot lines and character development.

The author, J.M. Dalgliesh, is known for writing compelling crime stories, adding credibility and expectations for quality storytelling. The production quality is expected to be high, given the publication by Hamilton Press and the enabling of enhanced typesetting, Word Wise, and X-Ray features, which indicate attention to detail and a good listening experience.

The length of the book, at 259 pages, suggests a moderate listening time, which should be manageable for most listeners. Content sensitivity isn't explicitly mentioned, but given the genre, listeners should be prepared for typical crime thriller elements that might include violence or disturbing themes. One Lost Soul is likely a strong contender in the true-crime audiobook category, especially for those who are fans of British detective stories and well-crafted murder mysteries.