We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

2 Best Weber Grill Inserts 2025 in the United States

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

headphones-stars

Our Top Picks

#1

Winner

Weber Rust-Resistant Griddle Insert, Genesis 300 Series

Rating
9.7
Chosen by1,301
Material
Size and Compatibility
Cooking Surface

Most important from
447 reviews

Material
This griddle fits perfectly and is made well. The thick metal holds heat and cooking on it is great.
Size and Compatibility
Exact fit for my Weber Genesis grill. It's a little heavy, but you get what you pay for. Great quality and it's not flimsy.
Cooking Surface
Works great for smashburgers, bacon, sautéing vegetables and whatever else you want to cook!
Heat Distribution
This griddle fits perfectly and is made well. The thick metal holds heat and cooking on it is great.
Ease of Cleaning
I still get some sticking, but it's gotten better over time with seasoning. A griddle scraper works great if the griddle is still hot.

The Weber Rust-Resistant Griddle Insert for the Genesis 300 Series is a versatile addition for those looking to expand their grill's capabilities. Constructed from durable carbon steel, this griddle insert is rust-resistant, ensuring longevity and consistent performance. Its pre-seasoned surface offers a natural non-stick experience right out of the box, eliminating the need for additional waxing or oiling before use. The griddle's design allows it to fit perfectly with 3-burner Genesis 2016+ and Summit 2024+ models, making it highly compatible with modern Weber grills.

One of its standout features is the even heat distribution across the entire cooking surface, which helps in cooking food uniformly. Additionally, the thick material helps in preventing warping, a common issue with thinner griddle surfaces. The rear grease slot is a thoughtful inclusion, directing grease into the grill’s grease management system and making cleanup easier. However, it is worth noting that this griddle is not dishwasher safe, which might be a drawback for those looking for minimal maintenance.

The absence of a nonstick coating means you can freely use metal tools without worrying about damaging the surface, but it might require more effort to clean manually. Weighing in at 30.6 pounds, it's relatively heavy, which can be a consideration if you frequently move or store your grill accessories. If you own a compatible Weber grill and seek a robust, easy-to-use griddle insert that ensures even cooking and durability, the Weber Rust-Resistant Griddle Insert is a solid choice. Just be prepared for a bit of manual cleaning post-cooking.

Rating
9.7
Chosen by1,301
Material
Size and Compatibility
Cooking Surface

Most important from
447 reviews

Material
This griddle fits perfectly and is made well. The thick metal holds heat and cooking on it is great.
Size and Compatibility
Exact fit for my Weber Genesis grill. It's a little heavy, but you get what you pay for. Great quality and it's not flimsy.
Cooking Surface
Works great for smashburgers, bacon, sautéing vegetables and whatever else you want to cook!
Heat Distribution
This griddle fits perfectly and is made well. The thick metal holds heat and cooking on it is great.
Ease of Cleaning
I still get some sticking, but it's gotten better over time with seasoning. A griddle scraper works great if the griddle is still hot.
#2

Weber Gourmet BBQ System Hinged Cooking Grate

Rating
9.4
Material
Size and Compatibility
Cooking Surface

Most important from
3084 reviews

Material
This replacement grill is strong, steady, and matches the original Gourmet BBQ System design perfectly.
Size and Compatibility
The grate fits flawlessly on 22-1/2-inch Weber charcoal grills and maintains reliable heat distribution.
Cooking Surface
The hinged grate design allows for easy addition of charcoal without removing the cooking surface, enhancing grilling convenience.
Heat Distribution
The grate fits flawlessly on 22-1/2-inch Weber charcoal grills and maintains reliable heat distribution.
Ease of Cleaning
Cleaning requires caution as the center insert can flip or fall into the coals, posing a serious burn risk without long grill mitts.

The Weber Gourmet BBQ System Hinged Cooking Grate is designed to fit 22-1/2-inch Weber charcoal grills and is made from plated steel with a stainless steel frame and handle, which offers decent durability and a clean look. Its hinged design is a standout feature, allowing you to add more charcoal without removing the grate, making it convenient to manage heat while cooking. The 12-inch cooking surface insert is compatible with various Gourmet BBQ System accessories like the griddle, wok, and sear grate, giving you flexibility for different cooking styles. Heat distribution is generally reliable thanks to the solid construction, helping you achieve even grilling results.

In terms of cleaning, the plated steel finish and hinged mechanism may require a bit more attention to keep free of grease and charcoal debris, but the design still makes access easier than some fixed grates. This grate is a great choice for outdoor cooking enthusiasts who want versatility and easier charcoal handling on Weber grills. If you’re looking for a larger cooking surface or a grate made of higher-end materials like cast iron, this plated steel insert might feel a bit basic. Additionally, it’s currently only shipped within the U.S., which could limit availability for some buyers.

Rating
9.4
Material
Size and Compatibility
Cooking Surface

Most important from
3084 reviews

Material
This replacement grill is strong, steady, and matches the original Gourmet BBQ System design perfectly.
Size and Compatibility
The grate fits flawlessly on 22-1/2-inch Weber charcoal grills and maintains reliable heat distribution.
Cooking Surface
The hinged grate design allows for easy addition of charcoal without removing the cooking surface, enhancing grilling convenience.
Heat Distribution
The grate fits flawlessly on 22-1/2-inch Weber charcoal grills and maintains reliable heat distribution.
Ease of Cleaning
Cleaning requires caution as the center insert can flip or fall into the coals, posing a serious burn risk without long grill mitts.

Buying Guide for the Best Weber Grill Inserts

When it comes to picking the right Weber grill insert, it's important to consider your specific grilling needs and preferences. Grill inserts can enhance your cooking experience by providing additional functionality and improving the quality of your food. To make an informed decision, you should understand the key specifications and how they align with your grilling habits. Here are some important factors to consider when choosing a Weber grill insert.
MaterialThe material of the grill insert is crucial because it affects durability, heat retention, and ease of cleaning. Common materials include stainless steel, cast iron, and porcelain-coated steel. Stainless steel is rust-resistant and easy to clean, making it a good choice for those who grill frequently. Cast iron retains heat well and provides excellent searing, but it requires more maintenance to prevent rust. Porcelain-coated steel offers a balance between durability and ease of cleaning. Choose a material based on how often you grill and your willingness to maintain the insert.
Size and CompatibilitySize and compatibility are important to ensure that the grill insert fits your specific Weber grill model. Measure your grill's cooking area and compare it with the dimensions of the insert. Inserts that are too large or too small can affect cooking performance and safety. Weber typically provides compatibility information for their inserts, so check the product details to ensure a proper fit. If you have a smaller grill, opt for a compact insert, while larger grills can accommodate bigger inserts with more cooking surface.
Cooking SurfaceThe cooking surface of the grill insert determines how much food you can cook at once and the type of cooking you can do. Some inserts have a flat surface, while others have grates or ridges. Flat surfaces are great for cooking delicate items like fish or vegetables, while grates and ridges are ideal for searing meats and creating grill marks. Consider what types of food you typically grill and choose an insert with a cooking surface that matches your needs. If you enjoy a variety of foods, look for an insert with interchangeable surfaces.
Heat DistributionHeat distribution is important for even cooking and preventing hot spots. High-quality grill inserts are designed to distribute heat evenly across the cooking surface. Look for inserts with features like heat diffusers or multiple layers of material that promote even heat distribution. If you often cook large cuts of meat or multiple items at once, an insert with good heat distribution will ensure consistent results. Pay attention to user reviews and product descriptions to gauge the heat distribution performance of the insert.
Ease of CleaningEase of cleaning is a key factor, especially if you grill frequently. Some materials and designs are easier to clean than others. Stainless steel and porcelain-coated inserts are generally easier to clean because food particles and grease don't stick as much. Cast iron requires more effort to clean and maintain, but it can be seasoned to create a non-stick surface. Consider how much time you're willing to spend on cleaning and choose an insert that aligns with your preferences. Removable and dishwasher-safe inserts can also simplify the cleaning process.

FAQ

Most Popular Categories Right Now