10 Best Youth Catchers Gloves 2025 in the United States

The Rawlings Select Pro Lite Adley Rutschman Youth Catcher’s Mitt is designed specifically for young players stepping into the catcher role. At 32 inches, the glove offers a good size for youth catchers, providing enough coverage for catching pitches effectively. Made from leather, it promises durability and a quality feel, which is important for a position that demands frequent catching and impact absorption. Its solid black webbing offers stable pocket control, essential for securing the ball.

One of the glove's standout features is its lightweight design, making it easier for kids to open and close the mitt without excessive strain. This is complemented by the Youth Pro Taper fit, which includes a smaller hand opening and lowered finger stalls to better fit smaller hands and offer improved comfort. The glove also comes mostly broken in (90% factory, 10% player break-in), meaning it’s ready to use quickly, reducing the usual stiff feel new gloves have. The solid web might limit airflow compared to open web styles, which could affect hand ventilation on hot days. Additionally, the catcher's mitt is tailored for right-hand throwers only, so left-handed throwers will need to look elsewhere.

This mitt is a great choice for youth baseball players who are serious about learning the catcher position. It balances comfort, fit, and performance well, especially for players transitioning from beginner to more competitive play. Its pro-inspired design and quality materials offer a feel that can motivate young players while supporting their development on the field.

The Rawlings PLAYER PREFERRED Baseball Catcher's Mitt is a well-regarded option for recreational baseball and slowpitch softball. Sized at 33 inches, this glove is designed for adult use but could be suitable for older youth players transitioning to adult-sized equipment. The one-piece solid web design is traditional for catcher's mitts, providing stability and secure catches.

Made from full-grain leather, the glove offers durability and can withstand the rigors of regular play. However, it is noted to have a synthetic leather lining, which may not be as breathable as full leather. The Zero Shock Palm Padding is a significant advantage, offering extra protection against impact, which is crucial for catchers. The adjustable wrist strap allows for a customizable fit, enhancing comfort during use.

The glove comes with an 80% factory break-in, meaning it requires minimal effort to be game-ready, which is convenient for players who prefer not to spend a lot of time breaking in their mitt. Younger players or those with smaller hands might find the 33-inch size too large. For youth catchers, this mitt is best suited for those nearing adult sizes or those looking for a durable and protective glove for recreational play.

The Rawlings Sandlot Baseball Catcher's Mitt is a solid choice for young players looking to enhance their catching skills. With a 33-inch size and right-hand throw orientation, this mitt is designed for youth and adult players alike. One of its standout features is the full-grain oiled shell leather, which offers impressive durability, ensuring it can withstand regular use. The zero shock palm pads provide excellent protection, making it a safe option for catching fast pitches, while the padded finger back linings contribute to comfort during play, allowing for longer practice sessions without discomfort.

One significant advantage is that the glove arrives 80% broken-in, which means players can start using it right away without the long break-in period typical of new mitts. This is great for youth players who may be eager to jump into the game. The 1-piece solid web design helps with visibility and grip, facilitating better control when catching.

There are a few drawbacks to consider. For those with smaller hands, the 33-inch size might feel a bit bulky, potentially making it challenging for younger players to maneuver. Also, while the glove is well-padded, some users might prefer a lighter option for speed and agility, especially in fast-paced games. Lastly, the right-hand throw orientation limits the mitt's usability for left-handed players, which could be a concern for families with multiple children of varying skill levels.